Best Bagels in Ithaca, NY

Ithaca, NY, is such a fun place, especially when it comes to food! One of my absolute favorite things to eat here is bagels. There are so many awesome bagel shops, each with its own special flavors and styles. I can’t wait to share my top picks with you, so you can enjoy the best bagels this town has to offer!

So, what are the best bagels in Ithaca, NY? Well, the best bagels can be found at a few amazing spots around town. Each place has its own yummy bagels, tasty toppings, and a cozy vibe that makes you want to stay a while. Whether you like classic flavors or something a bit different, there’s definitely a bagel for you here!

Stick around, and I’ll take you on a tasty journey through the best bagel shops in Ithaca. You’ll learn all about their unique offerings, the fun atmosphere, and what makes each one special. Trust me, you won’t want to miss out on these delicious bagels!

Top 10 Bagels in Ithaca, NY

1. Collegetown Bagels
2. Bus Stop Bagels
3. Ithaca Bakery
4. Collegetown Bagels
5. Paris Baguette
6. Shortstop Deli
7. Dolce Delight
8. Ooy’s Cafe & Deli
9. Ithaca Bakery
10. Collegetown Bagels

1. Collegetown Bagels

Collegetown Bagels is one of my favorite spots in Ithaca! It’s right on College Ave, and when you walk in, oh my gosh, the smell of fresh bagels hits you! It’s super cozy inside, and you can sit outside too, which is nice on sunny days. I love hanging out there with friends or just grabbing a quick bite.

What makes Collegetown Bagels really special is all the yummy choices. They have so many different bagels and toppings! If you go, you have to try the Everything Bagel with cream cheese. It’s toasted just right and tastes amazing! You can really tell they care about making great food.

Whether you want to eat in or take it to go, Collegetown Bagels is a must-try. Trust me, you’ll love it! And don’t forget to peek at their daily specials; they’re always fun!

2. Bus Stop Bagels

Bus Stop Bagels is one of my favorite places in Ithaca! It’s on Garden Ave, and I remember the first time I walked in. The atmosphere is super relaxed, and you can choose to sit inside or outside, which is awesome when the weather is nice. I love just hanging out there with my friends and enjoying a yummy bagel.

What really makes Bus Stop Bagels special is how friendly everyone is! The staff is always so nice, and the bagels are really fresh. You have to try their Plain Bagel with cream cheese. It’s soft and delicious, and you can tell they really care about making great food.

If you want a quick snack or a chill place to relax, Bus Stop Bagels is the perfect spot. You’re gonna love it!

3. Ithaca Bakery

Ithaca Bakery is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! It’s on N Meadow St, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The smell of fresh bread and bagels was so warm and inviting! The place feels cozy, and you can sit inside or outside, which is super nice when the weather is good.

What makes Ithaca Bakery really special is all the yummy choices they have. They offer so many different baked goods! You have to try their Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and soft, and it just melts in your mouth. You can really taste how fresh and good it is!

If you want a tasty bagel or a nice spot to chill, Ithaca Bakery is the place to go. You’re gonna love it!

4. Collegetown Bagels

Collegetown Bagels is one of my favorite hangouts in Ithaca! It’s on E State St, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The vibe is super chill and cozy, and there are so many comfy spots to sit, whether you want to be inside or outside. I love grabbing a bagel and just relaxing with my friends while sipping on some coffee.

What makes Collegetown Bagels really special is all the yummy choices they have! They offer so many different bagels and shmears that it’s hard to pick just one. If you go, you have to try their Poppy Seed Bagel with veggie cream cheese. It’s fresh and tasty, and the flavors are just perfect together!

If you’re looking for a fun place to hang out or grab a quick bite, Collegetown Bagels is the best spot. You’re gonna have a great time there, trust me!

5. Paris Baguette

Paris Baguette is one of my favorite places to visit in Ithaca! It’s on E State St, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The place is so bright and happy, and I love that you can sit inside or outside. When it’s sunny, I always try to grab a seat outside to enjoy my food.

What makes Paris Baguette really special is all the yummy treats they have! They offer so many delicious baked goods, and it’s hard to choose. You have to try their Spinach and Cheese Bagel. It’s warm, cheesy, and super tasty! You can really tell how fresh it is with every bite.

