If you’ve ever spent a morning in Naples, you know the search for a truly good bagel can feel oddly personal. There’s something almost magical about that first bite—a crisp crust, followed by a soft, chewy center. For bagel enthusiasts, Naples offers a surprisingly rich selection, from old-school classics to inventive new takes you didn’t see coming.
Many make the mistake of thinking you need a trip to New York for a great bagel, but Naples locals know better. I’ve trekked all over town, balancing tasting notes like a snack-obsessed scientist—all in pursuit of bagel excellence. The result? A list of spots that consistently deliver that elusive mix of texture and taste. Whether you crave a classic sesame or you’re hunting for a solid gluten-free round, you’ll find your match here. If you’re ready, let’s dive into the most satisfying bagel experiences Naples has to offer.
Where to find the best bagels in Naples, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Naples, FL:
- The Cafe
- Jane’s Cafe
- Goldies Restaurant
- Brooklyn Dough with a Hole
- Fifth Avenue Coffee Company & 6th Street Diner
- Terrazza
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Straight From New York Bagels
- Epiphany Gluten Free Bakery
- Panera Bread
1. The Cafe
The Cafe sits at the heart of 5th Avenue, where Naples mornings feel both relaxed and sophisticated. There’s a steady energy, the kind that comes from regulars chatting over coffee and first-timers eyeing the pastry display. I still remember my first bite of their bagel—fresh out of the oven, with a golden crust and airy middle that held up to a slather of house-made cream cheese.
The menu is as flexible as your morning mood, offering vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options without any fuss. Not sure what to try? Go for their classic bagel with smoked salmon, capers, and red onion. It’s a subtle nod to tradition, but it’s The Cafe’s approach—fresh ingredients, perfectly balanced flavors—that makes it memorable.
2. Jane’s Cafe
Jane’s Cafe feels like a tucked-away oasis in the middle of Naples, with koi ponds, garden patios, and a gentle hum of conversation all around. I’ve lost track of how many slow brunches I’ve enjoyed here, always savoring the balance between fresh flavors and lush surroundings. This spot brings in guests for breakfast, brunch, or lunch, but the bagel options remain a reliable favorite.
For a real treat, order their classic bagel with whipped cream cheese, topped with crunchy veggies or smoked salmon. Each bite reflects Jane’s commitment to freshness and a light hand with seasoning. The garden view isn’t just scenery—it sets the mood for a meal that feels easy and unhurried, making Jane’s perfect for early risers and lazy afternoons alike.
3. Goldies Restaurant
Goldies Restaurant quietly holds the title of Naples’ trusted neighborhood breakfast spot. Walk through the doors any morning and you’ll find a cheerful mix of regulars, the kind of place where the staff remembers your name and coffee order. On my first visit, the easygoing atmosphere pulled me in, but the bagels—fresh, warm, and chewy—are what brought me back.
Goldies’ signature bagel platter is a standout. The classic bagel arrives with a generous spread of cream cheese, ripe tomato, red onion, and a side of fresh fruit. Each piece comes together for a simple breakfast that highlights Goldies’ knack for honest, well-made food. If you’re after something familiar—and reliably good—this is the place to linger over bagels done right.
4. Brooklyn Dough with a Hole
Brooklyn Dough with a Hole feels like a love letter to bagel purists. If you close your eyes, the aroma, the dense chew, and the perfect crackle of the crust could transport you straight to a New York bakery. I wandered in one Saturday, craving authenticity, and found it in every bite.
The bagels here are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled, sticking to time-honored methods. There’s an obvious care in the process, visible in the golden sheen and rich flavor. My recommendation? Try an everything bagel layered with scallion cream cheese. It has that spot-on blend of crunch and softness, a signature of Brooklyn-style. For anyone missing a true Northeastern bagel, this shop leaves no room for disappointment.
5. Fifth Avenue Coffee Company & 6th Street Diner
Fifth Avenue Coffee Company & 6th Street Diner brings a laid-back vibe to bustling downtown Naples. This spot mixes classic diner comfort with the aroma of fresh coffee, making it easy to linger over breakfast or a midday bite. I’ve spent slow mornings here with the window open, a steaming cup in hand, and a satisfying bagel on my plate.
Their bagel sandwiches come with standout toppings and always hit the right note for flavor and freshness. I suggest the veggie bagel sandwich—bright, well-seasoned, and packed with crisp vegetables on a fresh bagel. It’s a great reflection of the diner’s attention to quality and their skill at elevating simple ingredients. Here, you’ll find bagels that fit any mood, paired comfortably with a hot drink and a people-watching window seat.
