Long Island, NY, is like a bagel lover’s paradise! Seriously, if you’re a fan of bagels, you’re in for a treat. There are so many amazing bagel shops here, each with its own special twist. I’ve tasted my way through countless bagels, and I’m excited to share the best spots with you. Trust me, you’ll want to know where to find the tastiest bagels around!
So, what are the best bagels in Long Island, NY? The best bagels here are super chewy and packed with flavor. You can find everything from classic plain bagels to fun, creative flavors that will blow your mind. Each shop has its own style, and they really know how to make a bagel that you’ll remember!
Get ready to dive into a list of the top bagel shops on Long Island! I’ll share my favorites, and you’ll discover some hidden gems that you absolutely need to try. Whether you like them toasted with cream cheese or loaded with toppings, there’s something for everyone. Let’s get started!
Top 10 Bagels in Long Island, NY
- Bagel Boss Hicksville
- A&S Bagels
- Avenue Bagels
- Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company
- Long Island Bagel Cafe
- Bagel Gallery
- Long Island Bagel Cafe
- Bricktown Bagels & Cafe
- Bagel Chalet
- The Bagel Place
1. Bagel Boss Hicksville
Phone: (516) 681-1856
Menu: www.theoriginalbagelboss.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Boss Hicksville is one of my favorite bagel spots! When you walk in, it just feels cozy and welcoming. The staff is super friendly, and they always have a smile on their faces. I love how they bake their bagels fresh every day, so you know you’re getting something really tasty.
What makes Bagel Boss special is their everything bagel. Oh my gosh, it’s so chewy and packed with flavor! I like to get it with their homemade scallion cream cheese. It’s the perfect combo, and I can’t get enough of it!
If you’re really hungry, you have to try their breakfast sandwiches. The bacon, egg, and cheese on a toasted bagel is just the best! It’s filling and delicious, and I always leave feeling super happy. You’ve got to check it out!
2. A&S Bagels
Phone: (516) 326-9288
Menu: www.aandsbagels.com
Directions: Open on Map
A&S Bagels is one of my go-to places for bagels! It’s open 24/7, which is super awesome because I can grab a bagel anytime I want. When I walk in, the smell of fresh bagels and yummy baked goods makes my mouth water. It’s such a happy place!
What I really love about A&S Bagels is how many choices they have. They have all kinds of bagels and even deli sandwiches! My favorite is the plain bagel with cream cheese. It’s so soft and fluffy, and it just hits the spot every time.
If you want to try something special, you should definitely get their bialys. They’re like bagels but with a tasty filling in the middle. They’re so good, and I always grab a few to take home. A&S Bagels is a must-try for sure!
3. Avenue Bagels
Phone: (631) 667-7399
Menu: avenuebagelsdeerpark.com
Directions: Open on Map
Avenue Bagels is one of my favorite spots to grab a bagel! I love going there because it has such a nice feel, and you can choose to sit inside or outside. The people who work there are super friendly, and they always make me smile. Plus, their bagels are fresh and oh-so-yummy!
What really makes Avenue Bagels special is all the different flavors they have. It’s like a bagel wonderland! My top pick is the cinnamon raisin bagel. It’s sweet and soft, and when I spread cream cheese on it, it’s just the best treat ever!
If you’re up for something a little different, you should definitely try their jalapeño bagel. It has a fun little kick, and it’s awesome with cream cheese, too. Avenue Bagels is a must-visit for sure!
4. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company
Phone: (718) 932-8280
Menu: www.bkbagel.com
Directions: Open on Map
Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! I love going there because it has such a fun and lively vibe. You can sit inside or outside, and it’s always a nice spot to relax. The best part? They make kettle-boiled bagels, which makes them super chewy and oh-so-delicious!
What really makes Brooklyn Bagel special is how you can pick your bagel and then choose from so many yummy spreads. It’s like a bagel adventure! My go-to is the everything bagel with garlic cream cheese. It’s so full of flavor, and I just can’t get enough of it!
If you want to try something really tasty, you should definitely get their smoked salmon bagel. It’s fresh and packed with flavor, making it a perfect treat. Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company is a must-try for sure!
5. Long Island Bagel Cafe
Phone: (516) 427-5454
Menu: www.libagelcafe.com
Directions: Open on Map
Long Island Bagel Cafe is one of my favorite places to go for bagels! I really enjoy visiting because it has such a cozy and friendly vibe. You can sit inside or outside, and the staff always greets you with a smile. The best part is that their bagels are super fresh and oh-so-yummy!
What makes Long Island Bagel Cafe special is the huge variety of bagels and spreads they have. There’s something for everyone, which is awesome! My personal favorite is the blueberry bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and soft, and it feels like a little treat every time I have it!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast bagel sandwich. The egg and cheese on a toasted bagel is just so good! Long Island Bagel Cafe is a must-visit for sure!
6. Bagel Gallery
Phone: (631) 360-8406
Menu: 24hrhotbagels.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Gallery is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! I really enjoy going there because it has such a chill vibe, and you can sit inside or outside, which is nice. The staff is always super friendly, and they make you feel so welcome. Plus, their bagels are always fresh and oh-so-yummy!
