Bagels and Peach Lake might not seem like an obvious match, but the locals know better. There’s something about a Saturday morning here: crisp air, coffee in hand, and a fresh bagel that’s just the right balance of chew and crust. I’ve had bagels in most corners of New York, but few beat the cozy charm and top-tier craft found around Peach Lake.
Choosing where to grab your next bagel shouldn’t feel like a gamble. Through countless taste tests (the kind I take very seriously), I’ve narrowed down the best spots where bagel dreams meet reality. Whether you’re after a pillowy classic or something with a little midnight shine, you’ll find a bagel on this list to get excited about.
Where to find the best bagels in Peach Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Peach Lake, NY:
- JV Hot Bagels
- Empire Bagels
- Bagelman Inc
- Bronx Buns and Bread
- Bagel Shop
- Our Town Bagels & Bakery
- Somers Hot Bagels
- Daily Bagel Cafe
- Einstein Bros Bagels
- What About A Bagel
1. JV Hot Bagels
JV Hot Bagels sits in the heart of Brewster, close enough for Peach Lake locals to consider it their go-to spot. From the moment you step inside, the scent of fresh dough makes you forget about the world outside.
Consistency is where JV Hot Bagels wins. The texture hits the sweet spot: bagels are fluffy inside with a thin, golden crust. My early Sunday visits here often run into familiar faces, all quietly focused on their bagels. It’s a ritual for many, and the staff knows their regulars by name.
It’s hard to go wrong, but their classic sesame or everything bagels are perfect for a quick breakfast. Try them with their signature scallion cream cheese, which is always fresh and packed with flavor. For lunch, grab a turkey and avocado sandwich on a warm everything bagel. The quality here is in the details, and it shows with every bite.
2. Empire Bagels
Empire Bagels sits on Route 22, close enough for busy mornings or lazy weekends near Peach Lake. Walking in, you’re greeted by a bustle that feels more urban than suburban—a sign of loyal crowds who know where to find a good bagel.
The draw here is variety. My go-to is the whole wheat everything, toasted, matched with their homemade veggie cream cheese. The bagels have just the right density, and the flavors never overshadow the classic, yeasty bite.
Don’t sleep on their salt bagel, which offers a simple yet bold punch. For something heartier, the egg salad on a poppy seed bagel is a local favorite, with a fresh, savory balance you won’t find everywhere. Empire Bagels proves that a short drive from Peach Lake leads to New York-worthy classics.
3. Bagelman Inc
Bagelman Inc sits just over the state line in Danbury, making it a favorite for Peach Lake folks willing to travel for something special. Every visit starts with the inviting smell of fresh bakes and the hum of early morning regulars.
What sets Bagelman apart is their hand-rolled, generously sized bagels. Each one has a satisfying chew and a crisp shell that delivers on classic bagel expectations. I’m always impressed by the friendly crew behind the counter who seem to remember everyone’s preferred order.
The spinach bagel with plain cream cheese is a must-try for something a little different. If you’re after a hearty breakfast, snag a classic egg and cheese sandwich on a toasted whole wheat bagel. Bagelman turns a simple bagel run into a small event worth savoring.
4. Bronx Buns and Bread
(475) 329-5465Call
Bronx Buns and Bread is a hidden spot just a short drive from Peach Lake, with a reputation that spreads fast among those in the know. It’s the kind of bakery where the bagels are the real deal and the service is as warm as the ovens.
Texture is where Bronx Buns and Bread excels most. The bagels have that classic New York chew and a beautiful, glossy finish that beckons you from across the counter. Every order feels crafted with purpose rather than production.
The plain bagel here is anything but basic; it’s pillowy and perfect with a swipe of whipped cream cheese. For a slight twist, try the pumpernickel—it’s robust and not overly dense. Whatever you choose, you’ll taste a little slice of the city just minutes from Peach Lake.
5. Bagel Shop
(845) 363-1647Call
Bagel Shop on Route 22 in Brewster is a small, inviting stop for anyone near Peach Lake looking for a classic bagel fix. The vibe is always relaxed, perfect for a quick breakfast or a relaxed brunch with friends.
Freshness defines Bagel Shop. The bagels come out warm, with a golden exterior that cracks just right. I’ve stopped by on countless early mornings, and the quality never takes a day off.
Their everything bagel—with a generous spread of vegetable cream cheese—stands out for its balanced flavors and satisfying crunch. If you prefer something simple, grab a plain or cinnamon raisin bagel. Every bite tastes homemade, rooted in the kind of care that keeps regulars coming back.
