Tulsa may not be the first place that springs to mind when bagel cravings strike, but you’d be surprised by what’s tucked between Yale and Memorial. Having roamed the city on foot (and on a very determined appetite), I’ve discovered that Tulsa’s bagel scene is quietly competitive. Whether you’re after chewy, golden rounds worthy of a New Yorker’s approval or more creative twists that still stick to tradition, there are solid options scattered across town.
This guide is built from real bites, not hearsay. Each spot featured has been chosen for quality, consistency, and a menu that keeps things clean and satisfying. If you’re on a mission for the best bagels in Tulsa, OK, this list will steer you right—without overwhelming you with fluff. Let’s cut to the crust.
Where to find the best bagels in Tulsa, OK
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Tulsa, OK:
- New York Bagel Cafe
- Old School Bagel
- Panera Bread
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Old School Bagel Cafe
- Bagel Boys 21st & Columbia
- Dunkin’
1. New York Bagel Cafe
New York Bagel Cafe in Tulsa offers a delightful fusion of quick-service dining with an inviting atmosphere, perfect for breakfast, lunch, or brunch adventures. Nestled in the heart of Brookside, this locally owned gem is celebrated for its freshly made bagels and pastries, creating a cozy spot for locals and visitors alike.
During my visit, I was charmed by the friendly service and the mouth-watering aroma of fresh bagels. The cafe’s standout is their classic bagel sandwich, which perfectly balances soft, chewy bagels with savory fillings. It’s easy to see why it’s a local favorite!
I highly recommend trying their vegetarian bagel sandwich—it’s a delicious blend of fresh ingredients that truly captures the essence of New York Bagel Cafe’s commitment to quality and flavor.
2. Old School Bagel
Old School Bagel brings a hearty, no-nonsense approach to bagels that feels both familiar and refreshing. The location on South Yale is clean, comfortable, and ideal for a grab-and-go breakfast or a longer lunch break. What separates Old School from others is its commitment to authentic bagel craft—every bite has that signature chew that bagel aficionados crave.
One morning I dropped by mid-rush and found the staff impressively swift yet warm. I ordered the veggie egg and cheese bagel, toasted just right. It was simple but done with care—the kind of balance that reflects the shop’s straightforward philosophy: quality ingredients, consistently prepared.
If you’re looking for flavor without compromise, start with their jalapeño cheddar bagel. It’s bold, satisfying, and one of the best bites Tulsa’s bagel scene has to offer.
3. Panera Bread
Panera Bread on East 15th Street blends consistency with comfort, offering a familiar yet satisfying stop for bagel lovers in Tulsa. The space is clean, the service is efficient, and the atmosphere is ideal for both a quiet solo breakfast or a casual meet-up over coffee.
What makes Panera stand out is its focus on clean ingredients and customizable options. I’ve often stopped in for a quick bite and found their whole grain bagel with veggie cream cheese to be a reliable go-to—simple, hearty, and balanced.
For something more filling, try the egg and cheese bagel sandwich. It’s warm, satisfying, and reflects Panera’s knack for turning everyday ingredients into something a bit more thoughtful.
4. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on 21st Street is a go-to spot for fresh-baked bagels and quick, satisfying breakfast or lunch. The welcoming atmosphere makes it perfect for a casual stop, whether you’re grabbing a dozen bagels for the office or enjoying a coffee and bagel combo.
What sets Einstein Bros. apart is their wide selection of gourmet topped and signature bagels, all made fresh each day. I particularly enjoy their double-whipped cream cheese shmear paired with a warm bagel, delivering a comforting, flavorful experience.
For a fulfilling meal, try the breakfast egg sandwich on a toasted bagel. It reflects their commitment to quality, convenience, and a truly satisfying bagel experience.
5. Old School Bagel Cafe
Old School Bagel Cafe on South Peoria offers a nostalgic approach to bagels, focusing on quality and fresh ingredients. The cozy, inviting environment makes it an ideal spot for breakfast or brunch in Tulsa’s Brookside neighborhood.
What makes Old School Bagel Cafe unique is its commitment to traditional methods and homemade flavors. I enjoyed their classic bagel with smoked salmon and cream cheese, which perfectly showcases their dedication to authentic tastiness.
If you’re seeking a satisfying, well-made bagel, opt for their everything bagel with a variety of fresh spreads. It exemplifies their straightforward yet quality-driven approach to classic bagel offerings.
6. Bagel Boys 21st & Columbia
(918) 960-2767Call
Tucked into the corner of 21st and Columbia, Bagel Boys brings a no-frills, flavor-first approach to Tulsa’s bagel scene. The space is modest, but the bagels speak volumes—dense, chewy, and baked with care. It’s the kind of place where regulars know what they want before they walk in.
What sets Bagel Boys apart is their focus on simplicity and consistency. No gimmicks, just solid bagels made fresh daily. I stopped in on a quiet morning and tried their plain bagel with veggie cream cheese—a classic done right. The texture was spot-on, and the spread had just the right balance of herbs.
If you’re new, start with the everything bagel toasted with scallion cream cheese. It’s a local favorite for a reason: bold, balanced, and satisfying without trying too hard.
7. Dunkin’
Located on South Yale, Dunkin’ is a familiar staple for quick, reliable breakfast and snack options in Tulsa. Known for its wide variety of donuts, bagels, and coffee, it’s a go-to spot for busy mornings or a mid-day pick-me-up.
What makes Dunkin’ stand out is its commitment to consistency and variety. During a recent visit, I enjoyed their everything bagel with chive cream cheese, which was fresh and flavorful, showcasing their classic quality.
If you’re looking for a satisfying, easy grab-and-go, try their breakfast sandwich on a toasted bagel. It’s a reliable choice that reflects Dunkin’s dedication to serving comfort-food favorites quickly and deliciously.
More Things to Try in Tulsa, OK
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best places to find authentic bagels in Tulsa, OK?
A: Some top spots include New York Bagel Cafe and Old School Bagel. Both are known for their fresh, traditional bagels and quality ingredients.
Q: Are there vegetarian-friendly bagel options in Tulsa?
A: Yes, several places like Old School Bagel and Panera Bread offer vegetarian bagel sandwiches and spreads, making it easy to enjoy a meat-free meal.
Q: Can I get bagels to-go or delivery in Tulsa?
A: Absolutely. Most bakeries and cafes like Dunkin’ and Einstein Bros. Bagels offer takeout and delivery options for convenience.
Q: Do Tulsa bagel shops offer custom toppings or spreads?
A: Yes, many places provide a variety of spreads, including cream cheese, flavored butters, and toppings like smoked salmon or vegetables to personalize your bagel.