Anyone who’s strolled through Ithaca knows that finding a proper bagel is an adventure of its own. The town buzzes with students and locals, each fiercely loyal to their own favorite spot. I once spent a rainy morning hopping from one bakery to the next, the elusive “perfect bagel” always just around the corner. It turns out, searching for the best bagels in Ithaca is half the fun—and the reward, wrapped in a chewy, golden crust, is always worth it.
Ithaca’s bagel scene is lively, quirky, and packed with surprises. Some places excel at classic, no-frills bagels, while others pile on inventive spreads and sandwiches you didn’t know you needed. If you’re searching for a chewy crumb or just a new go-to breakfast, this guide will steer you straight. Grab your coffee, and read on—finding your favorite bagel is about to get a lot easier.
Where to find the best bagels in Ithaca, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Ithaca, NY:
- Ithaca Bakery
- Collegetown Bagels
- Ithaca Bakery
- Collegetown Bagels
- Collegetown Bagels
- Panera Bread
- Collegetown Bagles Inc
- Dunkin’
1. Ithaca Bakery
As soon as you step into Ithaca Bakery, the aroma of freshly baked bread reels you in. Locals flock here for breakfast, but the relaxed vibe lingers all day. My first visit involved a toasted sesame bagel, still warm, smeared with their house-made cream cheese—simple, but unforgettable.
Ithaca Bakery stands out for its inventive bagel menu and top-tier ingredients. Everything feels handcrafted, from the chewy texture of the bagels to the clever vegetarian and vegan options lining their display. Their rainbow bagel brightens even the cloudiest morning, and the classic everything bagel hits that sought-after balance of salty and satisfying.
If you’re craving something heartier, try a bagel sandwich. The Garden Veggie on a multigrain bagel is filling and fresh, with crisp lettuce and tomato. Every bite feels like proof that Ithaca Bakery sets the bar for bagels in town.
2. Collegetown Bagels
Collegetown Bagels manages to be lively at any hour, packed with regulars and students fueling up for the day. I remember squeezing into a sunlit window seat, a just-toasted asiago bagel in my hands, the perfect base for their creamy scallion spread. It’s the kind of spot that makes breakfast feel like an event.
What makes Collegetown Bagels a standout is the endless variety, from classic New York style bagels to inventive, veggie-packed sandwich creations. Their bright menu lets you experiment or stick to the tried and true. The energy inside is always welcoming, the staff quick to offer suggestions for adventurous eaters.
Don’t miss the veggie breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel, which is both hearty and light, layered with crisp greens and just the right amount of spice. Every order here reflects CTB’s knack for mixing tradition with creativity.
3. Ithaca Bakery
The Ithaca Bakery on Triphammer Road brings the same welcoming bustle as its downtown sibling but feels tucked away, perfect for a quieter morning stop. My last trip here started with a honey wheat bagel, lightly toasted and spread with their signature veggie cream cheese—rich, flavorful, and wonderfully fresh.
What sets this location apart is the display of fresh bagels, all golden and still warm. There’s something comforting about watching staff bustle behind the counter, stacking bagels and prepping sandwiches. The variety impresses, from classic sesame and multigrain to a crisp everything bagel perfect for a build-your-own sandwich.
The lox and cream cheese on an everything bagel always brings the right mix of creamy, salty, and satisfying. This outpost of Ithaca Bakery keeps things simple but never dull—ideal for bagel lovers looking for quality and consistency.
4. Collegetown Bagels
Collegetown Bagels on College Ave sits at the heart of campus life, always buzzing with people and the scent of bagels. I remember standing in line one chilly morning, debating between a toasted whole wheat bagel with plain cream cheese or upgrading to a loaded veggie sandwich. Eventually, the veggie sandwich won, and it didn’t disappoint—crisp, colorful, and filling.
This spot is cherished for its inventive options and the energy that comes from always being open for breakfast, lunch, or even a quick late-night bite. The staff keeps things moving and brings a personal touch to every order.
