There’s an art to the perfect bagel. Some swear by the glossy crust and chewy middle, while others insist only a good schmear transforms it. In Hurley, NY, the search for bagel perfection is a small adventure—one paved with the scent of warm dough and fresh coffee.
My own bagel pursuits have led to early-morning queues and heated debates on seeds versus plain. I’ve learned that the best bagel shops mix tradition, a hint of local flavor, and a dash of personality. If you’re ready to explore Hurley’s standout spots, this guide will show you where to find the bagels worth getting out of bed for.
Where to find the best bagels in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Hurley, NY:
- Sunrise Bagel & Deli
- B and B Bagels
- Bodacious Bagels
- Moonrise Bagels
- Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe
- Lox of Bagels
- New Paltz Bagel Cafe
- Bagel Shoppe
- Eastdale Ave Bagels
- Bagel Bites
1. Sunrise Bagel & Deli
Sunrise Bagel & Deli isn’t just another bagel spot—it’s a local favorite where comfort and flavor meet. The first thing you notice when you walk in is the friendly buzz that makes early mornings feel a little brighter. The bagels here come out of the oven with just the right balance of chew and golden crispness.
There’s a clear sense that the team knows their craft. Each order feels thoughtfully made, whether you’re picking up a bagel on the go or lingering over breakfast. Try the classic sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese or the everything bagel layered with lox-style spreads. Both are reliable standbys that showcase the shop’s knack for fresh ingredients and real bagel tradition.
For a quick lunch, their deli-style bagel sandwiches never feel rushed. It’s a stop that keeps both regulars and newcomers coming back for more.
2. B and B Bagels
B and B Bagels thrives on simplicity done well. Tucked into Kingston Plaza, this spot is where I first realized how a fresh bagel can change your morning. The smell alone, when you walk in, hints you’re in for something good.
The bagels are robust and have a satisfying heft. Their plain and poppy bagels offer that old-school chew you only get from proper boiling and baking. Each bite is springy, never doughy.
For a classic pick, try a warm poppy seed bagel with veggie cream cheese. Or, go for an egg bagel paired with their house-made spreads. Here, bagel purists and flavor seekers can both leave happy.
3. Bodacious Bagels
Bodacious Bagels is the kind of place that makes the drive to Stone Ridge absolutely worth it. There’s a welcoming rhythm to the way bagels come out of the oven—always fresh, and still warm if you time it right. Their signature is a deep, golden crust with a tender, airy inside.
I remember my first bite of their whole wheat bagel. The flavor was richer than most, clearly the work of someone who cares about details. If you’re up for adventure, the rye bagel with a spread of chive cream cheese won’t disappoint.
Bodacious Bagels keeps the focus on quality and consistency. It’s a local staple for anyone who wants their bagel fix done right every single time.
4. Moonrise Bagels
Moonrise Bagels in Woodstock is where bagel craft gets a creative twist. The shop feels both classic and modern, and you get the sense that the bakers treat each batch like a small event. The bagels are beautifully dense, with a satisfying crackle on the crust.
One visit turned me into a fan after their everything bagel—piled with fresh vegetables—made breakfast feel like something special. Their herb bagel offers bursts of flavor that are just as good on their own as with a swipe of cream cheese.
If you want a little outside-the-box, Moonrise delivers. Seasonal specials and unique spreads set them apart from the usual lineup, making it a smart pick for both loyal bagel fans and the curious.
5. Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe
Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe blends small-town charm with excellent bagel-making. There’s a steady stream of regulars, each knowing they’ll leave with something warm and satisfying. The texture here is just right—crisp on the outside, soft and flavorful inside.
I still think about their cinnamon raisin bagel, generously dotted with juicy raisins and perfectly balanced spice. If you’re after something a bit more savory, their onion bagels with a simple cream cheese spread really let the bagel shine.
This is the place where the staff know your usual, and you never have to rush. When you want a bagel experience that feels like a ritual, Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe is the one to seek out.
6. Lox of Bagels
Lox of Bagels in Saugerties brings that classic New York bagel vibe a bit closer to Hurley. This is a place where bagels are taken seriously—the racks are always full, but nothing sits around for long. If you like your bagels with an old-world nod, this spot delivers every time.
