Finding the best bagels in Pueblo, CO, can feel like searching for a hidden treasure. Over the years, I’ve tasted my fair share of bagels—some fluffy, some dense, but only a few truly stand out. In this city tucked against Colorado’s scenic landscape, a handful of spots master the art of crafting bagels that are both satisfying and memorable. Whether you prefer your bagel toasted with cream cheese or loaded with savory toppings, Pueblo offers options waiting to satisfy every craving.
My journey to discover the top bagels here has been as delightful as it is flavorful. Each shop has its own unique twist, blending fresh ingredients and expert techniques. This article is meant to guide you through those gems—places that consistently deliver quality, flavor, and authenticity. Better bagels aren’t just about taste; they tell a story about the place and its people. Get ready to explore some of the finest bagel options in Pueblo, CO.
Where to find the best bagels in Pueblo, CO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Pueblo, CO:
1. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Located at 900 W Orman Ave, Einstein Bros. Bagels is a go-to spot for fresh-baked bagels in Pueblo. Whenever I visit, I’m always greeted by the warm aroma of oven-fresh bagels that instantly lift my mood. The variety here is impressive—from classic plain and everything bagels to unique flavors that keep things interesting. The shop’s friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect place for breakfast or a quick lunch.
What sets Einstein Bros. apart is their commitment to quality and freshness. Their bagels are perfectly chewy, with a golden crust—ideal for pairing with their rich shmears or making a breakfast sandwich with cage-free eggs. I recommend trying the Baker’s Dozen—a great way to sample different flavors—or the breakfast bagel sandwiches for a hearty start. Every bite reflects their dedication to crafting top-tier bagels that satisfy every time.
2. Blazin Bagels
(719) 569-7471Call
Nestled on Santa Fe Drive, Blazin Bagels is a local favorite that lives up to its fiery name with bold flavors and fresh ingredients. My first visit was a pleasant surprise—each bagel offered a perfect balance of chewiness and crispness, clearly made with care and skill. The shop’s casual vibe makes it a comfortable stop for breakfast or lunch in Pueblo.
Blazin Bagels stands out by blending traditional bagel-making with creative toppings and spreads. Their bagel sandwiches are especially noteworthy, packed with fresh vegetables, high-quality cheeses, and flavorful spreads. I recommend trying their signature bagel sandwich with cream cheese and fresh tomatoes, which highlights the freshness and quality of their ingredients. For those who appreciate a solid, well-crafted bagel with a touch of flair, Blazin Bagels won’t disappoint.
3. Dunkin’
Located at 3991 N Elizabeth Street, Dunkin’ has long been a reliable destination for bagels, coffee, and breakfast in Pueblo. My visits always start with the aroma of freshly brewed coffee—an inviting scene. Their wide selection of bagels, from plain to everything, is consistently fresh and soft, making them ideal for a quick breakfast or snack.
Dunkin’ stands out for its consistency and variety. Whether you choose a toasted bagel with cream cheese or a hearty breakfast sandwich, the quality remains high. I recommend their classic everything bagel with a smear of cream cheese—simple but satisfying. For those on the go, the convenience of ordering through the Dunkin’ app makes it easy to enjoy fresh bagels and coffee anytime.
More Things to Try in Pueblo, CO
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best fresh bagels in Pueblo, CO?
A: Some of the top places for fresh bagels in Pueblo include Einstein Bros. Bagels, Blazin Bagels, and Dunkin’. Each offers a variety of fresh-baked bagels with quality ingredients and unique flavors.
Q: What types of bagels are popular in Pueblo?
A: Classic options like plain, everything, and sesame are widely loved. Many shops also feature creative flavors and excellent bagel sandwiches with fresh toppings and spreads.
Q: Can I order bagels ahead in Pueblo?
A: Yes. For example, Dunkin’ offers ordering ahead through their app, making it convenient to pick up fresh bagels without waiting.
Q: Are there vegetarian-friendly bagel options?
A: Absolutely. Most bagel shops, including Einstein Bros. and Blazin Bagels, offer vegetarian spreads, cheeses, and vegetable toppings suitable for a meat-free diet.
Q: Do bagel shops in Pueblo serve breakfast sandwiches?
A: Yes. Many places feature breakfast sandwiches made with cage-free eggs, cheese, and fresh bagels, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.
Q: Are the bagels in Pueblo suitable for groups or events?
A: Yes. Places like Einstein Bros. Bagels offer baker’s dozen options, making it easy to cater to groups with fresh bagels and various spreads.