Best Bagels in New Haven, CT

New Haven, CT, is such a cool place, especially when it comes to food. And let me tell you, bagels are a big deal here! I’ve tasted so many different kinds, and I’m excited to share my favorites with you. This guide is all about the best bagel shops in town, where you can find everything from classic flavors to some really fun, creative options. Trust me, you’re going to want to check these places out!

So, what are the best bagels in New Haven, CT? Well, the best bagels can be found at a bunch of awesome spots around the city. Each place has its own special twist on bagels, making them super tasty and fun to try. Whether you like plain, everything, or something a little different, there’s a bagel shop here that’s perfect for you!

Stick around, because I’m going to take you on a tasty journey through New Haven’s bagel scene. You’ll learn about the coolest shops, what makes each one unique, and why you should definitely grab a bagel (or two!) next time you’re in the area. Trust me, you won’t want to miss this!

Top 10 Bagels in New Haven, CT

1. Olmo
2. Bruegger’s Bagels
3. East Rock Breads
4. G Cafe Bakery Chapel St.
5. Donut Crazy New Haven
6. Koffee?
7. Atticus Market
8. A.M. Bagel
9. G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square
10. G Cafe Bakery East Rock

1. Olmo

Olmo: A Bagel Paradise in New Haven

Oh my gosh, Olmo is such a fun place! It’s right on Whitney Ave, and when I walked in, I felt super cozy. The people there are really nice, and they make you feel like family. I remember the smell of fresh bagels in the air, and it made my mouth water right away!

What I love about Olmo is how fresh and yummy their bagels are. They have this amazing everything bagel that I just can’t get enough of! I like to get it with cream cheese and smoked salmon. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making great food.

Plus, you can get your bagels to go or have them delivered, which is super handy. If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out Olmo!

2. Bruegger’s Bagels

Bruegger’s Bagels: A Bagel Haven in New Haven

Bruegger’s Bagels is such a cool spot! It’s right on Whitney Ave, and when I walked in, I could smell the yummy bagels baking. The place feels super friendly, and the people who work there are always smiling. It’s just a nice place to hang out and grab a bite!

What I really love about Bruegger’s is their New York-style bagels. They make them in small batches, so they’re always fresh and chewy. My favorite is the plain bagel with cream cheese. It’s simple, but oh man, it’s so good! You can really taste how much care they put into making their food.

And guess what? You can get your bagels delivered or take them to go! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to try Bruegger’s!

3. East Rock Breads

East Rock Breads: A Sweet Spot for Bagels in New Haven

Oh wow, East Rock Breads is such a cute little place! It’s on State Street, and when I walked in, I could smell all the yummy bread and bagels baking. The vibe is super cozy, and it feels like a special spot that not everyone knows about.

What I really love about East Rock Breads is how they use really good ingredients. Their bagels are soft and fresh, and they have so many fun flavors! My favorite is the sesame bagel with cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really shows how much they care about making delicious food.

And the best part? You can just grab your bagels to go! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to stop by East Rock Breads!

4. G Cafe Bakery Chapel St.

G Cafe Bakery Chapel St.: A Cozy Bagel Spot in New Haven

Oh my goodness, G Cafe Bakery on Chapel Street is such a cute place! When I walked in, I could smell all the fresh bagels baking, and it made me so happy. The atmosphere is super cozy, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It felt really nice!

What I think makes G Cafe special is their yummy bagels and how friendly everyone is. They have so many choices, but my favorite is the blueberry bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and so delicious, and you can really taste how fresh everything is!

And guess what? It’s super easy to grab your bagels to go! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out G Cafe Bakery. It’s a great spot for a tasty treat!

5. Donut Crazy New Haven

Donut Crazy New Haven: A Sweet Spot for Bagels and Donuts

Oh wow, Donut Crazy is such a fun place! It’s on York Street, and when I walked in, I could smell all the yummy donuts and bagels. The atmosphere is super lively, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It made my visit feel really special!

What I think makes Donut Crazy stand out is their super creative menu. They have awesome bagels, but their donuts are just amazing! I tried the maple bacon donut, and it was so good! It’s sweet and salty, and I couldn’t stop smiling while I ate it.

And the best part? You can get your treats delivered or take them to go! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out Donut Crazy. It’s a sweet experience you won’t forget!

6. Koffee?

Koffee?: A Cozy Coffee and Bagel Spot in New Haven

Oh my gosh, Koffee? is such a cute little place! It’s on Audubon Street, and when I walked in, I could smell the delicious coffee and fresh pastries. The brick walls make it feel so warm and cozy, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It was just a nice spot to relax!

What I really love about Koffee? is their yummy fair-trade coffee and the tasty bagels. I tried their bagel with cream cheese, and it was so soft and fresh! You can really tell they use good ingredients, and it made my snack feel special.

