Finding a truly great bagel in Tustin, CA is a bit like uncovering a hidden gem. The city holds a surprising range of spots, each with their own twist on the perfect, chewy bite. After sampling far and wide—sometimes scoring a tender, still-warm everything bagel that begs for a swipe of cream cheese—I learned Tustin’s bagel scene runs deeper than expected. Some places keep things classic and round, while others lean into creative fillings or regional inspirations.
If you’re searching for the best bagels in Tustin, you’re in the right hands. I’ve done the carb-heavy lifting to bring you a guide that highlights both old favorites and lesser-known shops worth the detour. Whether you crave a New York-style stretch or a California spin, you’ll find options here to satisfy even the most specific cravings. Dive in and let your next bagel adventure begin.
1. Bageled
Bageled brings a fresh, modern vibe to traditional bagels. Tucked along Robinson Drive, it’s the kind of spot where you can see bakers working behind the counter, turning out glossy, golden rings all morning. I still remember my first visit—the aroma of baked dough was impossible to resist, and the texture hit that perfect mark: chewy inside, with a crisp shell.
Standout flavors rotate daily, but the sesame bagel with house-made cream cheese always stays on my radar. There’s also a lineup of creative sandwiches that add a Tustin touch, like the avocado and herb spread layered on a toasted everything bagel. Quality ingredients and attention to detail make every bite memorable.
Not sure where to start? Try the classic bagel with lox (all halal), or ask for a recommendation from staff; they know their flavors. Bageled’s commitment to freshness shines through in each order, setting it apart from the usual spots.
2. Western Bagel
Western Bagel keeps things classic with a touch of West Coast charm. When I stopped in on a sleepy Saturday morning, I was greeted by the steady hum of regulars and the unmistakable scent of bagels hot out of the oven. Their bakers clearly believe bagels shouldn’t be rushed—every bite had a satisfying chew and just enough crisp on the edge.
The menu covers the basics, but quality is never an afterthought. I couldn’t resist their simple plain bagel, toasted and slathered with cream cheese. It’s the kind of breakfast you come back for. They’re also known for their hearty sandwiches, especially the veggie option with crisp lettuce and ripe tomato, piled onto a fresh bagel.
If you’re looking for a quick start or something to take home, Western Bagel’s consistency and no-frills approach make it a solid standby in Tustin’s breakfast scene.
3. Bagel Me
Bagel Me is a bright, busy spot on Newport Avenue that has a little bit of everything for breakfast lovers. My first visit was a blur of cheerful staff and the sight of fresh bagels lining the counter. There’s something about the buzz here that made me want to linger just a bit longer.
What sets Bagel Me apart is their inventiveness. You’ll find classic flavors, but their spinach parmesan bagel with a swipe of plain or chive cream cheese is something special—fluffy inside, robust and savory. For a heartier bite, the California bagel sandwich (hold the bacon) loaded with egg, cheese, and creamy avocado brings west coast flair to every mouthful.
This is the destination for anyone craving bagels that feel both familiar and fresh. Never dull, always satisfying.
4. Gourmet Bagel Co
(714) 730-2003Call
Gourmet Bagel Co is a cozy, unassuming shop that proves good things often come in simple packages. When I visited, it felt like a true neighborhood haunt—locals stopping by for their daily fix and exchanging quick greetings with the staff. There’s nothing pretentious here, just a focus on wholesome, expertly made bagels.
The texture stood out right away: a crackly shell with a tender center, perfect for a breakfast on the go or a slow weekend treat. Their jalapeño bagel is a flavorful favorite, with just enough heat to keep breakfast interesting. Paired with their smooth, house-made cream cheese, it’s tough to beat.
Looking for something lighter? Their classic sesame bagel offers a nutty crunch and pairs beautifully with their selection of spreads. Gourmet Bagel Co’s dedication to fresh ingredients makes each visit feel like a neighborhood secret worth sharing.
5. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ might be known for coffee, but its bagels earn plenty of fans on their own. This Tustin spot is always busy, especially in the morning. When I dropped in for a quick bite, service was brisk and the classic bagel selection hit just the right note for a grab-and-go breakfast.
Their plain and everything bagels are soft, slightly sweet, and always toasted to order. There’s a comfort in getting exactly what you expect—nothing fussy, just fresh bagels and a wide range of halal cream cheese options. The veggie cream cheese is a standout, offering a fresh crunch with every bite.
If you’re after reliable morning fuel with a familiar feel, Dunkin’ serves up all the essentials in a casual setting. It’s easy, efficient, and never disappoints when you crave a quick classic.