For a classic Collegetown experience, try the egg and cheese on an everything bagel, or go lighter with a bagel and their tangy hummus. It’s hard to make a wrong choice here.
5. Collegetown Bagels
The East Hill Plaza location of Collegetown Bagels is a quiet favorite for anyone craving the same vibrant menu in a more laid-back spot. My last visit landed me a pumpernickel bagel, toasted and piled high with herbed cream cheese—not too heavy, just right for a late lunch.
What stands out here is the speedy service and the range of options for every appetite. The menu’s just as creative as downtown, and you get the bonus of fast lines and ample seating. The staff know their regulars and always make room for custom orders.
If you’re unsure what to try, start with the classic breakfast bagel sandwich or explore a veggie-packed bagel with their bright hummus spread. There’s comfort in the freshness and flexibility at this CTB outpost.
6. Panera Bread
Panera Bread on South Meadow Street offers a comfortable option for those who crave predictability but still want fresh flavor. I’ve swung by many times for a quick breakfast—the cinnamon swirl bagel, toasted and slathered with plain cream cheese, is one of my favorite ways to start a busy day.
What sets Panera apart is the consistent quality and wide menu, making it a safe bet when you’re in a rush or meeting a friend. The staff are quick, and the space feels relaxed no matter how crowded it gets. Complimentary Wi-Fi and easy takeout also don’t hurt.
Bagel lovers should try the asiago cheese bagel or a classic plain bagel with their rich veggie cream cheese. Panera keeps things simple, but you’ll always find options that hit the spot.
7. Collegetown Bagles Inc
(607) 272-5000Call
Collegetown Bagles Inc sits by the waterfront, a bit off the well-trodden trail, and it’s a spot I stumbled into on a lazy afternoon walk. The calm setting is a change of pace from the busy downtown shops, and you get a bit more space to take in the views while enjoying your meal.
Here, bagels arrive fresh and chewy with a great outer crust—no frills, just the kind of simple perfection bagel lovers appreciate. The menu focuses on staples done well, always stacked with bagels hot from the oven. Staff seem to know exactly what regulars want, and they somehow make ordering easy, even on the first visit.
Try a poppy seed bagel with scallion cream cheese for a savory treat, or pick a classic sesame for your favorite sandwich. The straightforward, relaxed style at Collegetown Bagles Inc is part of its lasting charm.
8. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on Elmira Road delivers what you’d expect: speedy service, plenty of choices, and the kind of consistency that makes busy mornings easier. More than once, I’ve dashed in for a last-minute meeting fuel and left with a perfectly toasted plain bagel and a hot coffee in hand.
What separates Dunkin’ from the rest is pure convenience. The app makes ordering for pickup fast, so you’re never stuck waiting in a line. Staff are quick and the space stays bright and clean even during the breakfast rush.
For bagel seekers, the multigrain or everything bagel with veggie cream cheese is a reliable choice—soft, flavorful, and filling. Dunkin’ keeps things straightforward while still offering a little variety for Ithaca’s on-the-go crowd.
More Things to Try in Ithaca, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the freshest bagels in Ithaca?
Fresh bagels are a given at Ithaca Bakery and Collegetown Bagels. Both places bake daily, so getting there in the morning almost guarantees warm bagels straight from the oven.
Are there gluten-free bagel options in Ithaca?
Yes, most locations, especially Collegetown Bagels and Ithaca Bakery, offer gluten-free bagels alongside their traditional choices.
Which bagel shop has the best vegan options?
Collegetown Bagels is known for creative vegan sandwiches and spreads. Grab a whole wheat or plain bagel topped with hummus and veggies for a satisfying meal.
Can I find classic New York-style bagels in Ithaca?
Absolutely. Ithaca Bakery and Collegetown Bagels both serve bagels that match the classic chewy style and flavor you’d expect from a New York bagel.
Is there a spot with plenty of seating for groups?
Panera Bread and the larger CTB locations usually have ample seating, perfect for group breakfasts or study sessions.