Best Bagels in Pittsburgh, PA

Pittsburgh, PA, has some of the best bagels I’ve ever tasted! Seriously, if you love bagels like I do, you’re in for a treat. The city is packed with amazing bagel shops that serve everything from classic flavors to super fun, creative ones. I can’t wait to share my favorites with you!

So, what are the best bagels in Pittsburgh, PA? Well, let me tell you, the best bagels can be found at a bunch of different places around the city. Each shop has its own special twist, whether it’s a traditional New York-style bagel or something totally unique. You’ll find a little bit of everything, and trust me, there’s something for everyone!

Stick around, and I’ll take you on a tasty adventure through the best bagel spots in Pittsburgh. You’ll learn all about their yummy offerings, cozy vibes, and what makes each place special. Get ready to find your new favorite bagel!

Top 10 Bagels in Pittsburgh, PA

1. Pigeon Bagels
2. Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal
3. Bagel Factory
4. Einstein Bros. Bagels
5. Three Brothers Bagels
6. Bruegger’s Bagels
7. Big Dog Coffee
8. Einstein Bros. Bagels
9. Bruegger’s Bagels
10. Bruegger’s Bagels

1. Pigeon Bagels

Pigeon Bagels is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! It’s located at 5613 Hobart St, and it’s such a cozy little spot. When I walk in, I feel right at home. They have so many yummy bagels, and you can get them one at a time or in a big bunch. Plus, they have cakes and hot drinks, which is super nice!

What I really love about Pigeon Bagels is how you can make your bagel just the way you like it. You can pick all kinds of toppings! I always go for the Everything Bagel with cream cheese and fresh veggies. It’s so tasty and really shows off how good their bagels are!

If you’re ever in the area, you have to try it out! It’s a fun place to enjoy a delicious bagel and maybe even a sweet treat too!

2. Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal

Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal is one of my go-to spots for bagels! It’s right at 3915 Butler St, and I just love how you can choose to sit inside or outside. The place has such a chill vibe, making it perfect for hanging out with friends or just enjoying a quiet moment with my bagel.

What really makes Brooklyn Bagel special is all the yummy flavors they have. Everything is super fresh, and I can never decide what to get! My favorite is the Plain Bagel with lox and cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever nearby, you’ve got to stop by! It’s a fun place to grab a delicious bagel and enjoy the nice atmosphere!

3. Bagel Factory

Bagel Factory is one of my favorite places to go for bagels! It’s at 5885 Forbes Ave, and I really like that you can sit inside or outside. The vibe is super friendly, and it’s a great spot to hang out with friends or just enjoy a quiet moment with my bagel.

What I love about Bagel Factory is all the yummy choices they have! They have so many different bagels and toppings, and everything is super fresh. My favorite is the Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and creamy, and it really shows how tasty their bagels are!

If you’re ever in the area, you should totally check it out! It’s a fun place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe even some coffee to go with it!

4. Einstein Bros. Bagels

Einstein Bros. Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! It’s at 436 Seventh Ave, and I really like that you can sit inside or outside. The place is always full of happy people, which makes it a fun spot to enjoy my bagel and maybe even chat with friends.

What I love about Einstein Bros. is all the yummy choices they have! They have so many different bagels and spreads, and everything is super fresh. My go-to is the Asiago Bagel with veggie cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever in the area, you should definitely stop by! It’s a perfect place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe a nice coffee too!

5. Three Brothers Bagels

Three Brothers Bagels is one of my favorite places to go! It’s at 1718 Mt Royal Blvd, and I really like that you can sit inside or outside. The vibe is always super friendly, and it feels like a great spot to enjoy a bagel with friends or just chill by myself.

What I love about Three Brothers Bagels is all the yummy choices they have! They have so many different bagels and toppings, and everything is super fresh. My favorite is the Spinach and Feta Bagel. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making delicious food.

If you’re ever in Glenshaw, you should totally check it out! It’s a fun place to grab a tasty bagel and enjoy the nice atmosphere!

6. Bruegger’s Bagels

Bruegger’s Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! It’s at 806 S Aiken Ave, and I really like how cozy it feels inside. The place is always full of happy people, which makes it a fun spot to enjoy my bagel and maybe chat with friends.

