10 Best Bagel Toppings for Irresistible Flavor

What are the best bagel toppings to make every bite unforgettable?
I’ll share my favorite tried-and-true combinations that have turned simple bagels into mouthwatering moments for me.

A warm, fresh bagel is pure joy. The right topping can turn it into something unforgettable. I’ve tried countless blends to find the ones that truly shine.

I still remember the first time I sprinkled everything seasoning over cream cheese—it was magic. Let me guide you to the best bagel toppings so every bite is perfect.

List of Top 10 Bagel Toppings

Title	Best For	Price
Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend Original XL 10 Ounce Jar. Delicious Blend of Sea Salt and Spices Dried Minced Garlic & Onion Flakes. Bagel Allspice, Sesame Seasoning Spice Shakerac	This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor in every bite. Great for anyone who enjoys easy, tasty meals with a mix of garlic, onion, and crunchy seeds.	View on Amazon
365 by Whole Foods Market, Everything Bagel Seasoning, 2.85 Ounce	This Everything Bagel Seasoning is perfect for anyone who loves flavorful and easy toppings. It’s great for bagels, avocado toast, and eggs. The shaker jar makes it simple to use and add flavor to your meals.	View on Amazon
The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend – 4.6 oz Shaker Jar – Premium Everything Seasoning for Bagels – Gourmet PALEO and KETO Approved Spice – The Perfect Everything Bagel Spice – 7079	This spice is perfect for home cooks and food lovers who want big flavor with simple steps. It’s great for anyone who likes natural ingredients and easy meals.	View on Amazon
Birch & Meadow Everything Bagel Seasoning, 11.2 oz, Pre-Mixed Spices & Seeds, Crunchy Texture	This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor with a crunchy texture. It’s great for anyone who loves to sprinkle bold taste on snacks, veggies, or toast.	View on Amazon
King Arthur, Everything Bagel Topping, Certified Kosher, 8 Ounces	This is perfect for baking lovers and foodies who want to add a crunchy, savory flavor to their meals. It’s great for bagels, breads, eggs, and avocado toast.	View on Amazon
Crave Coarse Pretzel Salt 1.5 Pound Large Bag For Soft Pretzels – Premium All Natural Coarse Food Grade Topping – For Bagels & Breads too!	This salt is perfect for pretzel lovers, home bakers, and anyone who wants a crunchy, salty topping. It adds a bold taste to bagels, breads, and even sweet treats.	View on Amazon
Food to Live Everything Bagel Seasoning Mix, 8 Ounces – A Blend of White and Black Sesame Seeds, Minced Garlic, Onion, and Himalayan Pink Salt Flakes. Great as a Topping and Baking Ingredient	This mix is great for home cooks, bakers, and anyone who loves easy flavor. It’s perfect if you want a healthy, tasty topping for your meals.	View on Amazon
Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend with No Salt by It’s Delish, 5 Lbs Bulk Bag – Premium All Natural Bagel Spice Seasoning Mix Without Salt for Bagels, Buns, Bread, Salad Topping Seasonings for Food – USA Made, Salt-Free, Keto, Vegan, Kosher	This is perfect for anyone who wants big flavor without salt. It’s great for people who eat keto, vegan, or low-calorie meals.	View on Amazon
Bakers Club 8.5oz Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend – Authentic New York Style Spices for Bagels, Avocado Toast, Eggs, Pretzels, Popcorn, Hummus & More – Mix of Garlic, Onion, Sesame Seeds, Poppy, Salt	This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor in every bite. Great for home cooks and chefs who enjoy adding a savory twist to many dishes.	View on Amazon
Dependable Food Everything Bagel Mix – 5 Lb. Resealable Jug – Natural, Non-GMO, No Additives, Kosher – Versatile Spice Blend for Elevating Any Dish	This is perfect for home cooks and chefs who love adding bold, authentic flavor to many dishes. It’s great for anyone who wants a natural, versatile seasoning that works on almost anything.	View on Amazon

Detailed Reviews

Looking for the best bagel toppings? This guide shows you the top picks with bold flavor, great value, and trusted quality. Each blend is packed with crunchy seeds, savory spices, and easy-to-use jars or bags. Find your favorite and make every bite better.

1. Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend Original XL 10 Ounce Jar. Delicious Blend of Sea Salt and Spices Dried Minced Garlic & Onion Flakes. Bagel Allspice, Sesame Seasoning Spice Shakerac

Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend Original XL 10 Ounce Jar. Delicious Blend of Sea Salt and Spices Dried Minced Garlic & Onion Flakes. Bagel Allspice, Sesame Seasoning Spice Shakerac

This Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend comes in an extra large 10-ounce jar. It is packed with bold, fresh flavor.

It has toasted onion and garlic for rich taste. Italian sea salt adds a savory touch. Poppy seeds and sesame seeds give a nutty crunch.

The flip top cap has two pour sizes. You can shake a little or a lot. Perfect for bagels, eggs, salads, and more.

Pros	Cons
Extra large jar lasts a long time Flip top cap makes pouring easy Rich mix of seeds and spices Toasted onion and garlic add bold flavor Great for bagels, salads, and snacks	Large size may be hard to store in small kitchens Strong flavor can overpower light dishes Seeds may spill easily when pouring

Perfect For:

This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor in every bite. Great for anyone who enjoys easy, tasty meals with a mix of garlic, onion, and crunchy seeds.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

2. 365 by Whole Foods Market, Everything Bagel Seasoning, 2.85 Ounce

This everything bagel seasoning comes in a 2.85-ounce jar. It has sesame seeds, sea salt, garlic, onion, and poppy seeds. It is Non-GMO and Kosher certified.

Use it on bagels, avocado toast, or eggs. The shaker jar makes it easy to sprinkle.

Pros	Cons
Rich blend of seeds, salt, garlic, and onion Non-GMO and Kosher for trusted quality Perfect for bagels, toast, and eggs Easy to use with handy shaker jar Adds flavor fast to any snack or meal	Small jar runs out quickly Salt level may be too high for some Seeds can get stuck in teeth

Perfect For:

This Everything Bagel Seasoning is perfect for anyone who loves flavorful and easy toppings. It’s great for bagels, avocado toast, and eggs. The shaker jar makes it simple to use and add flavor to your meals.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

3. The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend – 4.6 oz Shaker Jar – Premium Everything Seasoning for Bagels – Gourmet PALEO and KETO Approved Spice – The Perfect Everything Bagel Spice – 7079

The Spice Lab Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend - 4.6 oz Shaker Jar - Premium Everything Seasoning for Bagels - Gourmet PALEO and KETO Approved Spice - The Perfect Everything Bagel Spice - 7079

This is a savory spice blend with a little crunch. It has Hudson Valley salt, chili flakes, and more. Use it to make food taste bold and fresh.

Sprinkle it on popcorn or eggs. Mix it into rice or baked dishes for extra flavor.

It’s made with natural ingredients and has no additives. The jar is easy to store and ready to use. It’s Kosher, non-GMO, and gluten-free.

Pros	Cons
Bold flavor with a hint of chili spice Made with natural, non-GMO, and gluten-free ingredients Adds a crunchy kick to eggs, popcorn, and more Great for home cooks and professional chefs Comes in a handy shaker for easy use	Chili flakes may be too spicy for some tastes Not ideal for recipes needing a mild flavor Crunchy salt pieces can feel too coarse in dishes

Perfect For:

This spice is perfect for home cooks and food lovers who want big flavor with simple steps. It’s great for anyone who likes natural ingredients and easy meals.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

4. Birch & Meadow Everything Bagel Seasoning, 11.2 oz, Pre-Mixed Spices & Seeds, Crunchy Texture

Add bold flavor and crunch to your meals with Birch & Meadow Everything Bagel Seasoning. This mix is packed with spices and seeds that taste great on many foods.

Sprinkle it on avocado toast or roasted vegetables. Use it to coat cheeseballs and other snacks. Share the tasty ingredients with family and friends.

Pros	Cons
Crunchy texture adds fun to snacks and meals Great for cheeseballs, dips, and easy appetizers Tastes amazing on avocado toast and veggies Made with simple ingredients you’ll love to share Proudly packaged in the USA for trusted quality	Large size may be too much for small kitchens Crunchy texture not ideal for all recipes Flavor mix might overpower mild dishes

Perfect For:

This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor with a crunchy texture. It’s great for anyone who loves to sprinkle bold taste on snacks, veggies, or toast.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

5. King Arthur, Everything Bagel Topping, Certified Kosher, 8 Ounces

This Everything Bagel Topping is full of flavor. It has poppy seeds, sesame seeds, dried onion, garlic, and salt. It comes in an 8-ounce reusable jar.

