Suffolk County, NY, is a fantastic place for bagel lovers like me! There’s just something special about biting into a fresh, warm bagel that makes my taste buds dance. I’ve explored so many bagel shops here, and I can confidently say that this area has some of the best bagels around. Whether you like them plain, toasted, or piled high with toppings, there’s a bagel shop that’s perfect for you.
So, what are the best bagels in Suffolk County, NY? Well, the best bagels can be found at a bunch of local spots that really care about what they make. They use great ingredients and stick to traditional ways of making bagels, which is super important. Each place has its own vibe and yummy flavors, so you’re sure to find something you love.
I can’t wait to share my favorite bagel shops with you! You’ll learn about their special bagels, the cozy atmospheres, and what makes each one unique. Get ready for a tasty adventure through the best bagels in Suffolk County!
Top 10 Bagels in Suffolk County, NY
- BETTER ON A BAGEL EXPRESS
- Bagel Gallery
- Toasted Bagel Patchogue
- St. James Bagels
- Bagel Deli Gourmet
- Bagel Boss Yaphank
- West Islip Bagel
- Bagel Chalet
- Bean’s Bagels & Gourmet Catering
- Avenue Bagels
1. BETTER ON A BAGEL EXPRESS
Better on a Bagel Express is such a cool spot in Coram, NY! When I walked in, the smell of fresh bagels hit me right away, and it made me feel so happy. The people working there are super nice and really quick, which is awesome when you’re hungry and ready to eat.
What I love about this place is how many different bagels they have. They’ve got all the classics, like plain and everything, but they also have some fun flavors too! If you go, you have to try their breakfast sandwich. It’s got a yummy egg, crispy bacon, and melty cheese all stuffed in a warm bagel. It’s like a big hug for your tummy!
Plus, it’s really affordable, and you can grab your food to go if you’re in a hurry. Better on a Bagel Express is definitely a must-try for anyone who loves bagels!
2. Bagel Gallery
Phone: (631) 360-8406
Menu: 24hrhotbagels.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Gallery in Smithtown is one of my go-to places for bagels! When I walked in, I was hit with the yummy smell of fresh bagels baking, and it made me smile. The staff there is super friendly, and I love that I can sit inside or outside, depending on the weather. It’s such a nice place to hang out!
What I really like about Bagel Gallery is how many different bagels they have. They’re all so fresh and tasty! My favorite is the everything bagel because it’s chewy and packed with flavor. If you’re feeling adventurous, you should definitely try their lox spread. It’s creamy and just so good!
Oh, and they even deliver, which is awesome when I want to relax at home. Bagel Gallery is a must-try for anyone who loves a great bagel!
3. Toasted Bagel Patchogue
Phone: (631) 730-1130
Menu: www.toastedbagelcafe.com
Directions: Open on Map
Toasted Bagel Patchogue is one of my favorite spots for bagels! When I walked in, the bright colors and happy atmosphere made me smile right away. The yummy smell of bagels toasting filled the air, and I couldn’t wait to dig in. The people working there are super friendly, and I love that I can sit inside or outside, depending on my mood.
What really makes Toasted Bagel Patchogue special is their amazing choices. I always get a toasted plain bagel with cream cheese because it’s warm and so tasty! If you want to try something different, their smoked salmon bagel is a must. It’s fresh and full of flavor!
They even have delivery, which is great for those lazy days when I just want to enjoy a bagel at home. Toasted Bagel Patchogue is a must-try for anyone who loves bagels!
4. St. James Bagels
Phone: (631) 250-9500
Menu: stjamesbagels.com
Directions: Open on Map
St. James Bagels is one of my favorite places to go for a yummy bagel! When I walked in, the friendly staff welcomed me with big smiles, and the smell of fresh bagels made my tummy rumble. The cozy atmosphere is perfect for hanging out or grabbing a bagel to take home.
What I really love about St. James Bagels is how many different kinds they have. Their everything bagel is my go-to because it’s super tasty and chewy. If you want to try something different, their egg salad bagel is amazing! It’s creamy and so good, especially when I’m really hungry.
They also do delivery, which is awesome for those lazy days when I just want to chill at home. St. James Bagels is a must-try for anyone who loves delicious bagels!
5. Bagel Deli Gourmet
Phone: (631) 474-4445
Menu: www.bageldeligourmet.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Deli Gourmet is one of my favorite spots for bagels! When I walked in, the friendly staff welcomed me with big smiles, and the yummy smell of fresh bagels made my mouth water. I love that I can sit inside or outside, which is great for enjoying my food in the sunshine.
What really makes Bagel Deli Gourmet special is their awesome variety of bagels and toppings. I always go for their warm sesame bagel with cream cheese because it’s so tasty and perfect for breakfast! If you want to try something different, their turkey and avocado bagel sandwich is super fresh and really filling.
They even have delivery, which is perfect for those cozy days when I just want to relax at home. Bagel Deli Gourmet is a must-try for anyone who loves delicious bagels!
6. Bagel Boss Yaphank
Phone: (934) 238-1442
Menu: bagelboss.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Boss Yaphank is one of my favorite places to get bagels! When I walked in, the friendly staff greeted me with smiles, and the yummy smell of fresh bagels made my tummy rumble. I love that they have cozy seating inside and outside, so I can enjoy my meal no matter the weather.