If you want a nice place to relax or grab a quick snack, Paris Baguette is the perfect spot. You’re gonna have a great time there!

6. Shortstop Deli

Shortstop Deli is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel in Ithaca! It’s on W Seneca St, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The atmosphere is super friendly, and it feels like a cozy little spot where everyone is welcome. I love just hanging out there, enjoying my bagel, and soaking in the chill vibe.

What really makes Shortstop Deli special is their yummy selection of bagels and sandwiches. They have so many tasty choices! You absolutely have to try their Bagel with Lox and cream cheese. It’s fresh, flavorful, and just so delicious! You can really tell they care about making great food.

If you want a quick bite or a nice place to relax, Shortstop Deli is the perfect spot. You’re gonna have a great time there, trust me!

7. Dolce Delight

Dolce Delight is one of my favorite places in Ithaca! It’s on Danby Rd, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The place is so bright and happy, and I love that you can sit inside or outside. When it’s nice out, I always try to grab a seat outside to enjoy my food and the fresh air.

What makes Dolce Delight really special is all the yummy choices they have! They offer so many delicious bagels and treats, it’s hard to pick just one. You have to try their Everything Bagel with cream cheese. It’s super fresh and full of flavor, and you can really taste how good it is!

If you want a nice place to relax or grab a quick snack, Dolce Delight is the perfect spot. You’re gonna have a great time there, trust me!

8. Ooy’s Cafe & Deli

Ooy’s Cafe & Deli is one of my favorite spots in Ithaca! It’s on N Aurora St, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The place feels so cozy and welcoming, and I love that you can sit inside or outside. When the weather is nice, I always grab a seat outside to enjoy my yummy bagel and the fresh air.

What really makes Ooy’s Cafe & Deli special is their tasty menu. They have so many delicious options! You absolutely have to try their Turkey and Avocado Bagel. It’s fresh, creamy, and just so good! You can really tell they use high-quality ingredients, and it makes every bite amazing.

If you’re looking for a fun place to chill or grab a quick bite, Ooy’s Cafe & Deli is the perfect choice. You’re gonna have a great time there, trust me!

9. Ithaca Bakery

Ithaca Bakery is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! It’s on N Triphammer Rd, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The smell of fresh bread and bagels was so warm and inviting! The place feels cozy, and you can sit inside or outside, which is super nice when the weather is good.

What makes Ithaca Bakery really special is all the yummy choices they have. They offer so many different baked goods! You have to try their Blueberry Bagel with cream cheese. It’s sweet and soft, and it just melts in your mouth. You can really taste how fresh and good it is!

If you want a tasty bagel or a nice spot to chill, Ithaca Bakery is the place to go. You’re gonna love it!

10. Collegetown Bagels

Collegetown Bagels is one of my favorite places to grab a bagel! It’s on Pine Tree Rd, and I still remember the first time I walked in. The place feels so cozy and welcoming, and I love that you can sit inside or outside. When it’s nice out, I always try to grab a seat outside to enjoy my bagel and the fresh air.

What makes Collegetown Bagels really special is all the yummy choices they have! They offer so many different bagels and toppings that it’s hard to pick just one. You have to try their Garlic Bagel with cream cheese. It’s fresh and super tasty, and you can really tell they care about making great food!

If you’re looking for a fun place to relax or grab a quick bite, Collegetown Bagels is the perfect spot. You’re gonna have a great time there, trust me!

Map of Bagels in Ithaca, NY

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best bagel shops in Ithaca, NY?
  The best bagel shops in Ithaca are places like Collegetown Bagels, Bus Stop Bagels, and Ithaca Bakery. Each one has its own yummy bagels and fun atmosphere, making them super popular with everyone!

• Do these bagel shops offer delivery?
  Yes, many bagel shops in Ithaca, like Collegetown Bagels and Ithaca Bakery, do offer delivery. It’s always a good idea to check their websites to see what they have and when they deliver.

• Are there vegetarian or vegan options available?
  For sure! Most bagel shops in Ithaca have vegetarian and some vegan options. You can find delicious bagels that everyone can enjoy!