Long Island’s bagel scene is a hidden treasure for anyone who loves a fresh, chewy bagel with the perfect crust. Over the years, I’ve tasted countless bagels across the island—from small family-run shops to bustling bakeries—and each offers its own unique twist. There’s a certain comfort in biting into a bagel that’s expertly boiled and baked, especially when it’s paired with cream cheese or innovative toppings. Long Island’s bakeries have mastered this craft, blending tradition with a dash of creativity, making it a culinary experience worth exploring.
If you’re searching for the best bagels in Long Island, you’re in for a treat. This guide will introduce you to standout bakeries that have earned loyal followings thanks to their dedication to quality and flavor. Whether you prefer a classic plain bagel or something more inventive, these spots promise a memorable bite. Follow along as we explore the top contenders, and discover what makes each one uniquely exceptional.
Where to find the best bagels in Long Island, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Long Island, NY:
- Terrace Bagelry and Deli
- Bagel Brothers
- Stuff A Bagel Inc
- Holbrook Bagel
- Boiled & Baked Old Fashioned
- New York Authentic Bagel
- Bella’s Ny Bagels Baked Goods Inc
- Stacie’s Bagels
- Bagel Patch
- New York Bagel Company
1. Terrace Bagelry and Deli
Nestled in Islip Terrace, Terrace Bagelry and Deli is a beloved spot known for its consistent quality and friendly atmosphere. I’ve always appreciated their warm, freshly baked bagels that strike the perfect balance between chewy and crispy. Their dedication to freshness makes every visit feel like a treat.
What truly sets Terrace Bagelry and Deli apart is their variety of classic and creative bagels, all made with care. I recommend trying their everything bagel with creamy smoked salmon or their plain bagel topped with rich, local cream cheese. These choices showcase their commitment to authentic, flavorful bagels that reflect true Long Island craftsmanship. It’s a place that understands the art of a good bagel.
2. Bagel Brothers
Located on Main Street in Holbrook, Bagel Brothers offers a warm, inviting setting for bagel lovers. I’ve enjoyed their consistently fresh bagels, which are crispy on the outside and soft on the inside—an ideal base for any topping. Their quick service and spacious parking make it a convenient spot for breakfast or a quick lunch.
What makes Bagel Brothers special is their wide selection and high-quality ingredients. I recommend the salt bagel with a generous smear of cream cheese or their hearty bagel sandwich. Each bite reflects their dedication to authentic Long Island bagel craftsmanship and satisfying flavors. It’s a place that truly values delivering a classic yet memorable experience.
3. Stuff A Bagel Inc
(631) 582-5222Call
Located on Willow Street in Central Islip, Stuff A Bagel Inc is a go-to spot for authentic, freshly baked bagels. I’ve always appreciated their warm, chewy bagels that are perfect for breakfast or a quick snack. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere make every visit enjoyable.
What sets Stuff A Bagel Inc apart is their dedication to quality and variety. I highly recommend trying their plain bagel with a generous spread of cream cheese or their popular breakfast bagel sandwich. Each bite showcases their commitment to traditional bagel baking and satisfying flavors. It’s a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Long Island bagels.
4. Holbrook Bagel
(631) 981-0848Call
Located on Lincoln Avenue, Holbrook Bagel is a neighborhood favorite known for its straightforward, quality bagels. I’ve enjoyed their no-nonsense approach—fresh, chewy bagels that pair perfectly with cream cheese or your favorite spreads. It’s the kind of place that delivers consistent satisfaction every visit.
What makes Holbrook Bagel stand out is their focus on crafting authentic, classic bagels without unnecessary fuss. I recommend trying their plain or everything bagel with a hearty smear of cream cheese. It’s a simple yet delicious choice that highlights their dedication to true bagel quality. For those seeking a reliable spot for a satisfying bagel, this place hits the mark.
5. Boiled & Baked Old Fashioned
Situated in Bohemia, Boiled & Baked Old Fashioned lives up to its name with classic techniques and a nostalgic vibe. I’ve always enjoyed their perfectly boiled, chewy bagels that are baked to golden perfection. Visiting this spot feels like a step back in time, highlighting authentic New York bagel craftsmanship.
What sets Boiled & Baked Old Fashioned apart is their commitment to tradition and quality. I recommend trying their everything bagel loaded with cream cheese or their signature lox bagel. Each bite reflects their dedication to delivering rich, flavorful, and well-crafted bagels that honor Long Island’s storied bagel heritage.
