If you find yourself in Shirley, NY, and a craving for bagels strikes, you’re in luck. This small town may not boast a multitude of options, but the bagel shops here are rich in flavor and tradition. Picture this: a morning where the sun peeks through your window, and the smell of freshly baked bagels wafts through the air. The warmth of a chewy, perfectly boiled bagel topped with cream cheese or smoked salmon can turn an ordinary breakfast into a delightful experience. Here, we’ll explore the best bagel spots that deliver just that.
As someone who has savored the local bagel scene, I can assure you that these establishments offer much more than mere sustenance; they serve a slice of community. You’ll find friendly faces and passionate bakers who take pride in their craft, each bite reflecting their dedication. Ready to embark on a journey through Shirley’s finest bagels? Let’s dive into the first standout shop that might just become your new favorite breakfast stop.
1. Strathmore Bagels
Strathmore Bagels, tucked along Montauk Highway, is a no-frills spot that nails the essentials—fresh, chewy bagels with just the right bite. The moment you step in, the aroma of dough boiling and baking pulls you in like a magnet. Their bagels have that perfect balance of crisp crust and soft interior, a rare find even in bagel-saturated Long Island.
What sets Strathmore apart is their consistency. Whether you grab a plain, everything, or sesame, each one is reliably excellent. Their veggie cream cheese, thick and tangy, clings to the bagel without overpowering it. For a hearty breakfast, try their bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel—the salt and seeds amplify the smoky bacon, making it a local favorite.
Vegetarians and vegans aren’t left out, either. The avocado toast on a toasted multigrain bagel, topped with sprouts and a squeeze of lemon, is a bright, satisfying option. Pair it with their cold-brew for a morning that starts right.
2. Freshy Fresh Bagels
Freshy Fresh Bagels on Montauk Highway is a hidden gem that serves up some of the most authentic bagels in Shirley. The moment you walk in, the warm aroma of freshly baked dough hits you, setting the tone for a satisfying meal. The cozy, no-frills atmosphere makes it a local favorite, where you can grab a quick bite or enjoy a leisurely breakfast.
What truly sets Freshy Fresh apart is their commitment to tradition. Their bagels are hand-rolled and boiled to perfection, giving them that chewy texture that bagel enthusiasts crave. The everything bagel here is a standout—loaded with just the right amount of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, and salt. Pair it with a generous spread of scallion cream cheese for a classic combination that’s hard to beat.
For something a bit different, try their cinnamon raisin bagel with a light schmear of honey cream cheese. It’s a sweet and savory twist that’s both refreshing and indulgent. Whether you’re a bagel purist or an adventurer, Freshy Fresh Bagels delivers quality and flavor that keeps locals coming back for more.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best places for bagels in Shirley, NY?
Strathmore Bagels and Freshy Fresh Bagels are highly recommended spots. Both offer fresh, handcrafted bagels with a variety of toppings and spreads. They’re local favorites that serve up authentic bagel experiences.
2. What types of bagels can I find in Shirley?
You can find a wide range of classic and specialty bagels, including everything, sesame, poppy, plain, cinnamon raisin, and more. Both Strathmore and Freshy Fresh take pride in their traditional recipes, ensuring a perfect balance of crunch and chew.
3. Are there vegetarian or vegan options available?
Yes, many options are vegetarian-friendly. Strathmore Bagels offers vegan choices like avocado toast on a multigrain bagel, and both shops provide a variety of cream cheeses and spreads that cater to different dietary preferences. It’s best to check with the specific location for vegan options.
4. Do the bagel shops in Shirley offer anything besides bagels?
Absolutely! Both Strathmore and Freshy Fresh offer a variety of breakfast and lunch items. You can enjoy classic combinations like lox with cream cheese or eggs, as well as more unique offerings like avocado toast and specialty sandwiches.
5. What’s the best time to visit for the freshest bagels?
Early mornings are the best time to visit for the freshest bagels, as they’re typically baked throughout the morning. Getting there early ensures you get your favorite varieties before they sell out.
6. Can I order bagels online or get them delivered?
It’s best to check directly with the shops for their current ordering options. Some may offer online ordering or delivery through third-party services, while others might focus on in-store pickup to maintain freshness.
