Finding a stellar bagel might seem simple. In Petaluma, it’s an enjoyable challenge. From the first time I bit into a toasted sesame bagel outside a corner shop here, the contrast between crisp crust and pillowy inside convinced me—good bagels are pure comfort and Petaluma has some gems. If you’re in search of that classic chew, or maybe something with inventive toppings, you’re in the right city.
Each bagel spot in Petaluma offers a signature twist: old-school deli vibes, creative schmears, or house-baked charm. As someone who’s wandered from bustling bagel shops in Brooklyn to lazy Sonoma mornings, I can say—Petaluma holds its own. With this guide, expect the fluff, the crunch, the flavor, and never a letdown. Ready to discover which bakery is serving up your future favorite?
1. Noah’s NY Bagels
Noah’s NY Bagels at 375 S. Mcdowell Blvd. is where the day kicks off with the smell of fresh-baked bagels. The lineup is broad—everything from traditional plain to poppy seed and sesame, all baked at sunrise. What catches my attention is their knack for getting that balance between chewy inside and crisp outside.
The double-whipped shmear is a must-try. One bite of that velvety spread on a warm bagel, and you’ll understand why locals keep coming back. If you need something heartier, go for a breakfast sandwich. The cage-free eggs elevate every bite, and you can taste the difference.
Those with more time should pair their bagel with coffee for the full experience. Noah’s makes takeout simple, or you can skip the line and order ahead.
2. The Bagel Mill
Craving a bagel that feels like it was crafted with care? The Bagel Mill on Western Ave hooks you from the doorway with the aroma of slow-fermented dough. This spot is a local favorite for a reason—they mill their own grains, so every bagel tastes impossibly fresh and hearty.
My personal standout? The classic sea salt or everything bagel—both toasted just right. Pair it with their chive cream cheese or a lox spread (minus any haram additions) if you’re feeling bold. The flavors are honest and robust, never bland.
The atmosphere is laid-back, making it easy to linger over that second cup of coffee. Whether dining in or grabbing a dozen to go, The Bagel Mill brings a handmade touch to every bite.
3. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ at Deer Creek Village is a staple for those who want bagels fast, fresh, and fuss-free. There’s comfort in knowing you can walk in, order a toasted bagel, and be out the door in minutes. Consistency is Dunkin’s secret weapon, so you always know exactly what to expect with every bite.
Their multigrain or cinnamon raisin bagels stand out, especially when paired with classic plain or veggie cream cheese. If you’re after something filling, the egg and cheese bagel sandwich keeps mornings on track. The texture leans soft, keeping things approachable for every palate.
Dunkin’ is where convenience meets a reliable breakfast. For those on a tight schedule, mobile ordering makes snagging your favorite bagel even easier.
4. Sonoma Valley Bagel
Sonoma Valley Bagel in Rohnert Park sits just outside Petaluma but garners loyal fans from both towns. On a lazy morning, I stopped by for a bagel and was pleasantly surprised by the quick service and the unmistakable scent of freshly baked dough. The place buzzes with regulars who swear by their unique blends and classic approach.
The everything bagel with chive cream cheese is a popular pick for a reason. Each bite has a satisfying chew, and the seeds are never overdone. Sonoma Valley Bagel pulls off the rare feat of being both unfussy and flavorful.
If you’re feeling adventurous, try their jalapeño bagel—or keep it simple with a sesame classic. Either way, you’re getting a bagel that’s sturdy, fresh, and always filling.
5. Ludukas Coffee and Bagels
(707) 664-5919Call
Ludukas Coffee and Bagels on Snyder Ln is a cozy hideaway where bagels and coffee really shine. On my last visit, the friendly staff and relaxed ambiance were a breath of fresh air. Here, it’s all about made-to-order freshness and a neighborhood feel you don’t always find elsewhere.
The plain and onion bagels are always spot on. Toasted, they deliver a satisfying crunch with a soft, warm center. Pair yours with a veggie cream cheese or a classic butter for that homemade vibe.
If you need a caffeine fix, their coffee drinks are no afterthought. Come for the bagels, stay for the relaxed pace—Ludukas is a true locals’ favorite in the bagel scene around Petaluma.