What really makes Bagel Boss Yaphank special is their tasty bagels and fun menu. My go-to is the everything bagel with cream cheese because it’s super flavorful and chewy. If you’re really hungry, you have to try their breakfast burrito bagel! It’s filled with eggs, cheese, and bacon, and it’s so filling.
They also have curbside pickup and delivery, which is super handy for busy days. Bagel Boss Yaphank is a must-try for anyone who loves delicious bagels!
7. West Islip Bagel
West Islip Bagel is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! When I walked in, the friendly staff greeted me with big smiles, and the yummy smell of fresh bagels baking made my mouth water. The cozy vibe is perfect for sitting down and enjoying my food.
What I really love about West Islip Bagel is their awesome selection. I always go for a plain bagel with cream cheese because it’s so fresh and tasty! If I’m really hungry, I can’t resist their bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It’s warm, filling, and just perfect for breakfast.
Plus, it’s super affordable, and I can easily take my bagel to go if I’m in a hurry. West Islip Bagel is definitely a must-try for anyone who loves delicious bagels!
8. Bagel Chalet
Phone: (631) 499-9820
Menu: bagelchalet.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Chalet is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! When I walked in, I felt so happy because the cozy vibe and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The yummy smell of fresh bagels and breakfast treats filled the air, and I couldn’t wait to pick something delicious!
What I really love about Bagel Chalet is their awesome bagels and made-to-order sandwiches. My go-to is the fresh blueberry bagel with cream cheese because it’s sweet and super tasty! If I’m really hungry, I can’t resist their breakfast sandwich with eggs and bacon. It’s warm, filling, and just perfect for starting my day.
They even have delivery, which is perfect for those lazy days when I just want to chill at home. Bagel Chalet is definitely a must-try for anyone who loves yummy bagels!
9. Bean’s Bagels & Gourmet Catering
Phone: (631) 553-7619
Menu: www.beansbagels.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bean’s Bagels & Gourmet Catering is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! When I walked in, the friendly staff welcomed me with big smiles, and the yummy smell of fresh bagels made my mouth water. I love that they have cozy seating inside and outside, so I can enjoy my food in the sunshine or chill inside.
What really makes Bean’s Bagels special is their awesome bagels and fancy options. My go-to is the cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese because it’s sweet and super tasty! If you want something fun to share, their breakfast platter is amazing. It has a little bit of everything, and it’s perfect for a group.
They also have curbside pickup and delivery, which is super handy for busy days. Bean’s Bagels & Gourmet Catering is definitely a must-try for anyone who loves yummy bagels!
10. Avenue Bagels
Phone: (631) 667-7399
Menu: avenuebagelsdeerpark.com
Directions: Open on Map
Avenue Bagels is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! When I walked in, the friendly staff welcomed me with big smiles, and the yummy smell of fresh bagels made my tummy rumble. I love that I can choose to sit inside or outside, which is perfect for enjoying my meal in the sunshine.
What really makes Avenue Bagels special is their tasty bagels and fun menu. I always get a plain bagel with cream cheese because it’s super fresh and delicious! If you’re feeling a little adventurous, you should definitely try their breakfast bagel with eggs and sausage. It’s warm, filling, and just perfect for starting my day.
They also have delivery, which is super handy for those busy mornings when I need to eat on the go. Avenue Bagels is a must-try for anyone who loves yummy bagels!
Map of Bagels in Suffolk County, NY
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BETTER ON A BAGEL EXPRESS | Inexpensive | – | Yes | No | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Gallery | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Toasted Bagel Patchogue | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| St. James Bagels | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Deli Gourmet | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Boss Yaphank | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| West Islip Bagel | Inexpensive | – | Yes | No | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Chalet | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bean’s Bagels & Gourmet Catering | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Avenue Bagels | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What are the best bagel shops in Suffolk County?
There are so many great bagel shops in Suffolk County! Some of my favorites are Better on a Bagel Express, Bagel Gallery, and St. James Bagels. Each place has yummy bagels and fun toppings that everyone will love. -
Are bagels in Suffolk County made fresh daily?
Yes, most bagel shops here make their bagels fresh every day! It’s awesome because you get to enjoy warm, chewy bagels that taste amazing. -
Can I get bagels delivered in Suffolk County?
For sure! Many bagel shops in Suffolk County offer delivery, so you can enjoy your favorite bagels right at home. Just check with the shop to see if they deliver. -
What are some popular bagel flavors?
Some super popular bagel flavors are plain, everything, sesame, and cinnamon raisin. Lots of shops also have special flavors, so there’s always something new to try! -
Do bagel shops in Suffolk County offer breakfast sandwiches?
Yes, they do! Most bagel shops have yummy breakfast sandwiches with eggs, bacon, sausage, and cheese on your favorite bagel. They’re perfect for starting your day! -
Are there vegetarian or vegan bagel options?
Absolutely! Many bagel shops have vegetarian and vegan options. You can find bagels with fresh veggies, spreads, and even plant-based proteins. Just ask the staff for their best picks! -
What is the average price of a bagel in Suffolk County?
Bagels in Suffolk County are usually pretty cheap, around $1 to $2 each. If you get a special bagel or a sandwich, it might cost a little more, but it’s still a good deal! -
Can I customize my bagel order?
Yes, you can! Most bagel shops let you customize your order with different spreads, toppings, and sandwich choices. It’s super fun to make your perfect bagel just the way you like it!
