Bagels spark a special kind of loyalty in Connecticut. In Middletown, finding a bagel that hits the mark—chewy, with a crisp edge and a real depth of flavor—feels like striking gold. I remember weaving through Main Street one foggy morning before work, tempted by the smell drifting out of a little corner shop. That first bite told me everything I needed to know: some places here take bagels very seriously.
Searching for the best bagels in Middletown isn’t about flash or trends. It’s a mission for something simple yet extraordinary. Over the past months, I tried everything from old-school delis bursting at the seams to sleek modern bakeries serving bagels piled high. The list ahead isn’t just a rundown—it’s a guide built on flour-dusted hands and plenty of taste tests. Whether you’re after the perfect sesame swirl or a plain bagel, toasted just right, these local spots deliver real satisfaction.
1. Brew Bakers
Brew Bakers blends Old World charm with inventive flavor. The space hums with a European feel, filled with art, sunlight, and the gentle clash of plates. Tucked just off Main Street, it’s a spot I often drift toward when I crave something more thoughtful than just a quick breakfast.
The bagels here are a triumph: perfectly chewy with a golden crust, sturdy enough to handle the hearty sandwiches Brew Bakers is known for. My pick is the classic egg and cheese on an everything bagel—simple, yes, but elevated by fresh, skillfully cured ingredients.
Try the smoked salmon bagel or the veggie-packed sandwich if you like bold flavors. Brew Bakers doesn’t cut corners; every bite reflects attention to detail and genuine care for quality.
2. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ is more than a pit stop for coffee in Middletown. It’s a familiar sight on Washington Street, always buzzing and open when you need it most. If you’re after a consistent bagel experience, this is the place to rely on, whether you’re rushing to work or easing into the weekend.
The bagels here deliver what you’d expect: no-nonsense, soft yet sturdy, and perfect for a quick bite. I often pair an everything bagel with a cup of their signature coffee for a comforting morning lift.
Bagel sandwiches, like the veggie or plain egg and cheese, are worth ordering. Dunkin’ may not surprise you, but it delivers the kind of affordable, familiar satisfaction that keeps you coming back.
3. Bagels Plus
Bagels Plus is a classic spot that knows how to hit the right notes with locals. Tucked on Farmington Ave, this place has a neighborhood feel—friendly faces behind the counter and regulars who know exactly what they want.
The bagels here are the definition of “just right.” There’s a crackly outside, a tender inside, and a wide selection of flavors ready to meet any craving. On busy mornings, I like to stop in for their sesame bagel with cream cheese: simple, warm, and satisfying.
Try their whole wheat or everything bagels for an extra layer of flavor. Bagels Plus keeps things straightforward, relying on freshness and quality to speak for itself—no extra fuss required.
4. Bruegger’s Bagels
Bruegger’s Bagels brings genuine New York-style flair to Connecticut. Every bagel is baked fresh in-house each morning, which gives the place an inviting aroma you can’t miss. I’ve popped in more than once for the familiar crunch and satisfying chew their bagels provide.
Their classic plain or everything bagels pair perfectly with the signature Vermont cream cheese. Some mornings, I go for their smoked salmon bagel, loaded with crisp veggies and rich, silky fish. It’s a nod to deli tradition with a touch of Bruegger’s personality.
Try the asiago cheese bagel if you like yours with a little extra bite. For reliability, variety, and a genuine bakery experience, Bruegger’s always delivers.
5. Fancy Bagels
Fancy Bagels has earned its name by doing the basics exceptionally well. This spot on Queen Street is often packed with regulars, and after a few visits, it’s clear why. The staff work quickly, but take time to greet everyone like they belong.
The bagels here are plump and generous, with a satisfying chew. I’m partial to their onion bagel with a thick layer of plain cream cheese. Every bite is fresh and never disappoints.
Their cinnamon raisin bagel is a must for anyone craving a hint of sweetness. Fancy Bagels doesn’t fuss with trends; it sticks to simple, honest, and tasty recipes that keep people coming back.
