Staten Island, NY, has some of the best bagels around, and I’m excited to share my favorites with you! There’s just something special about biting into a fresh bagel, and this borough really knows how to do it right. Whether you like them plain, toasted, or loaded with toppings, you’re in for a treat here.
So, what are the best bagels in Staten Island, NY? Well, the best bagels are fresh, tasty, and come in all sorts of flavors. You can find everything from classic plain bagels to fun, creative options that will surprise your taste buds. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!
Stick around, and I’ll take you on a tasty tour of the top bagel shops in Staten Island. You’ll learn about their must-try bagels, what makes each place unique, and why they’re worth a visit. Let’s dive into this delicious adventure together!
Top 10 Bagels in Staten Island, NY
- BAGELS R US
- Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering
- Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe
- Bagels N’ Buns
- Top Bagels
- Plaza Bagels and Deli
- Forest Bagels
- Bagels Bread & Butter
- Bagels By the Bay
- Clove Road Bagels
1. BAGELS R US
Phone: (718) 967-2299
Menu: m.facebook.com
Directions: Open on Map
BAGELS R US is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Amboy Road, and when you walk in, you can smell the yummy bagels baking. It feels so cozy, and the people who work there are super nice. They always help me pick out something tasty!
What I really love about BAGELS R US is how many different kinds of bagels they have. You can get a classic everything bagel or try something fun like jalapeño cheddar. My go-to is their smoked salmon cream cheese bagel. It’s so creamy and delicious—it’s like a party in my mouth!
If you’re in a hurry, you have to try their breakfast sandwiches. The egg and cheese on a fresh bagel is simple but oh-so-good! It really shows how much they care about making great food. You won’t regret stopping by!
2. Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering
Phone: (718) 233-8656
Menu: brunchsi.com
Directions: Open on Map
Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering is one of my favorite places to go for bagels on Staten Island! It’s located on Forest Avenue, and every time I walk in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super friendly, and they always make me feel welcome. I love that I can even do curbside pickup when I’m in a hurry!
What really makes Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering special is their yummy choices. They have so many different bagels and spreads to pick from! My favorite is the everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s always fresh and tastes amazing!
If you want to try something fun, you should get their breakfast platter. It has a little bit of everything, and it’s a great way to enjoy a tasty meal. I always leave with a big smile!
3. Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe
Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Victory Boulevard, and every time I go in, I can smell the yummy bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel welcome. I love how easy it is to get my bagel to go!
What really makes Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe special is their great prices and tasty choices. They have so many bagels to pick from, and everything is always fresh! My go-to is the plain bagel with lox spread. It’s so creamy and delicious—it’s one of the best things ever!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast sandwiches. They’re made with fresh ingredients and are perfect for a yummy start to your day. I always leave with a big smile and a full tummy!
4. Bagels N’ Buns
Phone: (718) 761-1900
Menu: bagelsnbuns.net
Directions: Open on Map
Bagels N’ Buns is one of my favorite spots for bagels on Staten Island! It’s right on Victory Boulevard, and every time I go in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super friendly, and they always make me feel right at home. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or enjoy it there!
What really makes Bagels N’ Buns special is their yummy choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels and toppings! My favorite is the cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and creamy, and it always makes me smile!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast burrito. It’s filled with all kinds of tasty stuff and is perfect for a big meal. I always leave feeling full and happy!
5. Top Bagels
Phone: (718) 227-2202
Menu: www.topbagelssi.com
Directions: Open on Map
Top Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Arthur Kill Road, and every time I walk in, I can smell the yummy bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always help me pick out the best bagel. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or sit down and enjoy it!
What really makes Top Bagels special is their awesome variety and great prices. They have so many different bagels to choose from! My favorite is the garlic bagel with cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really makes my day!
If you’re super hungry, you should try their breakfast sandwich. It’s made with fresh ingredients and is perfect for a yummy start to your morning. I always leave feeling full and happy!
6. Plaza Bagels and Deli
Plaza Bagels and Deli is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right in New Dorp Plaza, and every time I walk in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel right at home. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or sit down and enjoy it there!
