Best Bagels in Madison, WI

Madison, WI, has some of the best bagels I’ve ever tasted! Seriously, if you love bagels like I do, you’re in for a treat. There are so many places here that make bagels fresh and delicious, and I can’t wait to share my favorites with you.

So, what are the best bagels in Madison, WI? Well, let me tell you! The best bagels in Madison can be found at a bunch of amazing shops, each with their own special flavors and toppings. Whether you like classic bagels or want to try something new and exciting, there’s definitely a spot for you here.

Stick around, and I’ll take you on a tasty journey through the top bagel places in Madison. You’ll find out what makes each one special, what yummy things they serve, and why you should check them out!

Top 10 Bagels in Madison, WI

1. Bagels Forever
2. Einstein Bros. Bagels
3. Gotham Bagels
4. Mermaid Kitchen
5. Wonderstate Coffee – Madison Cafe
6. Marigold Kitchen
7. Ancora Cafe + Bakery
8. Stalzy’s Deli
9. Greenbush Bakery
10. Paleo Mama Bakery

1. Bagels Forever

Bagels Forever: My Favorite Spot

Oh my gosh, Bagels Forever is just the best! It’s right on University Avenue, and every time I go there, I feel so happy. When you walk in, the smell of warm bagels is just amazing! It’s super cozy, and I love grabbing a bagel to eat there or to take home.

What makes Bagels Forever really special is how fresh and yummy their bagels are. They boil and bake them just right, so they’re nice and chewy. My favorite is the Everything Bagel with cream cheese and lox. It’s so tasty and really shows how good their ingredients are!

And if you want something sweet, you have to try the cinnamon raisin bagel. It’s like a little piece of heaven with just the right amount of sweetness. You won’t regret it!

2. Einstein Bros. Bagels

Einstein Bros. Bagels: My Go-To Bagel Place

Oh wow, Einstein Bros. Bagels is just so much fun! It’s right on University Avenue, and I always get super excited when I go there. When you walk in, you see all the colorful bagels and yummy sandwiches, and it makes my tummy rumble! Plus, you can sit inside or outside, which is awesome when the weather is nice.

What I really love about Einstein Bros. is how many choices they have! There are so many bagel sandwiches and coffee drinks that it’s hard to pick just one. My favorite is the Spinach and Cheese Bagel Sandwich. It’s warm and cheesy, and it makes me smile every time!

And if you want something sweet, you have to try their blueberry bagel with cream cheese. It’s like a little piece of happiness that brightens my day. You’re gonna love it!

3. Gotham Bagels

Gotham Bagels: A Tasty New York Experience

Oh my goodness, Gotham Bagels is one of my favorite places! It’s on Mifflin Street, and every time I go there, I feel like I’m in New York City. When I walk in, I see all the hand-rolled bagels, and it makes my mouth water! You can sit inside or outside, which is super nice when the sun is shining.

What I really love about Gotham Bagels is how fresh everything is. They have so many yummy bagels and sandwiches to choose from! My top pick is the classic bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon. It’s so tasty and really shows how good their ingredients are!

If you want to try something fun, get the jalapeño bagel with cream cheese. It’s a little spicy and oh-so-delicious! You’re gonna love it!

4. Mermaid Kitchen

Mermaid Kitchen: My Cozy Bagel Spot

Oh my gosh, Mermaid Kitchen is just the cutest little place ever! It’s on Baldwin Street, and every time I go there, it feels like I’m visiting a friend’s house. The vibe is so warm and friendly, and I love that it’s family-owned. You can even order online, which is super handy!

What I really love about Mermaid Kitchen is how fresh everything tastes. They have the yummiest cream cheese flavors! My favorite is the chive cream cheese on a plain bagel. It’s so creamy and delicious, and you can really tell they put a lot of love into their food.

And if you’re looking for something sweet, you have to try their cookies! They are soft and chewy, and they make the perfect treat to enjoy with your bagel. You’re gonna want to go back for more!

5. Wonderstate Coffee – Madison Cafe

Wonderstate Coffee – Madison Cafe: My Happy Place for Bagels and Coffee

Oh my gosh, Wonderstate Coffee is just the best! It’s on Main Street, and every time I go there, I feel so cozy and happy inside. The place is super cute, and I love that I can sit inside or outside, depending on how the weather is. It’s a perfect spot to chill with a yummy bagel and a warm drink!

What I really love about Wonderstate is their amazing coffee and delicious bagels. They have so many choices! My favorite is the plain bagel with their creamy cream cheese. It’s simple but oh-so-good, and you can really taste how fresh it is.

And if you want something warm, you have to try their coffee! It’s rich and smooth, and it goes perfectly with any bagel. You’re gonna want to come back again and again!

