Finding a great bagel in Santa Cruz is a little like striking gold on West Cliff Drive—there’s something magical about the hunt and the reward is always delicious. If you’ve ever stood in line, inhaling the aroma from a fresh batch coming out of the oven, you know that not all bagels are created equal. In a town famous for coastal views and creative flair, the best bagels stand out for their chew, character, and unmistakable freshness.
After a morning wandering through the misty farmers market and biting into a warm, glossy bagel right out of the paper bag, I realized: bagel lovers here demand more than just bread with a hole. They crave real flavor and tradition. This guide is crafted for people like you—those who care about texture, taste, and a dash of local charm. Ready to discover where the true gems are hiding? Let’s get started.
1. Bagelry
Tucked away on Seabright Ave, Bagelry has been slinging classic bagels since 1977. Step inside and you’re immediately welcomed by a cozy, bustling vibe and the inviting aroma of bagels baking in the hearth. Kids chatter over breakfast, the coffee is hot, and the sense of community is strong.
What makes Bagelry stand out is its commitment to freshness and creativity. Every bagel has just the right chew and a crisp shell. You’ll find a variety of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, and their homemade chai has a flavor only possible with true care.
I always go for the Seabright Special—an everything bagel stacked with cream cheese, cucumber, tomato, and avocado. It’s a taste of Santa Cruz: fresh, simple, and satisfying.
2. Firefly Coffee House
Firefly Coffee House blends a neighborhood feel with the smell of fresh-baked bagels and rich, organic coffee. Tucked on Front Street, it’s a reliable spot for a quiet work morning or a quick catch-up with friends. Their staff always remembers regulars, and the vibe is always warm but unpretentious.
This café stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and local flair—all their coffee and chai are ethically sourced, and every bagel is baked daily. The star here is Caitlin’s bagels, which take a proud place in the pastry case each morning, golden and enticing.
The top pick is the simple sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese. It’s chewy, fresh, and pairs perfectly with their signature chai. Here, the bagel isn’t just a base; it’s a feature.
3. Bagelry
Right in the heart of downtown, Bagelry on Cedar Street is a Santa Cruz institution. The aroma of freshly baked, hearth-boiled bagels drifts through the air, pulling you in before you reach the door. The energy here buzzes with locals mixing in for coffee, quick lunches, or a lazy brunch.
What sets this spot apart is the classic artistry of their bagels. You’ll spot hand-rolled shapes lined up behind the glass, plus a spread menu that’s creative without being fussy. Their in-house chai and roasted coffee make it easy to linger and savor the flavors.
I’m partial to the garden veggie bagel sandwich—a thick layer of veggies and a slap of house-made hummus. It’s more than a meal; it’s a taste of old-school Santa Cruz.
4. The Bagelry
The Bagelry downtown pulls you right in with a whiff of freshly baked dough and a steady line of regulars who know exactly what they want. It’s an old-school spot that keeps things simple—no flash, just honest, quality bagels at great prices.
The hand-shaped bagels are the star, offering a chewy bite and a crispy shell every time. You won’t find distractions from the core offering, and that’s the charm. It’s a place suited for both grab-and-go and slow, quiet mornings with coffee.
If you’re wondering where to start, the classic poppy seed bagel with scallion cream cheese is a go-to. It’s nostalgic, filling, and a testament to The Bagelry’s focused craft.
5. Noah’s New York Bagels
(831) 454-9555Call
Noah’s New York Bagels brings a bit of East Coast tradition to the heart of downtown Santa Cruz. With a sprawling menu and an energetic, casual atmosphere, it’s a consistent spot for both locals and visitors. I’ve stopped in more than once for a quick breakfast before wandering Pacific Avenue’s shops.
Noah’s stands out with its reliable bagel selection—classic flavors, inventive spreads, and made-to-order sandwiches that hit the spot whether you’re craving breakfast or lunch. Their fast service makes it easy to grab something satisfying on a busy day.