6. Terrazza
Terrazza at The Ritz Carlton offers a polished take on the classic morning spread, blending Italian flair with local charm. From the sunlight dancing across the elegant dining room to the discreet, thoughtful service, breakfast here always feels like an occasion. I first stopped in, intending to linger over coffee, but the breakfast buffet drew me in with its sheer variety.
The bagels at Terrazza shine as part of the well-curated buffet. Try one with their silky smoked salmon and generous capers, paired with slices of red onion and fresh tomato. Each flavor complements the next, using quality ingredients that match the restaurant’s reputation. It’s a local favorite for mornings when you want your bagel with a side of luxury.
7. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels has carved out a niche for itself as a reliable, cheerful staple in Naples’ bagel scene. The space buzzes with locals swinging by for a quick breakfast or taking a coffee to go. My routine includes a pit stop here for a bagel sandwich when I need something filling and fast.
The everything bagel with garden veggie shmear is a personal favorite. It’s consistently fresh, never skimps on flavor, and strikes that satisfying balance of soft interior and golden crust. You’ll find veggie-friendly options, classic breakfast sandwiches, and sturdy bagels that hold up to hearty spreads. Einstein Bros. manages to blend friendly service with easy variety, making it a go-to for both early risers and lunch-break regulars.
8. Straight From New York Bagels
Straight From New York Bagels is where you go when you crave a traditional, no-nonsense bagel—all boiled, baked, and gloriously chewy. The shop has the casual, bustling atmosphere of a busy New York deli, where regulars know exactly what they want. I’ve long admired their commitment to the kettle-boiled process, a rare find in Southwest Florida.
Their classic plain bagel with house-whipped scallion spread is tough to beat. Each bite delivers the right ratio of crust to softness, showing off the kind of hand-crafted attention only true bagel fans can spot. If you want to try something extra, their bialys and cinnamon rolls round out the experience. For the purest taste of New York, this is the stop that never disappoints.
9. Epiphany Gluten Free Bakery
Epiphany Gluten Free Bakery is a lifeline for anyone who needs— or simply prefers—gluten-free baked goods in Naples. The bright space feels inviting, with the aroma of fresh bread and a sense of community that keeps visitors coming back. When I first discovered their gluten-free bagels, I was genuinely impressed—they tasted like a small miracle, light and flavorful with none of the “off” textures that can come with gluten-free baking.
The everything bagel is a must-order, especially topped with their dairy-free or regular cream cheese. Each bite proves that gluten-free can stand shoulder-to-shoulder with traditional options. Epiphany’s dedication to safe, allergy-friendly food never means compromising on taste, making it a local gem for breakfast and brunch lovers alike.
10. Panera Bread
Panera Bread consistently delivers a comforting blend of bakery warmth and laid-back café energy. I’ve stopped in many times—sometimes to work, sometimes to just unwind—and their bagels never disappoint. Their seating invites lingering conversations, and the staff manage to be attentive without hovering.
The cinnamon swirl and everything bagels both deserve a spot on your breakfast radar. Toasted, with a generous layer of cream cheese, they strike the right balance of chewy and soft, pairing well with a hot cup of coffee. Panera’s menu caters to a wide range of tastes and dietary needs, keeping things simple but satisfying—perfect for those who want a dependable bagel experience in Naples.
More Things to Try in Naples, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for bagels in Naples, FL?
Naples has plenty of strong contenders, but locals love spots like The Cafe, Brooklyn Dough with a Hole, Straight From New York Bagels, and Goldies Restaurant for a truly memorable bagel experience. You’ll also find reliable chains like Panera Bread and Einstein Bros. Bagels throughout town.
Are there gluten-free bagel options in Naples?
Yes, Epiphany Gluten Free Bakery specializes in gluten-free bagels, offering a broad selection for those with dietary restrictions.
Where can I find classic New York–style bagels in Naples?
Check out Brooklyn Dough with a Hole and Straight From New York Bagels—both are known for authentic kettle-boiled bagels with the right flavor and chew.
Do any bagel shops offer vegan or vegetarian bagels?
Many Naples bagel spots have vegan and vegetarian-friendly choices. The Cafe, Jane’s Cafe, and Epiphany Gluten Free Bakery all offer options that cater to these dietary needs.
Which cafes serve bagels with unique toppings?
Several places offer fun twists. Try Jane’s Cafe for garden-fresh toppings or Fifth Avenue Coffee Company & 6th Street Diner for creative bagel sandwiches.
Can I order bagels for takeout or delivery?
Absolutely. Most bagel shops in Naples, including Straight From New York Bagels and Panera Bread, offer takeout and online ordering for extra convenience.
Are there bagel shops open for breakfast and lunch?
Yes, almost every spot on this list serves both breakfast and lunch, letting you enjoy bagels whenever the craving hits.