My go-to here is the sesame bagel with a garden veggie spread. The bagels are sturdy yet not too heavy, providing the perfect base for any topping. You’ll taste care in every bite, with dough that’s flavorful on its own.
Lox of Bagels manages that ideal blend of reliable, tasty, and unpretentious. It’s the kind of place worth a short drive for a weekend treat.
7. New Paltz Bagel Cafe
New Paltz Bagel Cafe is where freshness and variety take center stage. The moment you step inside, the shelves are lined with every classic you’d hope for, plus a few surprises. The bagels here impress with their chewy centers and crisp, just-baked crusts.
I first tried their oat bran bagel on a colder morning. It had a deep, nutty flavor that works beautifully with a simple honey walnut cream cheese. Their salt bagels are a bold pick for those who want a bit of bite, best enjoyed with their rich, homemade spreads.
This place is big on quick service and big flavors. If you want bagels that don’t nap under the heat lamp, New Paltz Bagel Cafe is a must.
8. Bagel Shoppe
Bagel Shoppe in Red Hook has a steady following, thanks to its fresh approach to tradition. The place has a no-nonsense vibe, focused on letting the bagels speak for themselves. Their bagels are delightfully plump, with just the right chew and a hint of sweetness.
I became a regular after trying their multi-grain bagel, loaded with seeds. This one pairs especially well with their light, whipped cream cheese, letting the wholesome flavors stand out.
Bagel Shoppe’s simple menu means everything gets done right. It’s a solid pick for anyone who likes classic bagels, served quickly and always fresh.
9. Eastdale Ave Bagels
(845) 595-8711Call
Eastdale Ave Bagels in Poughkeepsie might fly under the radar, but for those in the know, it’s a little gem. Every bagel here feels like it’s made with care, not just in the baking but in the way it’s served. The result is a firm crust with a perfectly balanced soft center.
I like to stop by for their classic plain bagel toasted, then topped with a thick, creamy spread. Their everything bagel is generously seasoned, which makes each bite more interesting than the last.
If you’re after good service and consistently tasty bagels, this shop should be on your list. Eastdale Ave Bagels is quietly dependable, perfect for quick mornings or a relaxing start to your day.
10. Bagel Bites
Bagel Bites in Highland is a spot where flavor meets value. The menu is straightforward, but the freshness makes every trip worthwhile. The bagels here have a cheerful bounce to them—always soft but never lacking in chew.
I stumbled in one morning for their whole wheat bagel, lightly toasted, and it’s been my go-to ever since. Their vegetable cream cheese is a top pick, packing plenty of real veggies in each spoonful.
Bagel Bites keeps it easy and reliable, perfect for those days when you want something satisfying without fuss. If you want classic bagels at a good price, this is a solid stop.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the freshest bagels near Hurley, NY?
You’ll find the freshest bagels at local bakeries and delis around Hurley, including Sunrise Bagel & Deli, B and B Bagels, and Bodacious Bagels. These spots bake throughout the morning, so get there early for the best selection.
Do any bagel shops near Hurley offer gluten-free options?
Some places in the area offer gluten-free choices. It’s best to call ahead, as selections may vary and sometimes sell out quickly.
Are there vegan-friendly bagel options?
Most bagel shops offer classic bagels that are naturally vegan. Plain, sesame, poppy, and everything bagels are usually made without animal products, but always check with the shop for ingredient details.
What makes a New York-style bagel different?
A New York-style bagel is known for its chewy texture and shiny crust, created by boiling before baking. It’s dense but not tough, and packed with flavor inside and out.
Can I get bagel sandwiches at these shops?
Yes, many places like Sunrise Bagel & Deli and Rhinebeck Bagels & Cafe serve breakfast and lunch bagel sandwiches. They use fresh ingredients and let you build your own or choose from popular combos.
Which bagel shops are best for a quick stop?
Bagel Bites and Bagel Shoppe both offer fast, friendly service. Perfect for when you’re short on time but want something filling and fresh.