The egg and cheese bagel sandwich on a toasted asiago bagel is always a solid bet. It’s filling, flavorful, and a Dallas of New York attitude right here on the coast.
6. Dunkin’
(848) 702-3613Call
Dunkin’ on Ocean Street is where convenience meets comfort. It’s familiar, friendly, and a staple for anyone who wants something quick before hitting the bustle of east Santa Cruz. I’ve ducked in for coffee and a bite more times than I can count, and it’s always a smooth experience.
Dunkin’ stands out for its dependability—you know exactly what you’re getting, which is sometimes all you need. The staff moves fast even when the morning crowd picks up, and the bagels are always warm and ready.
If you want a reliable classic, try the plain bagel with veggie cream cheese. It’s simple, soft, and pairs well with their signature coffee for that satisfying, no-fuss breakfast Santa Cruz mornings are made of.
7. Main Street Bagel
Just over the Santa Cruz city line in Capitola sits Main Street Bagel, a cheerful neighborhood spot known for its bustling mornings and generous bagel selection. You’ll find regulars chatting near sunlit windows, always with coffee and a bagel in hand. I’ve enjoyed many laid-back mornings here, savoring bites between sips of fresh brew.
Main Street Bagel stands out for its wide variety and consistently fresh options. Bagels are baked fresh daily, with enough choices to keep even indecisive eaters happy. The shop’s charm lies in its homespun feel and speedy, friendly service.
My go-to order is the spinach bagel with plain cream cheese. It’s hearty and flavorful, a satisfying pick that really shows off their commitment to freshness and quality.
8. House of Bagels
(831) 438-8280Call
House of Bagels in Scotts Valley keeps things classic and dependable, just the way locals prefer. Tucked into Kings Village Shopping Center, it’s a spot where the bagels are always fresh, affordable, and plentiful. I’ve swung by for a morning bite and found the line moves quickly—no rush, just the gentle pace of a true neighborhood bakery.
Here, you get a sense of tradition. Bagels are baked daily, and the case is always full, from classic plain to seeded favorites. The prices are easy on the wallet, so it’s tempting to grab a second for later.
I recommend the whole wheat bagel with house-made veggie spread. It’s wholesome, chewy, and delivered with that old-fashioned friendliness that makes you want to stick around for another coffee.
9. Bagel Cafe
Bagel Cafe in Watsonville is a bright corner for bagel lovers looking for something a little different. The shop has a welcoming, relaxed vibe that makes it easy to linger over a pastry and a cup of coffee. I’ve stopped in for breakfast and always found the service fast and the bagels impressively fresh.
What sets Bagel Cafe apart is their inventive flavors and generous sandwich options. You’ll spot creative bagel varieties lined up behind the counter, and custom sandwiches made to order. Their selection keeps regulars coming back just to see what’s new that day.
I recommend trying their jalapeño cheddar bagel with hummus and crisp veggies. It’s bold, a little spicy, and the perfect reflection of Bagel Cafe’s playful twist on the Santa Cruz bagel scene.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular bagel spots in Santa Cruz?
Favorites include Bagelry, Firefly Coffee House, Noah’s New York Bagels, and several local cafes north and south of the city. Each has its own charm, so it’s worth trying a few.
Where can I find vegan or vegetarian bagels in Santa Cruz?
Most shops, like Bagelry and Firefly Coffee House, offer vegan and vegetarian options—think house-made spreads and plenty of fresh veggie toppings.
Which bagel shops have gluten-free options?
Some spots carry gluten-free bagels, but choices vary. Call ahead to places like Main Street Bagel or Bagel Cafe to check what’s fresh that day.
Are there places to sit and enjoy bagels with coffee?
Absolutely. Bagelry, Firefly, and most local cafes have indoor and outdoor seating if you want to slow down and savor your bagel and a hot drink.
What’s a must-try bagel flavor in Santa Cruz?
The everything bagel is the go-to for locals, but adventurous eaters should seek out seasonal flavors or the spicy jalapeño cheddar for something with more kick.