Finding good bagels in Palm Beach County is a bit like searching for buried treasure. The best ones rise above the rest with that rare balance of chewy crust and soft, flavorful center. After years of tasting bagels that ranged from forgettable to nearly perfect, a short list of the real standouts started to form in my mind. Once, while waiting in a busy Delray spot, someone next to me described a bagel as “transcendent.” I thought they were exaggerating until I tried one for myself.
Palm Beach County’s bagel scene is a blend of classic tradition and quirky innovation. From water-boiled New York classics to wild-card flavors tucked in inconspicuous strip malls, there’s something for every craving. This guide walks you through the top spots—where the bagels aren’t just fresh, but memorable. If you think a bagel is just bread with a hole, this list might change your mind.
1. The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co.
If you care about bagels, The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co. becomes a must-visit. Their secret? The water—filtered to mimic Brooklyn’s famous mineral balance—gives their bagels a distinct flavor and texture. I dropped in on a rainy morning and found the place bustling, the smell of freshly baked bagels in the air.
The everything bagel here is a standout, boasting that signature chew and seasoned crust. The bagel sandwiches, like the classic egg and cheese, showcase the pillowy interior of their round masterpieces. For purists, a simple order of a toasted plain bagel with a generous swipe of cream cheese highlights why they have such a devoted following in Palm Beach Gardens.
2. Brooklyn Bagels
Brooklyn Bagels in Wellington knows how to make a bagel that actually feels like a morning reward. The atmosphere buzzes with regulars who seem to all have their favorite spot by the window. I once watched a baker move trays of steaming bagels from oven to rack like he was handling gold—no shortcuts here.
Their salt bagel delivers just enough crunch and brine to wake up your taste buds. The egg bagel is light, golden, and pairs well with creamy spreads. Don’t skip their nova platter either; it puts the spotlight on their bagel’s dense yet springy crumb. This shop manages a balance of comfort food and creativity that keeps locals and bagel chasers alike coming back.
3. Bagel Boyz
Bagel Boyz mixes New York style street smarts with true Palm Beach warmth. The first time I walked in, a team member chatted with every customer like an old friend. There’s the hum of eggs sizzling and laughter floating in from families lingering over breakfast.
What sets Bagel Boyz apart is their dedication to the craft. Each bagel is made from scratch, boiled, then baked for the authentic NYC chew. Their house-smoked nova salmon on a fresh everything bagel is a true highlight. If you’re in the mood for comfort, their homemade tuna salad on a plain bagel hits the spot.
This shop proves that tradition and friendly service still matter, one bagel at a time.
4. Everything Bagels
(561) 792-8388Call
Everything Bagels hides in a low-key plaza but packs the punch of a true bagel gem. The first time I visited, the scent of bagels straight from the oven pulled me in and the staff’s easygoing vibe kept me there longer than I planned. This is the spot for bagel purists who want their dough chewy, with a firm crust and a real hint of malt.
The sesame bagel is crisp on the outside and soft inside—a perfect vehicle for their whipped cream cheese. Their classic poppy seed is another win, especially toasted. If you want a local’s tip, order your favorite bagel with their veggie cream cheese. You’ll understand why regulars stay loyal, bite after bite.
5. Bagels and More
(561) 753-5553Call
Bagels and More sits at the heart of Royal Palm Beach and delivers on its promise: bagels that live up to the name, plus a roster of deli favorites. My first visit was early one Saturday, and the steady stream of locals picking up their usual orders spoke volumes about the place.
The cinnamon raisin bagel here manages just the right sweetness, with enough chew to stand up to a thick layer of cream cheese. The onion bagel, toasted and topped with scallion spread, captures the classic New York vibe in every bite. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bagel or making it your go-to breakfast spot, Bagels and More has the goods to turn anyone into a repeat customer.
6. Maplewood Bagel Market
Maplewood Bagel Market in Jupiter looks humble from the outside, but inside, it’s a real haven for bagel lovers. I remember popping in for a quick breakfast and being surprised by how many regulars exchanged hellos with the staff. The place hums with that small-town, everyone-knows-everyone energy.
