Bagels in Paramus are not just food—they’re an adventure through doughy comfort and subtle craftsmanship. I’ve eaten my way through Bergen County, bagel by bagel, and Paramus stands out. Maybe it’s the way the bagel shops fill with the warm scent of fresh bread just after sunrise, or how the perfect chew meets a golden crust every time. Paramus lives and breathes bagels, and you can taste that pride in every bite.
You don’t have to wander aimlessly or settle for something average. I’ve tracked down the standout spots, from the iconic corner classics to the hidden gems tucked behind strip malls. Whether you crave a sesame classic, a batch of mini bagels for sharing, or a vegan option, there’s a shop here that knows how to do it right. The list ahead isn’t just about bagels—it’s a guide for those who want to eat local, eat well, and experience the best bagels Paramus offers. Keep reading, and you’ll find your next favorite.
1. Everything Bagels
Everything Bagels lives up to its name with shelves full of classic and creative bagels baked fresh throughout the day. The aroma hits you before you’re through the door, pulling you toward their basket of warm, perfectly chewy bagels. On my last visit, I discovered that their sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese was the kind of breakfast worth getting up early for.
The staff here know their regulars and seem to treat everyone as a neighbor. Service is down-to-earth and quick, making it easy to swing by on a busy morning.
Their egg bagel is a local favorite—soft, golden, and not too dense. You also can’t go wrong with a classic plain bagel and their house-made lox spread, which delivers big flavor. Everything Bagels nails the basics and keeps locals coming back.
2. Dennis Hot Bagels
(201) 261-5775Call
Dennis Hot Bagels is the go-to spot for that classic, just-out-of-the-oven bagel experience. The smell here in the morning is a promise—always fresh, never stale. I swung by after a morning run and the warmth from the bagels was almost as comforting as the first bite itself.
Dennis sets itself apart with consistency and speed; you walk in and your favorite is always there, baked to perfection. The staff knows how to keep things moving but doesn’t rush the quality.
The cinnamon raisin bagel with a dab of their plain whipped cream cheese is a top pick. Or opt for the whole wheat for a heartier chew. Every order highlights what Paramus bagels are all about: authentic taste and care in the craft.
3. Bagel Emporium Inc
Bagel Emporium Inc has the kind of counter where regulars chat about their week and newcomers become converts after one bite. My first visit, I watched a steady line of locals migrate toward the poppy seed bagels like it was a secret handshake.
Each bagel has a satisfying chew and a crisp exterior—no shortcuts in their baking process. That care shows, especially if you go for their everything bagel with a layer of veggie cream cheese.
Their oat bran bagel is a hidden treasure for those who want something a bit unique. Bagel Emporium Inc doesn’t just serve bagels—it feels like the heartbeat of Paramus mornings, quietly making every day better with every batch.
4. Bagel Stop
(201) 261-5520Call
Bagel Stop has a steady stream of fans, and I count myself among them. Stopping by early, the bagels are still warm, and the choices fill the racks from poppy to multi-grain. The aroma alone is half the experience here.
The staff doesn’t miss a beat, even on the busiest mornings. Orders are quick, smiles are genuine, and there’s always time for a friendly hello. People linger over coffee, which tells you the atmosphere is as inviting as the baked goods.
The pumpernickel bagel with their house-made veggie cream cheese is the standout order. You’ll get a bagel that’s crusty on the outside, fluffy inside, and never bland. Bagel Stop combines small-town comfort with big flavor, earning loyal followers one bagel at a time.
5. Bagel Supreme
(201) 523-9414Call
Bagel Supreme puts the “family” in family-owned, and you feel it from the second you walk in. I’ve joined the morning crowd a few times, and there’s always a pleasant hum of conversation mixed with the clatter of trays and the smell of fresh dough.
The bagels here have a distinct, satisfying bite—the kind that makes breakfast memorable. It’s hard not to notice their dedication, whether you’re grabbing a coffee or a dozen for the office.
Try their classic plain bagel with a generous spread of their signature veggie cream cheese. If you want to branch out, the onion bagel has a depth of flavor that’s tough to forget. Bagel Supreme keeps it personal, and the result is always flavorful.
