Finding a bagel that’s equal parts chewy and crisp isn’t as simple as it sounds. In Manhasset, NY, where mornings are brisk and locals are particular, bagel perfection is a pursuit all its own. I remember stopping by a nondescript shop on a chilly Sunday, only to find myself standing in line with half the neighborhood, clutching my coffee and mentally ranking my own favorite spots. The verdict? The perfect bagel really can make your day, whether you like yours loaded with cream cheese or left gloriously plain.
This guide cuts through the carbs to give you a list rooted in real visits and honest taste tests. If you’re on a quest for a genuine, fresh-baked bagel in Manhasset and nearby, settle in. You’re about to discover which places have locals raving, which ones are stashed away in strip malls, and maybe, just maybe, where you’ll find your new morning routine.
Where to find the best bagels in Manhasset, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Manhasset, NY:
- Manhasset Bagels
- Rmmd
- Munsey Park Bagel
- Dunkin’
- Slims Bagels and Bialys
- Bagel Boss
- Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
- Let There Be Bagels
- Greenvale Bagels
- Glen Oaks Bakery Inc
1. Manhasset Bagels
+1 516-627-8100
Manhasset Bagels sits right in the heart of town, drawing both commuters and weekend wanderers. The aroma hits you before you even reach the door—warm, fresh-baked bagels lined up behind the counter, each one boasting the perfect glossy crust. On my last visit, I noticed locals chatting with staff who already knew their usual orders. There’s a hum of morning energy here.
What sets Manhasset Bagels apart is the texture. The bagels manage the rare balance: light chew beneath a crisp shell, never dense or doughy. Grab a classic sesame bagel, toasted, with whipped scallion cream cheese. If you want a bit of adventure, the everything bagel with lox and red onion might just convert you. Breakfast here is a local tradition.
2. Rmmd
Rmmd sits quietly on Plandome Road, but don’t let its modest exterior fool you. This is a spot where simplicity reigns and the bagels do all the talking. On my last stop here, I was struck by the steady flow of regulars—people grabbing orders to go, many on a first-name basis with the counter crew.
What makes Rmmd unique is its dedication to classic technique. The bagels are kettle-boiled, ensuring the right blend of crunch and soft center. I recommend the whole wheat everything bagel with a generous schmear of homemade vegetable cream cheese. If you’re feeling classic, their plain bagel with butter really showcases the freshness.
It’s the kind of place you revisit, not just for the food, but for the feeling that you belong.
3. Munsey Park Bagel
Munsey Park Bagel feels like a local secret hidden in plain sight on Northern Boulevard. The space has a friendly, neighborhood vibe—think regulars picking up their orders and catching up with staff. During a rushed weekday morning, I dropped in and was surprised by how fast and efficient the service was, especially considering the busy crowd.
Their bagels are pillowy yet have a proper bite, a rare balance that keeps customers coming back. My go-to is their egg bagel topped with chive cream cheese. It’s warm, fragrant, and always hits the spot. The plain bagel, still warm from the oven, is also a standout if you prefer to keep it classic.
Munsey Park Bagel is about consistency and comfort, perfect for starting your day on a good note.
4. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on Plandome Road is the reliable choice when you need something fast and familiar. There’s a comfort in knowing exactly what to expect: quick service, recognizable flavors, and consistency every visit. I’ve popped in plenty of times during a busy morning, and never left disappointed.
Dunkin’ stands out for its convenience. Whether you’re stopping in on your way to work or swinging by after an afternoon errand, the bagels here are always warm and ready. The classic plain bagel toasted with a thick layer of cream cheese is a simple, satisfying option. For some energy on the go, the multigrain bagel pairs well with their signature coffee.
If you want breakfast that’s quick, simple, and hits the spot, Dunkin’ delivers every time.
5. Slims Bagels and Bialys
Slims Bagels and Bialys is a spot where tradition takes center stage. The bagels here are hand-rolled and kettle-boiled—each one comes out with a crackly crust and that chew true New Yorkers love. I remember coming in on a chilly Sunday, and the owner chatted with regulars as bagels were pulled hot from the oven. The place is no-frills, but the flavor speaks for itself.
What really sets Slims apart is their bialys. These are a perfect pick for anyone who loves a bagel but wants something a little different. The onion bialy is soft, a little bit tangy, and loaded with savory flavor. Try a poppy bagel with chive cream cheese to get the full Slims experience.