What makes Bagel Gallery special is the huge variety of bagels and toppings they offer. There are so many flavors to pick from! My favorite is the sesame bagel with cream cheese. It’s crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, and it’s just the best!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese. It’s super tasty and fills you up just right! Bagel Gallery is a must-visit for sure!
7. Long Island Bagel Cafe
Phone: (516) 781-6575
Menu: libc.com
Directions: Open on Map
Long Island Bagel Cafe is one of my favorite places to go for bagels! I love how cozy it feels, and you can sit inside or outside, which is really nice. The staff is always super friendly, and they make you feel so welcome. Plus, their bagels are always fresh and super tasty!
What really makes Long Island Bagel Cafe special is the big variety of bagels and spreads they have. There’s something for everyone, which is awesome! My favorite is the poppy seed bagel with cream cheese. It’s soft and delicious, and I just can’t get enough of it!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast bagel sandwich with sausage, egg, and cheese. It’s so yummy and fills you up just right! Long Island Bagel Cafe is a place you have to check out!
8. Bricktown Bagels & Cafe
Phone: (718) 361-2428
Menu: bricktownbagelcafelongisland.mknxonline.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bricktown Bagels & Cafe is one of my favorite places to go for a bagel! I really enjoy visiting because it has such a fun and cozy vibe with its cool exposed-brick walls and mismatched mirrors. You can sit inside or outside, and the staff is always super friendly, which makes me feel right at home. Plus, their bagels are always fresh and so yummy!
What really makes Bricktown Bagels special is their awesome menu. They have bagels, wraps, and salads, so there’s something for everyone! My go-to is the everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s so full of flavor, and I just love it!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast wrap. It’s packed with eggs, cheese, and your choice of meat. It’s super tasty and perfect for starting your day! Bricktown Bagels & Cafe is a place you have to check out!
9. Bagel Chalet
Phone: (631) 499-9820
Menu: bagelchalet.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagel Chalet is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! I really enjoy going there because it has a nice, simple feel, and you can sit inside or outside, which is great. The staff is always super friendly, and they make you feel so welcome. Plus, their bagels are always fresh and really tasty!
What makes Bagel Chalet special is their yummy made-to-order sandwiches and salads. They have a great selection, and everything is so good! My favorite is the egg everything bagel with lox spread. It’s so delicious and full of flavor!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast sandwich with bacon, egg, and cheese. It’s super yummy and perfect for starting your day! Bagel Chalet is a place you have to check out!
10. The Bagel Place
Phone: (516) 565-3917
Menu: www.thebagelplacecaterers.com
Directions: Open on Map
The Bagel Place is one of my favorite spots to grab a bagel! I really enjoy going there because it has such a friendly vibe, and you can sit inside or outside, which is nice. The staff is always super nice, and they make you feel right at home. Plus, their bagels are always fresh and super tasty!
What makes The Bagel Place special is their awesome selection of bagels and spreads. There are so many yummy choices! My favorite is the garlic bagel with cream cheese. It’s so full of flavor, and I just love it!
If you’re really hungry, you should definitely try their breakfast sandwich with egg and cheese. It’s super yummy and really gets my day started right! The Bagel Place is a place you have to check out!
Map of Bagels in Long Island, NY
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bagel Boss Hicksville | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| A&S Bagels | Inexpensive | No | Yes | Yes | Inaccessible | – |
| Avenue Bagels | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Long Island Bagel Cafe | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Gallery | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Long Island Bagel Cafe | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bricktown Bagels & Cafe | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel Chalet | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| The Bagel Place | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What makes Long Island bagels different from others?
Long Island bagels are super special because they’re really chewy on the outside and soft on the inside. A lot of places use kettle boiling, which helps make them extra yummy! -
Where can I find the best bagels in Long Island?
You can find amazing bagels at places like Bagel Boss, A&S Bagels, and Brooklyn Bagel & Coffee Company. Each spot has its own tasty flavors, so you should definitely try a few! -
Are there gluten-free bagel options in Long Island?
Yes, many bagel shops have gluten-free bagels! It’s always a good idea to check the menu or just ask the friendly staff for options. -
What are some popular bagel toppings?
Some yummy toppings are cream cheese, lox, butter, and all kinds of spreads like scallion or garlic. You can even add things like tomatoes or bacon for a fun twist! -
Can I get bagels delivered in Long Island?
Absolutely! Lots of bagel shops in Long Island offer delivery, so you can enjoy your favorite bagels at home. Just check their websites for delivery info! -
What time do bagel shops open in Long Island?
Most bagel shops open early, usually around 6 or 7 AM, so you can grab a bagel for breakfast. Some places, like A&S Bagels, are even open 24/7! -
Do bagel shops offer breakfast sandwiches?
Yes, they do! Many bagel shops have delicious breakfast sandwiches with eggs, cheese, and different meats. They’re a great way to start your day! -
Are bagels in Long Island suitable for vegetarians?
Definitely! There are lots of vegetarian options, like different bagels and spreads. If you’re not sure, just ask the staff for some tasty recommendations!