It is great on bagels, bread, and salt sticks. You can also mix it into doughs for extra taste.

Sprinkle it on eggs or avocado toast for a crunchy bite. The Certified Kosher blend is made by King Arthur, a trusted baking brand since 1790.

Pros	Cons
Adds flavor to bagels, bread, and more Crunchy mix of seeds, onion, and garlic Comes in a reusable and recyclable jar Certified Kosher for trusted quality From a trusted and long-standing baking brand	Jar size may run out quickly for heavy users Not ideal for those avoiding seeds or garlic Plastic jar may not suit zero-waste lifestyles

Perfect For:

This is perfect for baking lovers and foodies who want to add a crunchy, savory flavor to their meals. It’s great for bagels, breads, eggs, and avocado toast.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

6. Crave Coarse Pretzel Salt 1.5 Pound Large Bag For Soft Pretzels – Premium All Natural Coarse Food Grade Topping – For Bagels & Breads too!

This premium coarse pretzel salt is pure and all natural. It has no additives and is perfect for topping soft pretzels, breads, and bagels.

The bright white grains stick well to baked goods. It gives a full, salty flavor. The large 1.5-pound bag offers great value.

Pros	Cons
Pure salt with no additives or chemicals Large grains stick well to baked goods Versatile for pretzels, breads, and bagels All natural and made in the USA Great value in a big 1.5 lb bag	Large grains may be too coarse for some recipes No anti-caking agents, can clump in humid air Big bag size may be hard to store

Perfect For:

This salt is perfect for pretzel lovers, home bakers, and anyone who wants a crunchy, salty topping. It adds a bold taste to bagels, breads, and even sweet treats.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

7. Food to Live Everything Bagel Seasoning Mix, 8 Ounces – A Blend of White and Black Sesame Seeds, Minced Garlic, Onion, and Himalayan Pink Salt Flakes. Great as a Topping and Baking Ingredient

Food to Live Everything Bagel Seasoning Mix, 8 Ounces – A Blend of White and Black Sesame Seeds, Minced Garlic, Onion, and Himalayan Pink Salt Flakes. Great as a Topping and Baking Ingredient

This Everything Bagel Seasoning is made with premium quality raw ingredients. It is vegan-friendly and full of flavor.

It has white and black sesame seeds, garlic, onion, and Himalayan pink salt flakes. The mix is rich in protein, fiber, and good fats. It also gives you vitamins and minerals your body needs.

You can use it on bagels, buns, or crackers. Sprinkle it on salads, soups, or toast. The resealable bag keeps it fresh for longer.

Pros	Cons
Made with raw and premium ingredients for better taste Rich in nutrients like fiber, protein, and vitamins Lower sodium thanks to Himalayan pink salt flakes Perfect topping for bagels, toast, soups, and more Comes in easy-to-store resealable bags	Strong flavor may not suit all taste buds Salt content could be high for low-sodium diets Seeds may cause issues for those with allergies

Perfect For:

This mix is great for home cooks, bakers, and anyone who loves easy flavor. It’s perfect if you want a healthy, tasty topping for your meals.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

8. Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend with No Salt by It’s Delish, 5 Lbs Bulk Bag – Premium All Natural Bagel Spice Seasoning Mix Without Salt for Bagels, Buns, Bread, Salad Topping Seasonings for Food – USA Made, Salt-Free, Keto, Vegan, Kosher

Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend with No Salt by It's Delish, 5 Lbs Bulk Bag – Premium All Natural Bagel Spice Seasoning Mix Without Salt for Bagels, Buns, Bread, Salad Topping Seasonings for Food - USA Made, Salt-Free, Keto, Vegan, Kosher

This Everything Bagel Seasoning is made with the finest ingredients. You get bold flavor with no salt added.

It has black sesame seeds, poppy seeds, and toasted garlic. The mix gives a rich crunch to any food. You can use it on bagels, bread, or salads.

It is keto, vegan, and kosher. There are no additives or preservatives. You get fresh flavor in every bite.