If you’re looking for Old World taste just outside Manhasset, Slims should be on your list.
6. Bagel Boss
(516) 626-5599Call
Bagel Boss on Willis Ave is where bagel cravings meet their match, all under strict kosher guidelines. The shop buzzes from early morning, with cases full of classic bagels and an array of spreads you don’t always see elsewhere. During my visits, I’ve always been impressed by the friendly staff and the range of options for every dietary need.
Bagel Boss stands out for variety and freshness. The whole wheat bagel with veggie cream cheese is a personal favorite—nutty, soft, and perfect for busy mornings. They also serve a stellar French toast bagel if you’re in the mood for something sweet. The gluten-free and vegan choices mean no one gets left out of the bagel experience here.
For dependable, flavorful bagels with a welcoming community feel, Bagel Boss is a reliable stop.
7. Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
(516) 671-0100Call
Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe is a local treasure, set just far enough off the main Manhasset route that it feels like a destination. Stepping inside, you’re greeted by the comforting smell of freshly baked goods and the sight of bagels stacked high behind the counter. I’ve stopped in on lazy weekends when the line is long but so is the anticipation—no one seems to mind the wait.
The bagels here are plump, with a deep golden crust and a light, airy interior. If you’re making the trip, order the sesame bagel with a shmear of homemade scallion cream cheese. Their rye bagel, too, is memorable—earthy, subtly tangy, and perfectly chewy.
Come for the bagels, stay for the small-town warmth and a menu that’s both classic and creative.
8. Let There Be Bagels
Let There Be Bagels has a reputation that stretches well beyond Port Washington Blvd. The first thing you notice is the bustle—lines form early because regulars know these bagels come hot, hearty, and generously sized. I’ve made the early morning drive for a bagel fix more than once, and it’s always worth it.
The standout here is the classic poppy seed bagel: crisp on the outside, cloud-soft inside, and never short on flavor. Try it with their signature veggie cream cheese, packed with fresh herbs and a bright, tangy finish. For a simple pleasure, their plain bagel with butter is deeply satisfying.
Playful, friendly service adds to the charm, making this spot something to look forward to each time.
9. Greenvale Bagels
Greenvale Bagels, tucked just off Glen Cove Road, is the steady favorite of locals in the know. There’s a sense of calm about this place—no rushing, just the pleasant sound of bagels being sliced, toasted, and handed across the counter. I’ve stopped by after errands and always found the service quick and the mood relaxed.
Their bagels are subtly sweet with an old-school bite. The salt bagel here is a standout, pairing a crisp crunch with a light, almost melt-away center. Want something heartier? Grab an onion bagel with scallion cream cheese or an oat bagel for a touch of wholesome texture. Each order feels personalized, made right there for you.
For anyone craving a reliable bagel fix, Greenvale Bagels delivers every time—with flavor, warmth, and consistency.
10. Glen Oaks Bakery Inc
(718) 343-0303Call
Glen Oaks Bakery Inc is the kind of spot that locals recommend without hesitation. The scent of fresh, baked goods greets you at the door, mingling with the warmth of a staff that remembers returning faces. I wandered in one rainy morning, and the bakery counter was already dotted with regulars enjoying their usual.
Their bagels have a satisfying crunch with the first bite and a soft, tender inside. I always reach for their pumpernickel or everything bagel, toasted and topped with plain cream cheese—a combination that never misses. The bakery’s variety means there’s a flavor for every mood, with just the right amount of chew to keep things interesting.
Glen Oaks Bakery brings a classic touch to bagels, blending comfort and quality with every batch.
More Things to Try in Manhasset, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best bagel shops in Manhasset, NY?
Top shops include Manhasset Bagels, Munsey Park Bagel, and Bagel Boss. Each has its own unique twist, so it’s worth trying a few.
Do any bagel shops in Manhasset offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Yes, some spots like Bagel Boss offer gluten-free and vegan bagels and spreads. Always call ahead to check availability.
What’s the most popular bagel flavor in Manhasset?
Everything bagels and classic sesame bagels are always at the top of the list. They’re great with a simple cream cheese or a more adventurous spread.
Are there local places known for their specialty bagels?
Absolutely. Slims Bagels and Bialys is known for their bialys, while Let There Be Bagels serves up creative flavors and generous sizes.
Can I order bagels ahead for large groups or events?
Many Manhasset bagel shops, like Manhasset Bagels and Bagel Boss, offer catering and bulk order options for meetings or gatherings.