6. E Cohen Enterprise
E Cohen Enterprise hides in plain sight on Route 17, but locals know it’s a steady source for reliable bagels. I stopped in on a drizzly morning and left with a bag bursting with heat and a car that smelled like fresh bread for hours.
The focus here is on timeless flavors done right. There’s no parade of trendy mix-ins—just solid, well-baked bagels, always ready for your first bite or to share with a crowd.
The salt bagel here stands out, crisp and full of flavor, especially when paired with their smooth whipped cream cheese. Grab a dozen to go and you’ll see why families and commuters keep coming back. E Cohen Enterprise proves the classics never get old.
7. Perry’s Bagel Cafe
Perry’s Bagel Cafe has the friendly feel of a well-kept local secret. My most recent visit started with a line out the door—and for good reason. The bagels come out of the oven piping hot, with just the right golden edge and chewy center.
Perry’s sets itself apart with a perfectly balanced texture. Their bagels aren’t overstuffed or too dense. Each bite is light, but still satisfying, making it a favorite stop for busy commuters and families alike.
Their whole wheat bagel loaded with classic butter, or an everything bagel topped with veggie cream cheese, both capture what Perry’s does best. The flavors are simple, but crafted with care that keeps Paramus returning again and again.
8. Paramus Bagels & Deli
Paramus Bagels & Deli has a steady crowd thanks to its classic approach and inviting deli counter. On my first try, I watched as locals piled in for quick breakfasts or to grab a dozen for weekend gatherings. The atmosphere feels like everyone’s favorite neighborhood spot—bustling but never rushed.
The distinction here is the balance between a traditional bagel and deli-style service. Regulars know that freshness is never in question, and the menu offers solid choices for every kind of bagel fan.
The sesame bagel with their cucumber-dill cream cheese wins praise for good reason. It’s cool, crisp, and bright, reflecting the care they put into every order. At Paramus Bagels & Deli, quality and comfort go hand in hand.
9. Yummy Hot Bagels
(201) 265-1760Call
Yummy Hot Bagels stands apart by fulfilling the promise in its name—bagels here are always hot, fresh, and handled with care. I grabbed a batch early one morning, and the bag was still warm during my drive home. Nothing beats that mix of toasty crust and tender inside.
What makes Yummy Hot Bagels special is their commitment to warmth, both in their food and their quick, friendly service. Even when the line moves fast, they never skimp on quality.
The standout choice here is the rye bagel, especially when paired with their sun-dried tomato cream cheese. For anyone who loves a classic with a twist, this combo shows just how inventive Paramus bagels can get while staying true to tradition.
10. Eli’s Bagel Trattoria
(201) 493-1300Call
Eli’s Bagel Trattoria brings something different to the Paramus bagel lineup. Here, classic bagels meet a touch of old-world Italian hospitality. The place buzzes during the lunch rush, but it’s worth the wait. I remember sitting down with a toasted bagel and feeling like I’d stumbled onto something special.
Eli’s stands out with bagels that have exceptional chew and a whisper of sweetness in the crust. It’s a little twist you notice as soon as you bite in.
Try their sesame bagel with whipped scallion cream cheese or a classic egg bagel—both are made with care and a nod to tradition. Eli’s Bagel Trattoria is where comfort, flavor, and a bit of neighborhood flair come together seamlessly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of bagels can I find in Paramus, NJ?
You’ll find a wide range, from plain and poppy seed to pumpernickel, everything, egg, and multigrain. Shops in Paramus often offer seasonal favorites and creative spreads alongside the classics.
Are there vegan bagel options available in Paramus?
Yes, several local bagel shops offer vegan bagels and plant-based spreads. Always ask the staff for vegan choices since ingredients and preparation may vary by location.
Which shop is best for a quick breakfast on the go?
Paramus Bagels & Deli, Dennis Hot Bagels, and Bagel Stop are known for fast service, making them ideal for a quick, satisfying start to your day.
Can I order bagels for a group or catering?
Absolutely. Many Paramus bagel shops offer bulk orders, party platters, and catering, perfect for meetings, events, or family gatherings.
What’s a must-try bagel flavor in Paramus?
The everything bagel with cream cheese is a beloved local standard. For something unique, try a rye bagel with sun-dried tomato spread or oat bran with veggie cream cheese.