What I love about Bruegger’s is their small-batch, New York-style bagels. They are always fresh and super tasty! My go-to is the Sesame Bagel with cream cheese. It’s so yummy and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever in the area, you should totally stop by! It’s a perfect place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe even a breakfast sandwich to go with it!

7. Big Dog Coffee

Big Dog Coffee is one of my favorite little spots! It’s at 2717 Sarah St, and I just love how cozy it feels inside. You can sit inside or outside, which is super nice. The vibe is really chill, and it’s a great place to relax with a yummy drink and maybe a snack.

What I really like about Big Dog Coffee is all the yummy drinks and treats they have! Everything is super fresh and made with love. I usually get their delicious coffee and a tasty pastry. Their blueberry muffin is my absolute favorite because it’s so moist and bursting with flavor!

If you’re ever in the area, you should totally check it out! It’s a perfect place to grab a drink, enjoy a treat, and just hang out for a bit!

8. Einstein Bros. Bagels

Einstein Bros. Bagels is one of my favorite places to go for a bagel! It’s at 4910 Baum Blvd, and I really like how cozy it feels inside. You can sit inside or outside, and the place is always full of happy people, which makes it a fun spot to enjoy my bagel and maybe chat with friends.

What I love about Einstein Bros. is all the yummy choices they have! They have so many different bagels and spreads, and everything is super fresh. My go-to is the Spinach and Feta Bagel with cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever in the area, you should definitely stop by! It’s a perfect place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe a nice coffee to go with it!

9. Bruegger’s Bagels

Bruegger’s Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! It’s at 1801 E Carson St, and I really like how cozy it feels inside. The place is always full of happy people, which makes it a fun spot to enjoy my bagel and maybe chat with friends.

What I love about Bruegger’s is their small-batch, New York-style bagels. They are always fresh and super tasty! My go-to is the Everything Bagel with cream cheese. It’s so yummy and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever in the area, you should totally stop by! It’s a perfect place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe even a breakfast sandwich to go with it!

10. Bruegger’s Bagels

Bruegger’s Bagels is one of my favorite places to get a bagel! It’s at 531 Grant St, and I really love how cozy it feels inside. The place is always full of happy people, which makes it a fun spot to enjoy my bagel and maybe chat with friends.

What I really like about Bruegger’s is their small-batch, New York-style bagels. They are always fresh and super tasty! My favorite is the Everything Bagel with cream cheese. It’s so yummy and really shows how much they care about making great food.

If you’re ever in the area, you should definitely stop by! It’s a perfect place to grab a delicious bagel and maybe even a breakfast sandwich to go with it!

Map of Bagels in Pittsburgh, PA

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Shop	Price	Seating	Takeout	Delivery	Wheelchair	Reservation
Pigeon Bagels	Inexpensive	–	Yes	No	Accessible	No
Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	–	Accessible	No
Bagel Factory	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Einstein Bros. Bagels	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Three Brothers Bagels	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Bruegger’s Bagels	Inexpensive	–	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Big Dog Coffee	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
Einstein Bros. Bagels	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Bruegger’s Bagels	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Bruegger’s Bagels	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best bagel shops in Pittsburgh?
There are so many great bagel shops in Pittsburgh! Some of my favorites are Pigeon Bagels, Brooklyn Bagel at Arsenal, and Bruegger’s Bagels. Each place has its own yummy flavors and a nice vibe, making them fun spots to enjoy a bagel.

2. Are there any vegan or gluten-free bagel options in Pittsburgh?
Yes, lots of bagel shops in Pittsburgh have vegan and gluten-free options! It’s always a good idea to check the menu or just ask the friendly staff for what they have.

3. What are the typical prices for bagels in Pittsburgh?
Bagels in Pittsburgh are usually pretty cheap! They typically cost between $1 and $3 each, depending on where you go and what toppings you pick.

4. Can I get bagels delivered in Pittsburgh?
Absolutely! Many bagel shops in Pittsburgh offer delivery. You can check their websites or use food delivery apps to see if your favorite place delivers to you.

5. What are some popular bagel toppings?
Some really popular bagel toppings are cream cheese, lox, and avocado. You can also find fun toppings like hummus and fresh veggies at many shops, which makes your bagel even more delicious!