In Seaford, bagels aren’t just breakfast; they’re a daily rite. Long Island’s coastal breeze might get all the headlines, but ask any local and they’ll tell you—the real secret of the town is hidden behind bakery doors. Seaford’s bagel scene swings from classics with a crackle to soft rounds packed with creative fillings. I’ve circled these bakeries for years, sometimes out of habit, sometimes out of curiosity, always in search of that satisfying chew and perfect crumb. If you think all bagels taste the same, a weekend in Seaford will quickly change your mind.
Finding the “best” bagel is personal, but having taste-tested my way through Seaford’s favorites, I can promise each spot on this list earns its place. Whether you crave a no-nonsense sesame or something with a little flair, the town’s bagel shops deliver. Keep reading to discover the places where the lines form early and everyone insists their toppings really are the best. Your new favorite bagel may be one you’ve never tried.
Where to find the best bagels in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Seaford, NY:
- Mamma’s Bagels
- Seaford Bagels
- Calvert Manor Bagels Inc
- Dunkin’
- Bagel Plaza
- L & E Bagels
- Bagel Cafe
- The Bread Box Bakery Cafe
- The Crazy Bagel
- Stuff A Bagel
1. Mamma’s Bagels
(516) 809-6590Call
Mamma’s Bagels feels like the heartbeat of Seaford’s mornings. The moment you step inside, there’s this warm, savory aroma that says you’re in good hands. I’ve stopped here before an early train—always greeted with a smile and a swift line that never feels rushed. The bagels have a just-right crust and that pillowy chew every New Yorker swears by.
What really sets Mamma’s apart is their signature egg everything bagel. It’s savory, textured, and pairs perfectly with their whipped cream cheese or fresh Nova Scotia salmon for those who keep it classic. Their bagels are satisfying on their own, but a bacon, egg, and cheese (no haram included) from here always seems to beat the ordinary.
If you want something sweet, their cinnamon raisin is a solid pick—never dry, packed with plump fruit. Mamma’s Bagels keeps things unpretentious yet spot-on, a rare combo in Seaford.
2. Seaford Bagels
Seaford Bagels sits right on Merrick Road, quietly claiming a loyal morning crowd. I always appreciate how you don’t have to circle for parking—there’s plenty, and the vibe is relaxed. The bagels here come out warm, golden, and cut with precision—no flimsy rounds in sight.
If you like your bagels with a bit of heft, Seaford Bagels delivers. Their whole wheat bagel with scallion cream cheese is a stand-out—dense but tender, with a smack of flavor that makes early starts worthwhile. Their spreads and toppings always seem fresher than most, and the prices are gentle on your wallet.
The lineup of classic choices is long, but I’ve found the sesame with veggie cream cheese hits the mark every time. Seaford Bagels keeps it simple, and sometimes, that’s exactly what works best.
3. Calvert Manor Bagels Inc
(516) 798-9540Call
Calvert Manor Bagels Inc sits just off Hicksville Road, tucked into a spot that’s easy to miss unless you know what you’re looking for. My first visit was on a local’s tip, and I’ve been grateful ever since. Here, bagels are fresh from the oven—hot, satisfyingly dense, and never skimping on flavor or size.
The shop is unfussy, the kind of place where regulars chat with the staff and orders fly off the counter. If you want a true taste, try their classic poppy bagel with vegetable cream cheese. The seeds add the right crunch, and their spread is smooth with just enough bite from the veggies.
For lunch, their tuna salad on a salt bagel is another highlight—always fresh, never mushy. Calvert Manor shines through its simple, honest approach and clearly knows what makes a bagel great.
4. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ in Seaford is sometimes where mornings start before your eyes are even open. Consistency runs the show here. Whether you’re dashing through the drive-thru or grabbing a table, the bagels always show up warm and dependable. There’s a certain comfort knowing what awaits—no surprises, just that classic Dunkin’ spin.
I’ve popped in for a quick breakfast while on the go and found their plain bagel with cream cheese hits the spot—simple and satisfying, especially paired with their signature coffee. If you’re after something heartier, their multigrain bagel with veggie cream cheese keeps things light but filling. The convenience factor can’t be overstated. You’re in and out, coffee in hand, ready for anything.
Dunkin’ isn’t about bagel artistry, but it always answers the call for a no-fuss breakfast in Seaford.
5. Bagel Plaza
Bagel Plaza in Merrick sits just over the border from Seaford, and it’s worth every extra mile. It’s the kind of place where the scent of fresh bagels seems to follow you from the parking lot. I’ve made detours here on lazy Sunday mornings, always drawn by their impressively varied bagel selection and the steady hum of regulars catching up over coffee.
The standout dish? Their everything bagel with light veggie spread piles on flavor without weighing you down. You’ll also find their pumpernickel rounds and bialys are fresher than most, chewy with a hint of malt. It’s that classic New York taste—rich and unmistakably authentic.
