Bagels spark strong opinions. In Mt Sinai, the search for the best bagel often means spirited debates: Is it that glossy, crisp exterior that grabs your attention, or the dense, chewy middle that keeps you coming back? I’ve made it my personal mission—fuelled by countless early mornings and maybe too much coffee—to taste my way through this pocket of Long Island, all in pursuit of that perfect bite. Nothing compares to tearing into a lightly toasted bagel, steam rising as you break it open, revealing a doughy core just waiting for your favorite schmear.
If you’re ready to ditch the mediocre and find the real contenders in Mt Sinai, you’re in the right place. This guide is built from first-hand experiences, curious conversations with locals, and more than a few side-by-side taste tests. It’s for anyone who thinks breakfast sets the tone for the day, or those who just want a proper bagel without the fuss. Spoiler: there’s plenty to get excited about, whether you lean classic or crave something new. Let’s get right into the doughy details.
1. Strathmore Bagels
Strathmore Bagels holds a special place in Mt Sinai’s morning routine. The friendly bustle hits you as soon as you walk through the door; regulars chat with staff while trays of fresh-baked bagels disappear almost as fast as they come out. The pace is fast, but the service never feels rushed.
Bagel quality is what sets Strathmore apart—each ring is chewy inside with a subtly crisp crust, always made the old-fashioned way. I still remember my first bite into their classic sesame bagel, piled high with velvety scallion cream cheese. It’s a simple, honest standout.
For a local favorite, try the egg bagel with a swipe of vegetable spread; it’s bright, fresh, and unmistakably Mt Sinai. Strathmore Bagels nails the essentials every time.
2. Bagels Your Way
Bagels Your Way lives up to its name—here, customization rules. My first visit was pure bagel adventure, selecting from an impressive spread with all the classics and several inventive flavors. The staff has a knack for making you feel right at home, even when things get busy.
Each bagel boasts a sturdy exterior and soft, flavorful interior, ideal for stacking high with your favorite toppings. What sets them apart is the care with which each order is made, whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or lingering over lunch.
Go for their everything bagel with lox spread, or, if you’re feeling bold, the pumpernickel with cucumber and dill cream cheese. Both offer a taste of what keeps locals coming back for more.
3. Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe
(631) 403-4249Call
Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe sits conveniently at the corner of Nesconset Highway, making it a perfect stop for a pre-commute breakfast. My own discovery was fueled by curiosity—and the aroma drifting from the bakery section. The bagels have robust character: glossy outside, tender inside, with just the right amount of chew.
The menu is deep, featuring not only bagels but an array of deli options that go way beyond the basics. Here’s where everything feels made to order, right down to the last sprinkle of seasoning.
If you try one thing, let it be their whole wheat bagel topped with whipped vegetable cream cheese. It’s fresh, hearty, and consistently comforting—an honest reflection of Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe’s vibe and care for their craft.
4. Casey Bro’s Bagels
(631) 509-1956Call
Casey Bro’s Bagels is refreshingly straightforward, focusing on what matters most—a classic, well-made bagel. I found my way in on a Sunday morning and was met with the kind of neighborhood energy that makes a place memorable. The shop keeps things traditional, letting the bagels do the talking, and they have a knack for consistency.
There’s no over-complicating things here. Each bagel delivers a golden crust with a soft, dense center that’s perfect for a hearty spread. The selection may seem simple, but it covers every craving.
Definitely try the cinnamon raisin bagel with plain cream cheese. The sweetness of the raisins and the gentle crunch of the crust make this combination stand out in an understated, satisfying way.
5. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ is a familiar and comforting presence along Route 25A, perfect for those mornings when routine is key. The drive-thru setup makes it easy to grab a quick bite, and I’ve relied on it more times than I’d care to admit, especially on busy weekdays. Dunkin’ sets itself apart by always delivering consistency—you know exactly what you’ll get, no matter the time of day.
While their menu covers all the classics, the bagels here are a solid choice for a quick breakfast or snack. There’s always something ready, and the staff handles the crowd smoothly.
Order a plain bagel toasted with a side of hash browns for a classic pairing. It’s the simplicity and reliability that stands out, making Dunkin’ a reliable staple in Mt Sinai’s bagel lineup.
