Hunting for the best bagels in Yorktown, NY isn’t just about ticking off a to-do list. It’s about finding that perfect bite—lightly crisp on the outside, tender and chewy inside, and full of character. A good bagel pairs just right with your favorite spread, or stands proud on its own. Yorktown’s bagel scene covers all the bases, from classic hand-rolled dough to inventive twists that surprise even seasoned bagel fans.
My first proper New York bagel was in Yorktown, a modest plain bagel with a swipe of cream cheese. Simple, yet it taught me that not all bagels are created equal. Since then, I’ve sampled my way along Route 202 and through every corner bakery in town. That search led to some chewy masterpieces and a few tasty surprises. If you’re searching for the right spot to start your morning (or rescue your afternoon), let’s explore where Yorktown truly delivers on bagels, one satisfying bite at a time.
Where to find the best bagels in Yorktown, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Yorktown, NY:
- The Bagel Emporium of Yorktown Heights
- Dunkin’
- Daily Bagel
- J V Bagels
- Goldbergs Famous Bagels
- The Bagel Shoppe
- Briar Bagel & More
- The Bagel Emporium of Chappaqua
- Sinapi’s Kettled Bagels
- Our Town Bagels & Bakery
1. The Bagel Emporium of Yorktown Heights
The Bagel Emporium of Yorktown Heights is more than a local staple; it’s the place bagel lovers go when they want a sure thing. With seven “Best Bagel of Westchester” wins and decades in business, this spot’s reputation rests on real skill. My first time here, I remember the aroma of freshly baked bagels hit before I even opened the door.
Once inside, the displays are stacked with choices—each bagel has a golden crust that promises a genuine New York chew. The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese stands out. It’s loaded with flavor, not salt, and the schmear is fresher than any chain shop you’ll find.
If you’re feeling classic, order a toasted sesame bagel. It’s the foundation of their menu, and a bite tells you why locals keep coming back.
2. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on Downing Drive is the spot for those who value quick, reliable bagels alongside their coffee fix. With its bright, familiar orange sign, Dunkin’ is where routine meets comfort food. I’ve swung by early mornings when the line seems endless, yet the staff keeps things moving with practiced ease.
While Dunkin’ covers a classic bagel menu, the plain bagel with veggie cream cheese is a simple pleasure. It’s fresh enough to satisfy and always easy to grab when you’re in a rush. Their bagel breakfast sandwiches—especially the egg and cheese on an everything bagel—are a favorite for fueling up before a busy day.
Dunkin’ has a knack for consistency. Not every spot feels unique, but for dependable bagels and coffee, it delivers right when you need it.
3. Daily Bagel
Daily Bagel draws in a steady crowd for good reason. Tucked away on Crompond Road, this place feels old-school in the best way. The bagels here are hand-rolled, chewy, and have that satisfying bite locals crave. When I stopped by, the line buzzed with regulars chatting up the staff—always a sign you’re in the right spot.
The highlight at Daily Bagel is their poppy seed bagel with house-made lox spread. The poppy seeds add crunch, while the lox brings a savory depth you don’t often find outside city limits. Their fresh-baked muffins are tempting, but bagels are the main draw here.
If you like bagels that feel homemade, Daily Bagel nails the classic New York texture without overcomplicating things.
4. J V Bagels
(914) 962-0259Call
J V Bagels sits quietly on Lee Road, but it’s earned a devoted following for its bold, fresh flavors. Walk in, and you’re greeted by the unmistakable scent of real bagel baking—a clue you’re in for something good. My own visits have always ended with a warm bag of bagels that barely make it home untouched.
J V shines with its egg bagel, lightly toasted, and topped with a simple schmear. The texture is perfect: soft, yet with enough chew to keep you going back for more. Bagels here are never bland—every variety pops.
For folks searching for bagels made by people who genuinely care, this place stands out in the Yorktown area.
5. Goldbergs Famous Bagels
(914) 232-1370Call
Goldbergs Famous Bagels on Katonah Avenue brings a reliable classic to Northern Westchester. There’s nothing flashy about the atmosphere, but the bagels are dense, chewy, and unmistakably fresh. I remember grabbing a baker’s dozen here, and the poppy and sesame bagels disappeared fastest at home—always a stamp of approval.
This spot keeps things wallet-friendly, so you can sample without guilt. The standout is their whole wheat bagel with a crisp shell and an earthy interior. It pairs perfectly with a hand-mixed veggie cream cheese and works for breakfast or a quick lunch.
For those in search of a dependable bagel with a gently nostalgic flavor, Goldbergs checks every box and then some.
