Bagels in Roslyn Heights are not just about breakfast—they’re a quiet obsession. In this part of Long Island, people know the difference between a decent bagel and a perfect one, and they won’t settle for less. I’ll never forget biting into a fresh, hand-rolled bagel from a tiny bakery near Mineola Avenue. The crust had just the right chew, the inside was soft, and the aroma lingered long after the last bite. You don’t need to search endlessly—answers are all right here.
This guide captures the real standouts among Roslyn Heights’ bagel spots. Whether your loyalty leans classic or you’re on the hunt for something new, you’ll find the contenders that locals quietly brag about. Each entry is based on firsthand visits, real recommendations, and careful research, so you can be confident your next bagel is worth the carbs. Craving the best in town? You’re about to discover where to start.
Where to find the best bagels in Roslyn Heights, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Roslyn Heights, NY:
- Bagel Boss
- 113Mineola Avenue Inc
- Stuff Steffs
- Barbara’s Bagels
- Dunkin’
- Slims Bagels and Bialys
- Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
- Let There Be Bagels
- Greenvale Bagels
- Bagelman Of Mineola
1. Bagel Boss
(516) 626-5599Call
Bagel Boss in Roslyn Heights takes bagel-making seriously. The aroma hits before you’ve opened the door, and the first bite tells you you’re somewhere that values tradition. My favorite visit involved a still-warm sesame bagel, smeared with their rich, whipped cream cheese—simple, fresh, and unmistakably New York.
This shop offers a kosher menu and is entirely nut-free, which brings peace of mind for many locals. Gluten-free and vegan options ensure everyone gets a seat at the table. Each bagel is dense and chewy, with that classic snap when you break it open.
Try the classic everything bagel with scallion cream cheese or their signature egg bagel—these are the picks that showcase their craft. If you’re after a quick lunch, their salads and homemade soups make an easy pair.
2. 113Mineola Avenue Inc
(516) 484-3245Call
113Mineola Avenue Inc doesn’t need a flashy sign or endless menu to make its mark. This is the local go-to for pure, unfiltered bagel satisfaction. I first stopped in after a long walk, and the plain bagel—fresh out of the oven—needed nothing more than a swipe of butter.
The vibe here is no-nonsense and efficient. Bagels are done the old-school way, and everyone behind the counter seems to know exactly what you need. If you’re looking for trendy toppings, you’ll have to look elsewhere—this spot is about pure bagel nostalgia.
Order the onion bagel or poppy seed with a schmear. Their simplicity is their strength, and that’s why regulars keep coming back.
3. Stuff Steffs
(516) 625-1576Call
Stuff Steffs is a bit off the main road, but once you find it, you’ll wonder how you ever missed it. This spot is beloved by locals for imaginative bagel sandwiches and friendly service. I once tried their jalapeño bagel loaded with vegetable cream cheese—spicy, fresh, and satisfying.
The vibe inside is low-key and personal, with a staff that remembers your name the second time you visit. People line up for stuffed bagels stacked with fresh veggies and classic spreads, always made to order and generously filled.
Order a multigrain bagel with tomato and their tangy house-made cream cheese. The unique combinations set Stuff Steffs apart from more traditional shops in Roslyn Heights.
4. Barbara’s Bagels
Barbara’s Bagels feels like a neighborhood secret everyone actually knows about. The cozy shop draws early morning crowds—always a good sign. My first visit saw me torn between the cinnamon raisin and classic sesame. The friendly counter staff convinced me to try both. No regrets.
What separates Barbara’s is the balance: bagels are soft inside but hold their crisp shell until the last bite. Every bagel is hand-rolled and baked fresh, which explains the devoted following. You taste the attention in every chew.
The cinnamon raisin bagel with plain cream cheese is a hidden gem, as is the everything bagel, which bursts with seeds and flavor. Pair either with a coffee for a morning that just feels right.
5. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ has a spot in Roslyn Heights for those who crave fast, friendly service and consistent quality. It’s the kind of place where your coffee order is remembered and your bagel is always fresh. I once stopped by during a morning rush; in minutes, I had a toasted bagel in hand and was back on my way.
While Dunkin’ is known for its coffee, their bagels shouldn’t be overlooked. You get quick service, affordable prices, and bagels with just the right amount of chew—perfect for a grab-and-go breakfast.
The classic plain or everything bagel with a schmear of cream cheese never disappoints. For something heartier, try a bagel with egg and cheese. It’s simple, reliable, and hits the spot when you’re on the move.