Their pumpernickel bagel offers deep flavor and satisfies a craving for something a little different. The jalapeño bagel pairs well with plain cream cheese for a kick that wakes up your morning. And if you enjoy a good classic, the everything bagel is always fresh and balanced with bold toppings. Maplewood’s strength is consistency—bagels here always taste like they were made by hands that care.
7. Manhattan Bagel
(561) 775-0555Call
Manhattan Bagel brings a bit of city grit to Palm Beach Gardens in the best way. The first time I visited, I noticed the gentle bustle of early risers grabbing their favorites before work. There’s something familiar and comforting about their setup—like a classic bakery with an updated twist.
The whole wheat bagel balances nutty flavor with a soft bite, and tastes just as good plain as it does loaded. Be sure to try their sesame bagel layered with a fresh veggie spread; it’s a combo that feels lighter but still filling. Manhattan Bagel nails the essentials, making it an ideal stop for locals who want classic bagel shop energy with reliably tasty results.
8. Makebs Bagels
Makebs Bagels has been a local favorite in West Palm Beach for years, quietly turning out bagels that always feel fresh from the oven. On my first stop, I noticed the friendly, fast service and the mountain of bagels behind the counter waiting to be claimed by hungry regulars.
The rye bagel stands out, dotted generously with caraway seeds for an earthy note. Their egg bagel is golden, pillowy, and practically begs for a swipe of cream cheese. For a quick pick-me-up, their mini bagels make for a satisfying snack without overdoing it. Makebs puts care into every batch, offering quality that feels as honest as its simple storefront.
9. Bagel Bistro
Bagel Bistro in Tequesta feels like one of those places you wish you’d discovered sooner. Tucked in the Tequesta Shoppes, it’s where you find real-deal bagels and see neighbors catching up over breakfast. My first visit, I was struck by how quickly the staff remembered regulars’ names—always a good sign.
The French toast bagel is sweet, soft, and offers just enough cinnamon to keep you hooked. Their garlic bagel is robust, especially toasted and paired with a veggie cream cheese. If you want something classic, their plain bagel is light, with a perfect, chewy center. Bagel Bistro’s mix of hospitality and attention to detail makes it a spot you’ll remember—and recommend to anyone with a craving for true bagel flavor.
10. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels delivers consistency and speed, all wrapped in a warm, friendly vibe. I’ve popped in for a quick breakfast and always found the counters filled with fresh bagels ready to go. The smell alone puts you in a good mood before that first bite.
The asiago bagel is crisp, cheesy, and a crowd favorite for good reason. If you want a little kickstart, order the breakfast sandwich with egg and veggie toppings—it’s a reliable winner. For fans of the classics, the sesame and everything bagels hold their own, especially when slathered with one of their signature cream cheese options. Einstein Bros. shines for anyone craving a quick, tasty bagel fix right in West Palm Beach.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a great bagel in Palm Beach County?
A great bagel should have a chewy, slightly glossy crust with a dense, flavorful interior. Local favorites use traditional boiling and baking techniques to get that signature texture.
Are there authentic New York-style bagels here?
Yes, several shops in Palm Beach County boil their bagels before baking them, just like in New York. You’ll find specialty spots using imported water systems or time-honored recipes.
Do local bagel shops offer gluten-free options?
Gluten-free bagels are available at a few select locations, but always call ahead since availability can vary by day and baker.
Which bagel flavor is most popular with locals?
Everything bagels and asiago bagels see the most repeat business, but plain, sesame, and pumpernickel have dedicated fans too.
Do Palm Beach bagel shops serve breakfast and lunch?
Most bagel shops here offer breakfast all day alongside deli sandwiches, salads, and coffee. It’s a tradition to linger over a bagel, whether you go early or stop by for brunch.
Is there a Kosher bagel shop in the area?
There are a few Kosher-friendly options in Palm Beach County. It’s wise to check with individual shops for Kosher certification or menu options to fit your needs.