6. The Bagel Shoppe
The Bagel Shoppe, nestled on Katonah Avenue, delivers an old-school bagel experience with a modern touch. Every time I’ve stepped inside, I’ve been greeted with the comforting hum of a neighborhood favorite doing what it does best—rolling out fresh, warm bagels from the back.
Variety is where The Bagel Shoppe really shines. Their jalapeño bagel is a top pick if you’re after a little heat, while the classic plain bagel hits all the right notes with its soft crumb and glossy finish.
Here, every bagel feels freshly made and never mass-produced. It’s that commitment to craft—and the hum of regulars lining up—that sets The Bagel Shoppe apart in the local bagel scene.
7. Briar Bagel & More
Briar Bagel & More in Briarcliff Manor is the kind of spot where bagels aren’t just a side note; they’re the main event. With indoor and outdoor seating, it’s a relaxed place to linger over breakfast or lunch. The bagel counter always draws a crowd, especially on weekends.
I’ve found their salt bagel with classic butter to be an underrated standout—simple, yet packed with flavor. The deli side adds plenty of choices, but the real stars are the hand-rolled bagels, each one firm on the outside and soft inside.
If you want a quiet spot to enjoy a freshly made bagel and watch the world go by, Briar Bagel & More gets it just right.
8. The Bagel Emporium of Chappaqua
The Bagel Emporium of Chappaqua feels like a neighborhood cornerstone. Step inside and you’re met with the aroma of fresh bagels, a legacy that stretches back to 1983. This place takes pride in being a seven-time “Best Bagel of Westchester” winner. That reputation comes through in every bite.
I always go for their everything bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese. Each is hand-rolled and baked to a golden finish. The bagel has substance and a blend of seeds that hits just right—savory, never overpowering.
Whether you’re in for a full breakfast spread or just a bagel and coffee, The Bagel Emporium of Chappaqua delivers something familiar but never boring. Quality here is a given, not a gamble.
9. Sinapi’s Kettled Bagels
(914) 218-3870Call
Sinapi’s Kettled Bagels in Mount Kisco is a cozy spot where bagel lovers get rewarded for venturing off the main path. Their kettle-boiled bagels have a distinct crust—shiny and just crisp enough to give way to a perfectly chewy interior. Each visit feels like you’re in on a local secret.
The staff takes pride in their craft, and it shows. My go-to is the pumpernickel bagel with whipped cream cheese and tomato. The deep flavor of the pumpernickel makes for a memorable breakfast, while the toppings are always fresh and generous.
For those in search of a bagel that’s all about tradition and taste, Sinapi’s offers a satisfying take on a New York classic, no fuss required.
10. Our Town Bagels & Bakery
(845) 803-8745Call
Our Town Bagels & Bakery in Mahopac is the product of two sisters who know a thing or two about community and comfort food. The vibe inside is always welcoming, and you’ll spot Christina and Stephanie chatting with regulars between rolling out fresh bagels. This is the kind of place where “homemade” really means something.
The standout order is a whole wheat everything bagel with their signature veggie schmear. You can taste the attention to detail—the bagel is hearty, with a texture built for holding generous toppings, and the schmear is always full of flavor.
If you’re looking for a small-town feel with serious bagel skills, Our Town Bagels & Bakery is worth a detour.
More Things to Try in Yorktown, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a bagel in Yorktown, NY, stand out?
Yorktown bagels are known for being hand-rolled, boiled before baking, and finished with a distinct NY-style chew. Local shops use family recipes and fresh ingredients, which give their bagels flavor you won’t find at national chains.
Are there gluten-free bagel options in Yorktown?
A few local bakeries offer gluten-free bagels, but it’s best to call ahead. Many shops make their bagels fresh daily and gluten-free supplies can vary.
Which bagel shops in Yorktown have the best breakfast sandwiches?
The Bagel Emporium, J V Bagels, and Daily Bagel are crowd favorites for hearty breakfast sandwiches, with choices that satisfy both classic and veggie lovers.
Can I get non-dairy schmears or vegan options?
Some shops, especially the larger bakeries, carry non-dairy spreads or vegan-friendly options. It’s worth checking their menu or asking when you order.
Do bagel stores in Yorktown offer catering?
Yes, many local bagel shops provide catering for parties, business events, and family gatherings. Options include bagel platters, spreads, and fresh-baked pastries.
Is there a best time to buy bagels in Yorktown?
For the freshest experience, early mornings are hard to beat. Most bakeries start baking before sunrise—fresh bagels are usually at their peak before 11 a.m.