If you’re feeding a crowd, their boxed dozens and flavored whipped spreads make weekday breakfasts feel a bit celebratory. Bagel Plaza thrives on tradition and that’s what keeps me coming back.
6. L & E Bagels
(516) 679-9575Call
L & E Bagels sits quietly on Jerusalem Ave, but there’s nothing subtle about the bagels coming out of their ovens. I’ve grabbed breakfast here between errands and each time walked away impressed. Their bagels bring that spot-on New York chew—crisp exterior, tender bite, never doughy.
What keeps people coming back is the obvious care that goes into every order. The egg bagel with scallion cream cheese is a favorite of mine—fluffy, rich, and balanced by the mild onion. They offer a full spread of classic bagels, all done with consistency.
If you like tradition, the sesame bagel with a shmear hits all the right nostalgic notes. L & E Bagels is reliable, quick, and always delivers a quality fix.
7. Bagel Cafe
(516) 541-1304Call
Bagel Cafe on Merrick Road is one of those spots where the smell of fresh baking drifts out to the parking lot. My weekend ritual often brings me here, where the lineup is proof you’re in the right place. The bagels are hand-rolled, glossy, and served up warm with a side of friendly service—always appreciated when you haven’t had your coffee yet.
Their plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese is a classic—airy inside, just enough crust, and loaded with flavor. For something heartier, the whole wheat bagel with a scoop of whitefish salad is always a winner—never dry, always balanced.
Bagel Cafe keeps things simple but hits all the notes you want in a New York bagel shop. Come hungry, leave happy, and you’ll understand why locals keep coming back.
8. The Bread Box Bakery Cafe
(516) 557-2327Call
The Bread Box Bakery Cafe puts kettle-boiled bagels front and center, and the difference is clear with every bite. My first trip landed me in front of a baker rolling dough by hand—the kind of old-school detail you spot at a glance. The exterior is crisp, the inside is dense but soft, without the heavy aftertaste you’ll find elsewhere.
If you’re after pure bagel joy, go for the sesame or onion bagel with their house-made scallion cream cheese. The spreads are fresh, inventive, and loaded with flavor, never cloying or bland.
Every visit feels like you’re getting something crafted by someone who loves the process. The Bread Box doesn’t just serve bagels; it shows how much better they can be.
9. The Crazy Bagel
The Crazy Bagel lives up to its name with variety and personality, right down to the mini bagels that always tempt me to order more than I planned. My last visit turned into an impromptu bagel tasting—no regrets. The bagels are soft yet hearty, and the flavors run the gamut from classic to creative without ever feeling overdone.
The standout here is their cinnamon raisin bagel with walnut raisin cream cheese. The sweet tang of raisins paired with the crunch of walnuts is pure comfort food, especially when you want something a little different.
Breakfast is served all day, making this spot perfect for an anytime bagel fix. The Crazy Bagel keeps things fun without sacrificing quality and always leaves you satisfied.
10. Stuff A Bagel
(516) 541-7415Call
Stuff A Bagel in Massapequa has become a staple for those who prize variety and value. I’ve ordered delivery here more times than I can count, and it’s always reliable—even during the busiest weekend mornings. The bagels come out with a golden crust and airy, flavorful middles that hint at decades of baking experience.
Go for their everything bagel topped with a generous layer of their homemade vegetable cream cheese. This pairing shows off Stuff A Bagel’s knack for freshness and balanced seasoning, never skimping on the details.
If you want to try something heartier, their egg bagel loaded with a scoop of whitefish salad is satisfying without being heavy. Free delivery adds extra convenience, and the friendly service seals the deal.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best bagel shops in Seaford, NY?
Popular spots include Mamma’s Bagels, Seaford Bagels, and Calvert Manor Bagels Inc. All deliver fresh, classic options with plenty of variety for every taste.
Are there bagel shops in Seaford with good vegetarian options?
Yes, almost every local bagel shop in Seaford offers vegetarian-friendly spreads and sandwiches. Try veggie cream cheese or ask about fresh salads available as fillings.
Do Seaford bagel shops offer gluten-free bagels?
Some shops may offer gluten-free bagels. It’s best to call ahead to check availability as options can vary by day and location.
Can I find authentic New York-style bagels in Seaford?
Absolutely—Seaford’s bagel shops take pride in traditional recipes. Expect dense, chewy bagels with a crisp outer crust, all made on site every morning.
Which bagel flavor is most popular in Seaford?
Everything and sesame bagels top the list, often paired with classic cream cheese or smoked salmon—simple, but reliably delicious.
Do shops in Seaford offer catering or delivery?
Many, such as Stuff A Bagel and The Crazy Bagel, offer catering and delivery. Perfect for group breakfasts or events when you need a reliable spread.