Pros	Cons
High-quality seeds and spices for rich flavor No salt for healthier seasoning options Bulk 5 lb bag lasts a long time Keto and diet-friendly with low calories Additive-free and 100% fresh ingredients	Large 5 lb bag may be hard to store No salt means flavor might feel mild for some Limited ingredients may not suit all taste preferences

Perfect For:

This is perfect for anyone who wants big flavor without salt. It’s great for people who eat keto, vegan, or low-calorie meals.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

9. Bakers Club 8.5oz Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend – Authentic New York Style Spices for Bagels, Avocado Toast, Eggs, Pretzels, Popcorn, Hummus & More – Mix of Garlic, Onion, Sesame Seeds, Poppy, Salt

Bakers Club 8.5oz Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend - Authentic New York Style Spices for Bagels, Avocado Toast, Eggs, Pretzels, Popcorn, Hummus & More - Mix of Garlic, Onion, Sesame Seeds, Poppy, Salt

Enjoy the authentic flavor of a true New York everything bagel in every sprinkle. This blend adds a bold, savory pop to any dish.

It has garlic, onion, sesame seeds, poppy seeds, and salt. The taste is rich and fresh. The quality is always the same.

Use it on bagels, avocado toast, or even popcorn. It’s also great for soups and dips. The bulk size means you’ll never run out.

Pros	Cons
Authentic flavor that tastes like real New York bagels High-quality ingredients for a fresh, rich taste Versatile use on many snacks and meals Bulk size so you never run out Adds a savory pop to any dish	Bulk size may be too much for small kitchens Strong flavor might overpower light or delicate dishes Seeds can spill and make cleanup harder

Perfect For:

This is perfect for food lovers who want big flavor in every bite. Great for home cooks and chefs who enjoy adding a savory twist to many dishes.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

10. Dependable Food Everything Bagel Mix – 5 Lb. Resealable Jug – Natural, Non-GMO, No Additives, Kosher – Versatile Spice Blend for Elevating Any Dish

Enjoy the classic taste of an everything bagel in every bite. This mix blends sesame seed, salt, onion, garlic, and poppy seed. It adds rich flavor and crunch to any dish.

Made with natural, non-GMO ingredients and no additives. It is also Kosher certified for trusted quality.

Packed in a 5 lb resealable jug to keep it fresh. Use it on bagels, breads, salads, or dips for endless flavor.

Pros	Cons
Rich flavor from sesame, onion, garlic, and poppy seeds Natural and non-GMO for a wholesome seasoning choice Kosher certified to meet trusted quality standards Resealable jug keeps the mix fresh for longer Versatile blend for bagels, breads, salads, and dips	Large 5 lb size may be too much for some Strong flavor might overpower light dishes Not pre-portioned, needs measuring for small recipes

Perfect For:

This is perfect for home cooks and chefs who love adding bold, authentic flavor to many dishes. It’s great for anyone who wants a natural, versatile seasoning that works on almost anything.

Ready to Purchase?

View Price on Amazon

Buying Guide

A warm bagel with the right topping can change your whole day. I still remember the first time I tried everything seasoning—it was love at first bite.

Flavor Profile: Choose a blend that matches your taste. Some are savory and bold, while others are mild and nutty. Look for a balance of garlic, onion, seeds, and salt.
Texture: A good topping should add a pleasant crunch. Seeds like sesame and poppy give a nutty bite, while dried onion and garlic add crispness.
Salt Level: Check if you want regular, low-salt, or salt-free blends. Too much salt can overpower the bagel, while no salt lets other flavors shine.
Ingredient Quality: Go for natural, non-GMO, and additive-free mixes. Fresh spices and seeds give a richer, cleaner taste.
Versatility: Pick a topping you can use on more than just bagels. The best blends work on avocado toast, eggs, salads, and roasted vegetables.
Packaging Size: Decide between small jars for freshness or bulk packs for value. Resealable containers help keep the mix crisp and flavorful.
Dietary Needs: If you follow a specific diet, check for vegan, keto, or kosher certifications. This ensures the blend fits your lifestyle.
Heat Level: Some blends add chili flakes for a spicy kick. If you like a little fire, choose one with a mild to medium heat.
Brand Reputation: Trusted brands often have consistent flavor and quality. Look for ones with a history of making great seasonings.