Hunting for the best bagels in Sioux Falls, SD is a journey worth taking—especially if you know where to look. I’ve spent mornings following the scent of fresh-baked dough wafting from unexpected corners, and more than once found myself standing in line, coffee in hand, speculation high: Would today’s bagel reach that harmonious blend of soft, chewy, and golden? A well-made bagel feels almost like a local secret in Sioux Falls, hidden among breakfast chains and fast fare.
Some bakeries tuck in surprises, others stick to tradition, and the best leave you debating whether to go classic or chase something new. If you’re tired of settling for mediocrity, you’re in the right place. This guide filters out the fuss for genuine flavor and comfort in every bite, so you can skip the guessing and get straight to the best. Ready for a bagel experience that’s more than just bread with a hole? Let’s dive into the true standouts.
1. Bagel Boy
Bagel Boy on Minnesota Avenue is Sioux Falls’ essential stop for bagel lovers. There’s a cozy, lived-in feel as you walk in. You’ll see regulars nodding at each other over steaming cups and perfectly baked rounds. My first bite here was enough to make me a repeat visitor.
What makes Bagel Boy stand out is their dedication to freshness. The bagels come out warm, their crust just crisp enough to crack, revealing a satisfyingly chewy inside. Every batch feels like it was made with serious care—a rarity these days.
Their egg bagel, with a hint of sweetness, is a staple. Add a schmear of veggie cream cheese, and you’ve got a classic that’s hard to beat. For something heartier, a sesame bagel with lox, capers, and red onion is proof that simple can be exceptional.
2. Einstein Bros Bagels
Einstein Bros Bagels on E 10th Street strikes a balance between convenience and variety. I remember dropping in on a morning when time was tight, and leaving with a box that didn’t last long in the car. Their biggest draw is the sheer range of bagels and spreads, which keeps the routine breakfast eater guessing.
The Everything Bagel is a local favorite for good reason. It’s covered edge-to-edge in seeds and spices, and holds up well to a thick schmear or a piled-high sandwich. If you’re after comfort, their classic plain bagel with honey almond cream cheese is as easygoing as it gets.
Einstein Bros has a knack for turning simple ingredients into creative options. It’s easy to see why it’s always busy—the promise of something familiar, with a twist, brings people back.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find fresh bagels in Sioux Falls?
Bagel Boy and Einstein Bros Bagels both serve fresh, high-quality bagels every morning. Locals trust these spots for bagels that taste like they were just pulled from the oven.
What makes a great bagel?
A great bagel balances a slightly crisp crust with a dense, chewy center. Sioux Falls bakers focus on traditional techniques and fresh ingredients, so you get authentic flavor in every bite.
Are there vegetarian bagel options?
Yes, both Bagel Boy and Einstein Bros offer plenty of vegetarian bagel varieties. Popular choices include everything, plain, sesame, and a range of veggie cream cheeses.
Can I get bagels for a group or catering?
Both shops offer bagel boxes, bulk orders, and catering menus—perfect for meetings or family brunches. It’s best to call ahead for custom orders or larger parties.