What really makes Plaza Bagels and Deli special is their yummy choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels and toppings! My favorite is the everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s so flavorful and makes my breakfast feel extra special!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast platter. It has a little bit of everything, and it’s perfect for a filling meal. I always leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
7. Forest Bagels
Forest Bagels is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Forest Avenue, and every time I walk in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel right at home. I love how cozy and friendly it feels inside!
What really makes Forest Bagels special is their yummy choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels to pick from! My favorite is the poppy seed bagel with cream cheese. It’s so tasty and always makes my breakfast feel extra special!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast sandwich. It’s made with fresh ingredients and is perfect for starting your day. I always leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
8. Bagels Bread & Butter
Bagels Bread & Butter is one of my favorite places to get a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Forest Avenue, and every time I walk in, I can smell the yummy bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel so welcome. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or sit down and enjoy it!
What really makes Bagels Bread & Butter special is their awesome choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels and spreads! My favorite is the blueberry bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and creamy, and it always makes my morning feel extra special!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast burrito. It’s filled with all kinds of tasty stuff and is perfect for a yummy meal. I always leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
9. Bagels By the Bay
Phone: (718) 815-4447
Menu: bagel-bythe-bay.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagels By the Bay is one of my favorite places to get a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Bay Street, and every time I walk in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel so welcome. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or sit down and enjoy it there!
What really makes Bagels By the Bay special is their yummy choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels to pick from! My favorite is the sesame bagel with cream cheese. It’s crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, and it always makes my breakfast feel extra special!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast sandwich. It’s made with fresh ingredients and is perfect for starting your day. I always leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
10. Clove Road Bagels
Phone: (718) 727-6000
Menu: order.online
Directions: Open on Map
Clove Road Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel on Staten Island! It’s right on Clove Road, and every time I walk in, I can smell the fresh bagels baking. The staff is super nice, and they always make me feel so welcome. I love that I can either take my bagel to go or sit down and enjoy it!
What really makes Clove Road Bagels special is their yummy choices and great prices. They have so many different bagels to pick from! My favorite is the onion bagel with cream cheese. It’s so tasty and always makes my breakfast feel extra special!
If you’re really hungry, you should try their breakfast sandwich. It’s made with fresh ingredients and is perfect for starting your day. I always leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
Map of Bagels in Staten Island, NY
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAGELS R US | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering | Moderate | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | No |
| Bagels N’ Buns | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Top Bagels | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Plaza Bagels and Deli | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Forest Bagels | Inexpensive | No | No | No | Accessible | – |
| Bagels Bread & Butter | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagels By the Bay | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | – | – |
| Clove Road Bagels | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What are the best bagel shops in Staten Island?
Some of the best bagel shops in Staten Island are Bagels R Us, Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering, and Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe. Each place has yummy bagels and lots of tasty toppings to choose from! -
Do bagel shops in Staten Island offer delivery?
Yes, many bagel shops, like Bagels R Us and Bagels N’ Buns, do delivery! It’s super easy to get your favorite bagels without leaving your house. -
What types of bagels can I find in Staten Island?
You can find all kinds of bagels in Staten Island! There are classic ones like plain and everything, plus fun flavors like jalapeño cheddar and blueberry. There’s something for everyone! -
Are there vegetarian or vegan options at bagel shops?
Yes, lots of bagel shops have vegetarian and vegan options! You can get bagels with fresh veggies, spreads, and even vegan cream cheese. -
What is the average price of a bagel in Staten Island?
The average price of a bagel is usually pretty cheap, around $1 to $2 for a plain bagel. Specialty bagels and toppings might cost a little more, but they’re so worth it! -
Can I order bagels for catering events in Staten Island?
Absolutely! Many bagel shops, like Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering, offer catering for events. You can order a bunch of bagels and spreads to make your party extra special. -
What are the most popular bagel toppings?
Some of the most popular toppings are cream cheese, lox, butter, and different spreads. You can also add fresh veggies or even egg and cheese for a yummy meal!