6. New York Authentic Bagel
(631) 648-9939Call
Located on Ronkonkoma Avenue, New York Authentic Bagel offers a genuine taste of classic New York bagels. I’ve enjoyed their fresh, hand-rolled bagels that deliver that perfect chewiness and deep flavor. The setting is friendly, making each visit a straightforward pleasure.
What makes New York Authentic Bagel stand out is their dedication to traditional preparation. I recommend their plain or sesame bagel with a spread of cream cheese, or their hearty bagel with smoked fish. These choices capture the true essence of Long Island’s bagel heritage—simple, flavorful, and expertly made. It’s a spot where authenticity and quality come together seamlessly.
7. Bella’s Ny Bagels Baked Goods Inc
(631) 319-1296Call
Located on Smithtown Avenue, Bella’s NY Bagels Baked Goods Inc is a cozy spot famous for its fresh, flavorful bagels. I’ve always appreciated their consistent quality and the inviting aroma of baking bagels that greets you upon arrival. It’s a perfect place for a quick breakfast or a snack on the go.
What makes Bella’s NY Bagels stand out is their dedication to traditional baking techniques and using only the freshest ingredients. I highly recommend their everything bagel with a generous layer of cream cheese or their classic bagel and lox. These selections truly exemplify their commitment to authentic Long Island bagel craftsmanship—simple, satisfying, and delicious.
8. Stacie’s Bagels
Located on Hawkins Avenue, Stacie’s Bagels has earned a reputation for its fresh, hand-crafted bagels. During my visits, I’ve always appreciated the soft, chewy texture and the welcoming atmosphere that makes every meal feel special. Their attention to quality makes them stand out in the Long Island bagel scene.
What sets Stacie’s Bagels apart is their dedication to traditional baking and customer satisfaction. I recommend their plain or everything bagel with cream cheese, or their classic bagel sandwich. Each bite offers a true taste of Long Island’s bagel heritage—simple, flavorful, and consistently delicious.
9. Bagel Patch
On Sunrise Highway in Holbrook, Bagel Patch is a standout for its fresh, flavorful bagels and welcoming atmosphere. I’ve always enjoyed their warm, chewy bagels that are perfect for breakfast or a quick snack. Their dedication to quality keeps me coming back.
What makes Bagel Patch unique is their wide variety of bagels and creative toppings. I recommend the everything bagel with cream cheese or their popular bagel with lox. These choices showcase their craftsmanship and fresh ingredients, embodying the best of Long Island’s bagel tradition—simple, satisfying, and made with care.
10. New York Bagel Company
Located at Islandia Shopping Center, New York Bagel Company offers a convenient spot for fresh, delicious bagels. I’ve enjoyed visiting their welcoming shop, where the aroma of baking bagels greets you as soon as you walk in. Their consistent quality makes it a favorite among locals.
What makes New York Bagel Company stand out is their focus on classic flavors with a variety of toppings. I recommend their plain or everything bagel with cream cheese or their hearty bagel with smoked fish. These selections highlight their dedication to authentic, flavorful bagels that reflect Long Island’s rich bagel tradition.
More Things to Try in Long Island, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What makes Long Island bagels different from other regions?
A: Long Island bagels are known for their chewy texture, shiny crust, and rich flavor. They are typically boiled before baking, which gives them their characteristic firmness and glossy finish. The traditional methods and high-quality ingredients contribute to their distinctive taste.
Q: Are there gluten-free bagel options available in Long Island?
A: Yes, some bakeries on Long Island offer gluten-free bagels. It’s best to check with specific shops beforehand, as availability varies. Look for places that emphasize gluten-free products if you need this option.
Q: What are popular bagel toppings or fillings in Long Island?
A: Classic toppings include cream cheese, lox (smoked salmon), butter, and jam. Popular fillings are bagel sandwiches with deli meats, eggs, and cheese, perfect for a hearty breakfast or lunch.
Q: Can I find vegan or vegetarian bagel options in Long Island?
A: Absolutely. Many bakeries offer vegan cream cheese options and vegetarian fillings like vegetables, hummus, or plant-based spreads. Always ask about vegan choices when ordering.
Q: What’s the best time to visit bagel shops in Long Island?
A: Early mornings, around 7 to 9 am, are ideal for the freshest bagels and least crowds. Many shops bake in the morning, ensuring your bagel is warm and delicious.