6. Seed Bagel Shop
Seed Bagel Shop isn’t your usual bagel joint—there’s a sense of invention behind everything. The kitchen draws inspiration from local farms, and the menu always feels fresh, adaptable, and a little daring. The first time I walked in, it struck me how many choices there were for every taste and preference.
Their bagels are a canvas for creativity. You’ll find the classics, but the real joy comes from tasting their signature sandwiches. I especially like the avocado, tomato, and egg on a multigrain bagel—simple flavors, delivered with precision and care.
They offer vegan and gluten-free options, making it easy for anyone to find a satisfying start to their day. At Seed, bagels are more than breakfast—they’re an experience.
7. Bagelz Franchise Corp
(860) 657-4400Call
Bagelz Franchise Corp sits quietly on Nutmeg Lane, but its reputation speaks volumes. This spot has a straightforward approach that centers around tried-and-true recipes and no-nonsense execution. It’s the kind of place where the staff knows their regulars and keeps the service fast and friendly.
The bagels themselves are satisfying: crisped on the outside, pillowy within. I’ve stopped in for a quick breakfast more than once, usually going for a poppy seed bagel with light cream cheese. The options are plentiful, catering well to both traditionalists and adventurers.
Don’t skip the whole wheat or classic sesame varieties—they capture the understated quality that keeps Bagelz on local must-try lists. Here, simple comfort wins every time.
8. Fancy Bagels Xpress
(860) 426-3909Call
Fancy Bagels Xpress puts the focus on efficiency without giving up quality. For anyone running on a tight schedule, this spot on Buckland Street nails the concept of quick, good food. It has the same inviting energy as its sister location, with even faster turnaround.
The bagels here are always fresh and consistently shaped just right. I’ve dashed in for a quick breakfast and never left disappointed. The classic plain bagel with whipped cream cheese is my personal go-to when I’m short on time.
Their everything bagel is just as reliable, pairing well with hot coffee for a balanced, satisfying meal. Fancy Bagels Xpress is about getting real flavor, even when you’re on the go.
9. Bagel Plus
(860) 873-9448Call
Bagel Plus on Falls Road is a little out of the way, but it’s worth the drive. This spot stands out for its relaxed, hometown vibe and the unmistakable scent of freshly baked bagels that greets you before you even walk in.
The bagels are classic: hand-rolled, with a wholesome texture and just the right chew. My personal favorite is the poppy seed, toasted and spread with their rich, creamy cheese. The locals swear by the whole wheat or salt bagels, each one perfect for a hearty, simple breakfast.
If you need something quick, grab a bagel sandwich loaded with eggs and veggies. Bagel Plus doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel—it just makes sure every bite feels like home.
10. Brookside Bagels By The Cove
(860) 571-0271Call
Brookside Bagels By The Cove delivers old-fashioned bagel charm with a riverside twist. Located on Main Street in Wethersfield, it’s a cozy morning stop where the bagels taste homemade and the pace feels unrushed.
The everything bagel here really stands out: toasted, with just the right balance of crunch and chew. I’ve settled in with a hot cup of coffee and a fresh bagel more than once, watching the world go by through the front window.
Try their plain bagel with vegetable cream cheese for something classic and comforting. Brookside offers a reminder that simple ingredients, done well, can make every breakfast feel like a small celebration.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best bagel flavor to try in Middletown, CT?
It depends on your taste, but everything, sesame, and plain are always favorites. Many local shops craft their own flavors, so don’t be afraid to ask about daily specials or unique creations.
Are there any vegan or gluten-free bagel options in Middletown?
Yes, several spots like Seed Bagel Shop offer vegan and gluten-free choices. Always check with the shop, as availability can change.
Which bagel shop has the best bagel sandwiches?
Brew Bakers and Bruegger’s Bagels are top picks for loaded bagel sandwiches, with fresh veggies, eggs, and flavorful spreads.
Do Middletown bagel shops offer catering or large orders?
Most local favorites, including Brew Bakers and Bruegger’s, offer catering services for events or meetings. Pre-order for the best selection and quick pickup.
What time do bagel shops usually open?
Most bagel shops in the area open early, around 6 or 7 a.m., to catch the breakfast crowd. Weekend hours may vary, so checking ahead is always a good idea.