And guess what? They even have curbside pickup, which is super convenient! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out Koffee? for a yummy treat and a great cup of coffee!

7. Atticus Market

Atticus Market: A Fun Bagel Spot in New Haven

Oh wow, Atticus Market is such a neat place! It’s on Orange Street, and when I walked in, I felt so welcomed by the warm atmosphere. I loved that I could sit inside or outside, which made it a great spot to chill and enjoy my food.

What I really like about Atticus Market is how they use fresh, local ingredients. Their bagels are super yummy! I tried their everything bagel with cream cheese, and it was so flavorful and fresh. It really made my taste buds happy!

And guess what? You can take your bagels to go, which is super handy! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out Atticus Market for a tasty and fun experience!

8. A.M. Bagel

A.M. Bagel: A Yummy Bagel Spot Near New Haven

Oh my gosh, A.M. Bagel is such a great place! It’s on New Haven Ave in Derby, and when I walked in, I could smell all the fresh bagels baking. The vibe is super friendly, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It felt really nice!

What I think makes A.M. Bagel special is their big selection of bagels and toppings. I tried their garlic bagel with cream cheese, and it was so tasty! The flavor was really strong and yummy, and you can tell they put a lot of love into their food.

And the best part? You can take your bagels to go! If you’re nearby, you’ve got to check out A.M. Bagel for a delicious treat!

9. G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square

G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square: A Cozy Bagel Spot in New Haven

Oh wow, G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square is such a cute place! It’s in the Palladium Building on Orange Street, and when I walked in, I was greeted by the warm, cozy vibe and the yummy smell of fresh bagels. I really liked that I could sit inside or outside, which made it a nice spot to relax and enjoy my food.

What I think makes G Cafe Ninth Square special is their super tasty bagels and how friendly everyone is. I tried their poppy seed bagel with cream cheese, and it was so delicious! The bagel was fresh and had just the right amount of flavor, which made it a real treat.

And guess what? They have takeout, so you can grab your bagels and enjoy them anywhere! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square for a yummy snack!

10. G Cafe Bakery East Rock

G Cafe Bakery East Rock: A Sweet Bagel Spot in New Haven

Oh wow, G Cafe Bakery East Rock is such a lovely place! It’s on Orange Street, and when I walked in, I was greeted by the cozy vibe and the yummy smell of fresh bagels. I really liked that I could sit inside or outside, which made it a nice spot to enjoy my food.

What I think makes G Cafe East Rock special is their super tasty bagels and how friendly everyone is. I tried their cinnamon raisin bagel with cream cheese, and it was so delicious! The sweetness was just right, and you could really tell they use fresh ingredients.

And guess what? They even have delivery, which is super handy! If you’re in New Haven, you’ve got to check out G Cafe Bakery East Rock for a yummy treat!

Map of Bagels in New Haven, CT

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Shop	Price	Seating	Takeout	Delivery	Wheelchair	Reservation
Olmo	Inexpensive	–	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No
Bruegger’s Bagels	Inexpensive	–	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
East Rock Breads	–	–	Yes	No	–	–
G Cafe Bakery Chapel St.	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	–
Donut Crazy New Haven	Moderate	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	–
Koffee?	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	No	Inaccessible	No
Atticus Market	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	–
A.M. Bagel	–	Yes	Yes	–	Accessible	No
G Cafe Bakery Ninth Square	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
G Cafe Bakery East Rock	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	No

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best bagel shops in New Haven?
  Oh, there are so many great bagel shops in New Haven! Some of my favorites are Olmo, Bruegger’s Bagels, and G Cafe Bakery. Each place has its own yummy flavors and a cozy vibe that makes them fun to visit!

• Do these bagel shops offer delivery?
  Yes, lots of bagel shops in New Haven, like Bruegger’s and Donut Crazy, have delivery options. It’s super easy to get your favorite bagels delivered right to your door!

• Are there vegetarian or vegan bagel options?
  For sure! Most bagel shops have vegetarian options, and some even have vegan bagels and spreads. Just ask the friendly staff for what they recommend!

• What is the typical price range for bagels in New Haven?
  Bagels in New Haven are usually pretty inexpensive! You can expect to pay around $1 to $3 for a bagel, depending on what toppings you choose.

• Can I sit down and eat at these bagel shops?
  Yes! Many bagel shops, like G Cafe and Atticus Market, have nice indoor and outdoor seating. It’s a great way to enjoy your bagel and relax for a bit!

• What is the most popular bagel flavor?
  The most popular bagel flavors are usually plain, everything, and sesame. They’re super tasty and go well with lots of different toppings!

• Are there gluten-free bagel options available?
  Some bagel shops do have gluten-free bagels! It’s a good idea to check with the shop or look at their menu to see what they offer.

• What should I order with my bagel?
  A classic choice is cream cheese, but you can also try yummy toppings like smoked salmon or avocado. Each topping makes your bagel even more delicious!