There’s something almost magical about biting into a great bagel—one that’s chewy on the inside, with just the right crisp edge. If you’re in Mequon, WI, you don’t need to cross state lines for a proper fix. The local bagel landscape quietly delivers, whether you crave the classic poppy-seed or something a bit more adventurous.
As someone who has chased down bagels across the Midwest, I’ve learned a few secrets. The best bagels aren’t just made; they’re nearly obsessed over, guarded by bakers who have opinions about water temperature and flour like it’s a secret code. Mequon’s top spots have earned their reputations, and sampling each one is an adventure in itself. If you’re after the real deal, stick around—your taste buds are about to thank you.
1. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on N Port Washington Rd is a familiar pitstop when I need a true classic. This isn’t just a chain spot—it’s where you see the sunrise glow through baskets of bagels and smell breakfast in the air. The dough gets special attention here, resulting in bagels with a signature chew and warmth.
There’s comfort in their menu: think fresh, hearty bagels topped with a generous spread. I always lean toward their plain bagel with garden veggie shmear—simple, but the creamy spread hits just right. For those who like a twist, the asiago cheese bagel has fans for good reason.
If you’re after a seat with your coffee and bagel, this spot’s relaxed brunch vibe lets you settle in or grab breakfast on the go.
2. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on N Port Washington Rd has saved me more mornings than I can count. There’s always a buzz, as regulars queue for their bagels and iced coffees. Speed and consistency make Dunkin’ a go-to when time is short but you don’t want to compromise.
Their bagels won’t disappoint if you like them classic and straightforward. I like the everything bagel with plain cream cheese—it’s bold, fresh, and pairs well with black coffee. Dunkin’s approach is about keeping it reliable and simple, so you always get what you expect.
For a quick breakfast, the grab-and-go set up is hard to top. If you want the basics done right, Dunkin’ is where you’ll find them.
3. Big Apple Bagels
Big Apple Bagels in Grafton is a spot you slip into when you want a neighborhood feel. My first visit was a blend of warm greetings and the comforting smell of fresh bread in the air. The bagels come out soft, with a tender crumb and just enough chew to remind you why bagel lovers keep coming back.
The menu is filled with options, but I usually go for the salt bagel with a smear of cucumber dill cream cheese. It’s a little zesty, a little cool, and always tastes fresh. Their bagel sandwiches are another draw, layered generously and perfect for a midday meal.
Big Apple Bagels stands out for those who appreciate variety and a friendly atmosphere you’ll want to revisit.
4. Bruegger’s Bagels
Step into Bruegger’s Bagels on Silver Spring Dr and you’re met with the unmistakable aroma of bagels fresh from the oven. The first time I stopped in, what caught me was their attention to texture—that true New York-style chew and glossy crust, hard to find outside the East Coast.
The bagels here invite you to keep it classic or mix it up with creative options. I’m partial to the everything bagel with made-in-Vermont cream cheese. The blend of toasty seeds and silky spread sums up Bruegger’s knack for balancing tradition and fresh ideas.
If you like hearty bagel sandwiches and a bustling morning scene, this place is a safe bet. Bruegger’s brings a bit of city pace and classic deli flavor, just outside Mequon.
5. Enjoy Living
(414) 419-0515Call
Enjoy Living is one of those places you find out about from word of mouth and wonder why you didn’t know sooner. My first visit was almost accidental, but the straightforward vibe and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The bagels are fresh and unfussy, the sort you can enjoy any day of the week and not get bored.
I gravitate toward the sesame bagel—its nutty flavor and tender crumb are simple but satisfying. Their selection covers all the classics, and you can expect consistent quality every time. No pretension here, just great bagels and a low-key spot to enjoy them.
Parking is easy, and the whole experience feels like a hidden gem in the Milwaukee area for bagel lovers.
6. Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette
Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette stands out for its creative spirit and vibrant energy. On my visit, I was drawn in by the open kitchen and the scent of bagels baking. Their bagels are hand-rolled and have a satisfying balance of chewiness and crispness, which makes every bite memorable.
The menu goes beyond the ordinary, but the classic sea salt bagel with whipped cream cheese is a pick that’s both comforting and flavorful. Every ingredient feels carefully chosen, and the spreads are rich and plentiful.
Sit down with your order, watch the team at work, and you’ll get why this spot has a devoted following. Allie Boy’s feels thoughtful, modern, and truly passionate about bagels.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular bagel flavors in Mequon?
Plain, everything, sesame, and asiago cheese top the list. Most local spots keep these in steady rotation.
Where can I find kosher or vegetarian bagel options in Mequon?
Most bagel shops offer vegetarian-friendly choices, especially plain, sesame, and everything bagels with cheese or veggie spreads. Ask staff for details; they’re happy to help.
Do any bagel shops in Mequon offer gluten-free options?
Some larger chains sometimes stock gluten-free bagels, but always call ahead. Dedicated gluten-free options are rare but slowly appearing at select bakeries.
What makes a bagel “New York-style”?
It’s all about the texture: chewy interior, slightly crisp exterior, and a malty flavor. Shops like Bruegger’s Bagels aim for this classic style.
Can I order bagels online for pickup or delivery in Mequon?
Yes, most chains and some local bakeries offer online ordering for easy pickup. Delivery is usually available through third-party apps.