6. Better On A Bagel
(631) 473-5858Call
Better On A Bagel may sit just outside Mt Sinai, but it’s a regular stop for locals who crave well-crafted bagels. I first stumbled in on a Saturday morning, drawn by the long line snaking out the door—a promising sign. The bagels are generous, golden, and distinctly flavorful, each bite balanced between chewy and light.
The deli counter is full of classic spreads and fresh ingredients, making even simple orders a little more special. Service is friendly, even during the morning rush.
Try the poppy seed bagel piled with their homemade vegetable cream cheese. The combination says everything about what this shop does well: hearty, satisfying, and never bland, just the way a Long Island bagel should be.
7. Better On A Bagel Express
Better On A Bagel Express brings a quick, satisfying bagel experience to the Pine Plaza neighborhood. I was impressed on my first visit by the speed without any drop in freshness—a rare combination. Bagels still come out hot and full of personality, keeping the focus on flavor and texture even when you’re in a hurry.
The counter staff have the rhythm down, moving efficiently while still offering a personal touch. It’s ideal for a quick breakfast or a casual catch-up.
Their everything bagel with low-fat scallion cream cheese is a standout, packed with robust seasoning that doesn’t overpower. You get all the essentials here—efficiency, quality, and a taste that makes a busy day start off right.
8. The Bigger Bagel and Deli
(631) 209-2444Call
The Bigger Bagel and Deli makes good on its name, offering bagels that actually feel substantial. I ended up here on a friend’s recommendation, and the sheer size of the bagels is only outdone by their freshness. The texture lands right in the sweet spot—chewy, but not tough, with a crust that resists just enough before giving way.
The deli options stretch well beyond bagels, but every visit, I find myself sticking with the classic breakfast staples they do so well. The staff keeps things moving, creating a lively, welcoming vibe even when it’s packed.
The salt bagel with a shmear of chive cream cheese is a house favorite—salty, creamy, and indulgent without feeling heavy. This spot is a worthy detour for anyone who takes their bagels seriously.
9. Zara’s Deli and Bagel
Zara’s Deli and Bagel makes busy mornings better, thanks to its fast service and focus on freshness. I dropped by during a lunchtime rush and was surprised how quickly everything moved—no skimping on quality. Every bagel is made to order, with that unmistakable just-baked aroma.
The deli is casual, with sit-in space and free Wi-Fi for lingering or work breaks. They offer a wide variety, so the menu feels plentiful even when you’re in a hurry.
The oat bran bagel with sun-dried tomato cream cheese is a hidden gem—both hearty and full of flavor, reflecting Zara’s knack for turning simple ingredients into something memorable.
10. Grand Central Bagels
(631) 744-6611Call
Grand Central Bagels is a Rocky Point staple, known for its cash-only, no-frills charm. My first visit was a weekend tradition—people lining up, clutching coffee cups, chatting as they waited for their orders. These bagels are classic Long Island: dense, golden, and built for bold spreads.
The staff knows the regulars by name, and the vibe is comfortable, making it easy to settle in or grab and go without drama. Parking is easy, so popping in is never a hassle.
Try the onion bagel with their scallion cream cheese; the balance of savory and creamy is spot on. It’s the kind of spot that reminds you why a good bagel is worth seeking out.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best bagel shops in Mt Sinai, NY?
Strathmore Bagels, Bagels Your Way, and Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe are top choices, each offering fresh, classic bagels with their own unique touches.
Are there any bagel shops in Mt Sinai that offer gluten-free options?
Some local shops may carry gluten-free bagels; it’s best to call ahead to places like Bagels Your Way or Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe to confirm availability.
Which bagel flavors are most popular in Mt Sinai?
Everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, and classic plain bagels are consistent favorites across shops in the area.
Can I order bagels online or for pickup?
Many local spots, such as Strathmore Bagels and Bagels Your Way, offer online ordering for quick and easy pickup.
Do bagel shops in Mt Sinai offer catering or large orders?
Yes, several shops provide catering trays and bulk orders. Call your favorite spot ahead for details and options.