My search for the best bagels in Lake Mary led me through a journey of flavors and textures that stayed with me. I discovered spots where each bagel carried its own story, reflecting the unique charm of this town. I have tasted bagels that were chewy, lightly crisp, and perfectly balanced with a hint of sweetness or savory depth. This adventure opened my eyes to a community that values tradition and quality in every bite.
Each establishment brings its own twist to a classic favorite. My experiences in Lake Mary have shown me that finding a great bagel involves more than just flavor—it is about the care behind each recipe and the local pride in every creation. The following sections highlight spots that stand out, and I trust you will find this guide as insightful as my own journey.
1. The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Company
+1 407-878-2850
The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Company captures the essence of classic New York bagels, bringing a taste of Brooklyn to Lake Mary. Located conveniently on W Lake Mary Blvd, this spot is perfect for a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch. A cozy atmosphere combined with friendly service makes it a local favorite.
During my visit, I tried their Everything Bagel adorned with a generous layer of cream cheese, and it did not disappoint. The bagel was perfectly chewy with just the right amount of seasoning, exemplifying their commitment to quality.
For a unique twist, order the Avocado Toast on a plain bagel. It’s simple yet packed with flavor, showcasing freshness that sets this establishment apart. If you’re a bagel lover, this place will quickly become your go-to.
2. TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant
+1 407-833-0848
TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant is a cherished gem in Lake Mary, celebrated for its delightful blend of deli and bakery offerings. With a history spanning 40 years, it embodies the spirit of a classic Jewish deli where comfort food reigns supreme. Nestled on Lake Emma Road, this spot is always bustling with loyal customers eager for a taste of home.
On my recent visit, the bagel sandwiches caught my eye. I opted for the Tuna Salad on a fresh bagel, and it was a winning combination with its perfectly balanced flavors. The quality of ingredients really stood out, reflecting TooJay’s commitment to excellence.
If you’re in the mood for breakfast, don’t miss their fantastic Bagel and Lox—it’s a creamy, savory treat that perfectly showcases their dedication to authentic flavors.
3. Bagel King
+1 407-732-7609
Bagel King offers a refreshing twist on traditional bagels in Lake Mary. Located on W Lake Mary Blvd, the ambiance is relaxed yet upbeat, making it a local hotspot for a quick meal.
My visit here turned ordinary breakfast into a memorable meal. I enjoyed a crisp, warm bagel layered with light cream cheese and fresh veggies. The texture and flavor truly highlight their commitment to quality.
For an unbeatable taste, I suggest trying their signature toasted bagel sandwich. The balance of ingredients reflects Bagel King’s focus on simplicity and authentic flavor in every bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best bagels in Lake Mary, FL?
A: Local gems such as The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Company, TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant, and Bagel King offer distinct tastes and freshly baked delights worth trying.
Q: Do these establishments offer options for special dietary needs?
A: Yes, many spots include vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices, ensuring a variety of diet preferences are met.
Q: Can I order bagels for takeout or catering?
A: Absolutely. Several locations provide convenient takeout services, and TooJay’s Deli is known for dependable catering, making it perfect for any event.
Q: What bagel dish should I try first?
A: Start with a classic Bagel and Lox or a signature bagel sandwich. Each bite highlights unique textures and flavors that define Lake Mary’s bagel scene.