6. New York Bagels
New York Bagels on Commerce Blvd brings that classic city attitude to the North Bay. Walking in, you’ll notice the shelves stacked with a variety of bagels, all with that unmistakable New York-style shine. The energy is lively, and the bagels never disappoint.
The salt bagel or classic poppy seed is a standout—toasted and topped with their house cream cheese, it’s as close to the East Coast as you’ll get without leaving California. Every bite is chewy, with a golden crust that’s hard to beat.
If you want a true sample of their style, go for a dozen assorted. Each bagel offers that signature chew and depth of flavor that makes this spot a favorite with locals and transplants alike.
7. Sonoma Valley Bagel & Cafe
Sonoma Valley Bagel & Cafe makes bagel mornings simple and satisfying. I remember ducking in on a rainy day and finding the place bustling with cheerful chatter. Their bagels are made fresh and always feel sturdy enough to hold even the heartiest of toppings.
The spinach bagel is a local favorite, especially when paired with veggie cream cheese or avocado for a California spin. The texture walks that perfect line between chewy and soft, making each bite a reliable pleasure.
Prices are friendly, and the menu is broad enough to please everyone in your circle. If you want that neighborhood cafe feel with a solid lineup of classic and creative bagels, this is where you’ll want to start your morning.
8. Redwood Bagel Company
Redwood Bagel Company in Novato makes the short drive from Petaluma worth it. The atmosphere is low-key, perfect for starting your day at a slower pace. I popped in once mid-morning, and the smell alone had me hooked before I could even place my order.
The Asiago cheese bagel is a standout choice. It’s rich, subtly tangy, and crisped just enough at the edges. For something comforting and classic, their whole wheat or sesame bagels always deliver consistency with a hearty chew.
Pair your bagel with a simple black coffee and you’ll see why so many locals claim this spot. Redwood Bagel Company brings genuine flavor and a friendly touch to the area’s bagel scene.
9. Einstein Bros Bagels
Einstein Bros Bagels on Grant Ave delivers that familiar, friendly bagel sensation every time. I’ve ducked in more than once on a road trip, and it’s always the same—a warm greeting, plenty of seating, and bagels ready to go. Their menu is broad, but the bagel is always the star.
The honey whole wheat bagel is dependable and subtly sweet. Match it with their garden veggie or plain schmear for a balanced, satisfying breakfast. Each bagel boasts a soft crumb with a gently crisp shell, easy to enjoy on the move.
If you’re craving bigger flavors, try the Asiago or pretzel bagel for something different. Einstein Bros makes getting a quality bagel hassle-free whether you’re dining in or grabbing a dozen to share.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the freshest bagels in Petaluma?
Most bagel shops in Petaluma bake their bagels daily. Spots like The Bagel Mill and Noah’s NY Bagels are known for early morning freshness. For a just-out-of-the-oven taste, arrive shortly after opening.
Q: Which local bagel shops offer vegan or dairy-free options?
Many Petaluma bagel shops offer plain, sesame, or everything bagels free from animal products. Check with each shop, but The Bagel Mill and Sonoma Valley Bagel often have dairy-free spreads and toppings available.
Q: Can I get gluten-free bagels at Petaluma bakeries?
Some shops carry gluten-free options, though selection varies. It’s best to call ahead to check availability at spots like Noah’s NY Bagels or Einstein Bros Bagels.
Q: Which spot is best for a classic bagel-and-schmear combo?
For a classic setup, try New York Bagels or Noah’s NY Bagels. Their plain or everything bagels with cream cheese keep things simple, chewy, and satisfying.
Q: Are there family-friendly options for breakfast or lunch?
Almost every bagel shop in Petaluma caters to families. Sandwiches, bagels with spreads, and kid-friendly drinks make for an easy breakfast or lunch out.
Q: Do Petaluma bagel shops offer catering or large orders?
Yes, several shops like Noah’s NY Bagels and Redwood Bagel Company offer catering-sized orders and boxed breakfasts. Ordering ahead makes pick-up smooth for events or office mornings.