6. Slims Bagels and Bialys
Slims Bagels and Bialys sits just outside Roslyn Heights, but it’s worth the short drive. The first thing you notice is the old-school feel—cash only, brisk service, and bagels made by hand. My weekend ritual used to include a salt bagel, still warm from the oven, enjoyed in the car while it was still quiet outside.
Slims is known for both bagels and bialys, the chewy cousin with a savory center. Bagels here are boiled, not steamed, with a crust that snaps and an interior that stays satisfyingly dense. The line moves fast and the regulars always know what they want.
Don’t miss the bialys, but a sesame bagel with vegetable cream cheese is also a winner. Slims keeps it classic, and that’s exactly why it shines.
7. Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
(516) 671-0100Call
Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe is tucked away on Glen Cove Ave, and the regulars wouldn’t have it any other way. This is where you find bagels baked throughout the morning—always fresh, never left sitting. My first time in, I had their whole wheat bagel with low-fat cream cheese and left feeling like I’d uncovered a local gem.
The staff here know bagels, offering everything from classic sesame to more adventurous twists. Prices are friendly, portions are generous, and the cafe atmosphere is relaxed enough to linger. Sea Cliff also offers catering if you want those same fresh bagels at your next event.
The everything bagel is a standout—well-seasoned and generously topped. Pair it with scallion cream cheese and a hot coffee for the full experience.
8. Let There Be Bagels
Let There Be Bagels in Port Washington is almost legendary for its bustling energy and endless bagel options. If you’re an early riser, you’ll see the line snaking out the door, a sure sign you’re in the right place. I still remember picking up a bakers’ dozen for a Sunday brunch—each bagel was piping hot, chewy, and fragrant.
What makes this spot stand out is the sheer variety, from classic poppy seed to creative flavors like pumpernickel. Every bagel is boiled and baked on-site, giving that old-fashioned crust and soft middle everyone wants.
The pumpernickel bagel with chive cream cheese is a must-try, especially if you want something a bit out of the ordinary. Grab a coffee and you’re set.
9. Greenvale Bagels
Greenvale Bagels has the air of a classic, family-run shop—no fuss, just great bagels. You’ll spot it off Glen Cove Road, where regulars chat over fresh coffee and morning specials. My personal favorite moment was an early stop for a sesame bagel loaded with light cream cheese, still warm from the oven.
This place stands out for its consistent quality at affordable prices. The bagels have a golden crust, a tender bite, and just enough chew to remind you why you stopped in. Service is unfussy and fast, perfect if you’re on your way to work or school.
Try the salt or sesame bagel with a generous schmear. You’ll taste the care that keeps locals returning each week.
10. Bagelman Of Mineola
Bagelman Of Mineola sits right on Jericho Turnpike, and it’s the first place that comes to mind when I want a bagel made with care. There’s a steady buzz here every morning, and the aroma of baking bagels fills the air. On my last visit, I grabbed a salt bagel with veggie cream cheese—simple, salty, and satisfying.
This shop impresses with its wide range of bagels and quick, helpful staff. Service is efficient, and the bagels have a hearty chew and that “just baked” freshness every time. Parking is easy, so there’s no excuse not to swing by.
Order a classic everything bagel or try the marble rye bagel for a twist. Pair it with one of their fresh spreads to see why Bagelman is a local favorite.
More Things to Try in Roslyn Heights, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a Roslyn Heights bagel unique?
Bagels in Roslyn Heights are known for their traditional boil-and-bake method, which gives them a chewy crust and soft interior. Many shops use recipes passed down for generations, making each bite distinct.
Are there kosher or nut-free bagel options in Roslyn Heights?
Yes, several local shops, such as Bagel Boss, offer kosher menus and are completely nut-free, providing peace of mind for families with dietary restrictions.
Where can I find vegan or gluten-free bagels?
Bagel Boss and some other bakeries offer vegan and gluten-free bagel choices so everyone can enjoy a fresh bagel, regardless of dietary needs.
Which bagel shops have the best variety of spreads?
Shops like Stuff Steffs and Let There Be Bagels are favorites for their creative cream cheese spreads and unique toppings. You’ll find everything from classic plain to inventive veggie blends.
Do any bagel spots in Roslyn Heights offer catering?
Yes, places like Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe and Bagel Boss provide catering platters, perfect for office breakfasts or weekend gatherings.
What is the best time to get fresh bagels?
For the freshest bagels, visit early in the morning. Most shops have their best selection right after opening, and you might even snag a bagel that’s still warm.