6. Noah’s NY Bagels
Noah’s NY Bagels serves up East Coast nostalgia right in Tustin. My first bite into their bagel had all the hallmarks of the real New York deal: a crisp, glossy outside and chewy interior. The bakery’s open early, always stocked with trays of bagels just begging for their signature double-whipped shmear.
What makes Noah’s stand out is the range of choices. The asiago bagel paired with garden veggie shmear is a personal go-to—savory, with the perfect cheesy crust. Sandwich fans will enjoy the avocado and egg sandwich, proof that Noah’s can do simple or stacked with style.
Every menu item is prepped with quality in mind, and there’s no shortage of ways to mix and match flavors. For a taste of classic New York tradition, Noah’s NY Bagels delivers every time.
7. East Coast Bagel
(949) 733-3414Call
East Coast Bagel, just a short drive from Tustin, brings classic bagel craftsmanship to Orange County. Walking in, I noticed racks of bagels cooling on display, each with that signature glossy finish and a dense, satisfying bite. There’s a friendly, neighborhood vibe—perfect for early mornings or a quick afternoon snack.
What sets East Coast Bagel apart is their dedication to traditional methods and simple, quality ingredients. The everything bagel here is loaded with fresh toppings and pairs beautifully with their whipped cream cheese or a slice of ripe tomato. For something with a little more substance, try the veggie bagel sandwich—fresh, filling, and a consistent favorite.
This is the spot for bagel purists who crave authenticity and real New York texture, without the cross-country flight.
8. Bruegger’s Bagels
Bruegger’s Bagels, just north of Tustin, is where you’ll find genuine New York-style bagels baked fresh each morning. On my latest visit, the morning line moved quickly and the staff handed over steaming, hand-rolled bagels that practically called for a generous slathering of their Vermont-made cream cheese.
Bruegger’s stands out for its perfect balance of crisp crust and soft interior. Their cinnamon sugar bagel is predictably popular—sweet but never cloying—and pairs beautifully with their original cream cheese. If you’re in a savory mood, the sun-dried tomato bagel offers a tangy twist that’s hard to resist, especially as part of a veggie breakfast sandwich.
Variety is the rule here, so there’s always something new to try. For consistency with an East Coast spirit, Bruegger’s Bagels is a Tustin-area staple worth repeat visits.
9. Dough Exchange
Dough Exchange is the kind of bakery where a bagel is treated as an art form. My first trek there was spurred by word-of-mouth, and it didn’t disappoint—one bite, and you can taste the handcrafted dedication. Every bagel here is rolled by hand, with unique toppings and inventive flavors you’ll want to try at least once.
Dough Exchange stands apart thanks to its balance of tradition and creativity. Classic options like the everything bagel get top marks for texture and toasted finish, while more inventive choices—think za’atar or poppy with a tangy house-made spread—showcase the team’s flair.
Sandwiches are also a highlight, built on bagels that pack a satisfying chew without being heavy. Come early for the best pick and let yourself be surprised by what’s new on the menu.
10. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels has a reputation for being both convenient and dependable. I’ve dropped by after an early class and also on busy weekend mornings, and there’s always a fresh batch waiting. The atmosphere is casual, making it a go-to for students, families, and anyone needing a pick-me-up.
Their bagel variety is impressive, from hearty whole wheat to playful asiago. The six-cheese bagel with plain or garden veggie shmear is a standout—savory, cheesy, and satisfying for any time of day. For a lighter option, their honey whole wheat bagel meets that just-sweet-enough mark without overpowering flavor.
If you like your bagels soft, warm, and loaded with spread choices, Einstein Bros. is a solid choice close to Tustin. Quality and comfort are always on the menu here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find authentic New York-style bagels in Tustin, CA?
Try Noah’s NY Bagels or Bruegger’s Bagels for the classic New York texture—crisp outside, chewy inside. These shops focus on traditional prep and flavors.
Are there any bagel shops in Tustin that offer unique flavors?
Absolutely. Dough Exchange is known for inventive options like za’atar or poppy seed with house-made spreads. Bageled and Bagel Me also rotate specialty flavors regularly.
Which places have vegetarian or vegan bagel options?
Nearly every spot offers veggie bagel sandwiches or plant-based spreads. Western Bagel, Bagel Me, and Einstein Bros. Bagels shine when it comes to variety without the meat.
Do any shops serve halal bagels or sandwiches in Tustin?
Yes. Shops like Bageled and Dunkin’ offer halal-friendly options—just ask staff to confirm your choice when ordering.
Can I get bagels for catering or large groups?
Noah’s NY Bagels and Bruegger’s Bagels both have catering menus perfect for meetings or brunch gatherings. Advance orders are recommended for best selection.