6. Our Town Bagels & Bakery
(845) 803-8745Call
Our Town Bagels & Bakery feels like a slice of Mahopac’s heart, with roots sunk deep in local soil and connections to Peach Lake regulars. The owners, two sisters, built their bakery on family recipes and neighborhood spirit, making every visit feel familiar.
Homemade is the magic word here. The bagels are boiled and baked for that authentic, old-world bite. Freshness is a given, but it’s the friendly greetings and community buzz that keep me coming back.
The asiago bagel, paired with their silky scallion cream cheese, is a standout. If craving something sweet, their blueberry bagel is soft and bursting with flavor. Each order is made with care, perfect for those who want a real, local touch in every bite.
7. Somers Hot Bagels
(914) 628-4165Call
Somers Hot Bagels on Route 6 is a favorite pit stop for anyone rambling through Baldwin Place or heading from Peach Lake. It’s the kind of place where steamy mornings start and hungry drivers make a quick, happy detour.
Freshness and speed are Somers Hot Bagels’ trademarks. I love how the bagels are consistently hot from the oven, their exteriors crisp and interiors satisfyingly chewy. Even during the morning rush, the service moves faster than expected, with plenty of smiles behind the counter.
The salt bagel is a must for its crunch and simple, bold flavor—perfect with plain cream cheese. My personal favorite is their egg bagel, which is soft and stands up well to a spread of veggie cream cheese. Somers Hot Bagels keeps things easy and reliably tasty, every visit.
8. Daily Bagel Cafe
(845) 279-4255Call
Daily Bagel Cafe in Patterson is a welcoming spot where Peach Lake bagel lovers know they’ll get a reliable start to their day. It’s bright, spotless, and always filled with the irresistible aroma of fresh bakes.
What makes Daily Bagel Cafe memorable is their balanced bagel—soft inside, crisp on the outside, never too dense or doughy. There’s a personal touch here; even first-timers get greeted like locals.
The whole wheat everything bagel is a highlight, especially when paired with their rich, homemade hummus. If you want a classic New York breakfast, try an onion bagel with lox-style cream cheese and tomato. Each visit feels effortless and delicious—the kind of dependable comfort every town needs.
9. Einstein Bros Bagels
Einstein Bros Bagels, tucked away on White Street in Danbury, offers a familiar and inviting place for anyone cruising in from Peach Lake. Here, the pace is quick and the menu is vast, perfect for busy mornings or casual meet-ups.
The strength of Einstein Bros is the range and consistency. I’ve leaned on them many times when I needed a reliable, toasted bagel, and the staff always delivers with a smile. Everything bagels are chewy but light—never dense or overly salty.
The signature Honey Whole Wheat bagel is a strong choice, especially with their garden veggie shmear. If you’re in the mood for something sweet, the blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese pairs well with their café’s bright vibe. It’s a chain, but it never feels impersonal or rushed.
10. What About A Bagel
(203) 792-2435Call
What About A Bagel, just off Newtown Road in Danbury, is a local spot that packs plenty of charm and seriously good bagels. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your name—and your coffee order—by your second visit.
Their bagels are known for their subtle crispness and soft, chewy center. Early mornings here are a mix of regulars grabbing breakfast and families picking up fresh dozen for weekend brunch. What stands out is the attention paid to each order, no matter how busy it gets.
The spinach bagel with veggie cream cheese is especially fresh and filling, a favorite of mine after a Peach Lake hike. Those looking for a sweeter bite should try the cinnamon raisin bagel, which pairs beautifully with a classic schmear.
More Things to Try in Peach Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I get the best bagels near Peach Lake, NY?
A handful of local favorites stand out, including JV Hot Bagels in Brewster, Empire Bagels, and Our Town Bagels & Bakery in Mahopac. Each spot has its own unique style, so the best one depends on your taste—classic, creative, or loaded with toppings.
Are there any bagel shops in Peach Lake that offer gluten-free options?
Some area shops, like Empire Bagels and Bagelman Inc, often stock gluten-free bagels. It’s best to call ahead to confirm availability for the day, as gluten-free selections can sell out quickly.
What is the most popular type of bagel around Peach Lake?
Everything bagels and sesame bagels are always in high demand, but you’ll also find strong fans of specialty choices like asiago or blueberry bagels.
Do these bagel shops serve coffee or breakfast sandwiches?
Most bagel shops near Peach Lake offer fresh coffee, breakfast sandwiches, and a variety of classic spreads. JV Hot Bagels and Bagel Shop are especially known for hearty breakfast combos.
Is there a family-friendly bagel spot near Peach Lake?
Absolutely. Daily Bagel Cafe, What About A Bagel, and Einstein Bros Bagels all provide a relaxed, kid-friendly setting along with plenty of menu choices for little ones.