6. Marigold Kitchen

Marigold Kitchen: My Happy Place for Bagels

Oh my gosh, Marigold Kitchen is just the cutest place ever! It’s on Pinckney Street, and every time I go there, I feel so happy because it’s so bright and cheerful. I love that I can sit inside or outside, especially when the sun is shining. It’s a perfect spot for breakfast or lunch!

What I really love about Marigold Kitchen is their super creative menu. They have so many yummy choices! My favorite is the bagel with avocado and a sprinkle of everything seasoning. It’s fresh and so tasty, and it really shows how they like to make things special.

And if you’re looking for something sweet, you have to try their homemade granola! It’s crunchy and delicious, and it makes the perfect snack with your bagel. You’re gonna want to come back for more!

7. Ancora Cafe + Bakery

Ancora Cafe + Bakery: My Cozy Bagel Place

Oh my gosh, Ancora Cafe + Bakery is just the sweetest little spot! It’s on King Street, and every time I go there, I feel so warm and happy inside. The place is super charming, and I love that I can sit inside or outside, depending on how the weather is. It’s a perfect place for breakfast or brunch!

What I really love about Ancora is their yummy house-made goodies and creative egg sandwiches. My favorite is the bagel with a fluffy egg and cheese. It’s warm and so delicious, and you can really taste how fresh everything is!

And if you’re looking for something sweet, you have to try their pastries! They are so tasty and make the perfect treat to enjoy with your coffee. You’re gonna want to come back for more!

8. Stalzy’s Deli

Stalzy’s Deli: My Favorite Deli Spot

Oh my gosh, Stalzy’s Deli is just the coolest place ever! It’s on Atwood Avenue, and every time I go there, I get so excited! When I walk in, I see all the yummy sandwiches and bagels, and it makes my tummy rumble with happiness! The vibe is super friendly, and I really like that they have curbside pickup, which is super handy when I’m in a hurry.

What I love about Stalzy’s Deli is how fresh everything is. My favorite is the bagel with turkey and cream cheese. It’s so tasty and really shows how much care they put into their food!

And if you’re looking for something warm, you have to try their homemade soups! They are so comforting and make the perfect side with your bagel. You’re gonna want to come back for more!

9. Greenbush Bakery

Greenbush Bakery: My Favorite Sweet Spot

Oh my gosh, Greenbush Bakery is just the best place ever! It’s on Regent Street, and every time I go there, I feel so excited! When I walk in, I see all the yummy donuts and bagels, and it makes my mouth water! It’s a family-owned bakery, and you can really feel the love in every bite.

What I really love about Greenbush Bakery is their super fun flavors. My favorite is the maple bacon donut. It’s sweet and salty, and it’s like a little party in my mouth!

And if you want something classic, you have to try their plain bagel with cream cheese. It’s fresh and delicious, and it’s the perfect way to start your day. You’re gonna want to go back for more!

10. Paleo Mama Bakery

Paleo Mama Bakery: My Favorite Healthy Treat Spot

Oh my gosh, Paleo Mama Bakery is such a neat place! It’s on Few Street, and every time I go there, I feel so happy! When I walk in, I see all the yummy treats, and it makes my mouth water! They focus on healthy, paleo-friendly goodies, which is super cool.

What I really love about Paleo Mama Bakery is how they use fresh, wholesome ingredients. My favorite is the almond flour bagel. It’s soft and tasty, and it’s perfect for anyone who wants something healthy!

And if you’re in the mood for something sweet, you have to try their chocolate chip cookies! They are chewy and delicious, and they make the perfect treat to enjoy with your bagel. You’re gonna want to come back for more!

Map of Bagels in Madison, WI

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best bagel shops in Madison, WI?
Oh, there are so many great bagel shops in Madison! Some of my favorites are Bagels Forever, Einstein Bros. Bagels, Gotham Bagels, and Mermaid Kitchen. Each place has its own yummy flavors, and you really can’t go wrong with any of them!

2. Are there gluten-free bagel options in Madison?
Yes, there are gluten-free bagel options at some shops! It’s always a good idea to ask the staff or check the menu to see what they have available.

3. Can I get bagels delivered in Madison?
Absolutely! Many bagel places, like Einstein Bros. and Gotham Bagels, offer delivery. You can enjoy your favorite bagels right at home, which is super nice!

4. What are some popular bagel toppings?
Oh, there are so many tasty toppings! Some popular ones are cream cheese, lox, avocado, and different spreads. You can even find fun flavors like hummus or flavored cream cheeses at some shops!

5. Do any bagel shops in Madison offer vegan options?
Yes, definitely! A lot of bagel shops in Madison have vegan options. You can find bagels made without dairy and yummy plant-based spreads to enjoy. It’s great for everyone!