Bagels in Goshen are a quiet obsession. Stroll down Main Street in the early morning, and you’ll spot regulars huddled near steamy windows, deciding between poppy and plain. The smell alone could sway the most stubborn toast enthusiast. Finding a great bagel isn’t just about a doughy carb—it’s about texture, chew, and that bit of local personality.
After countless “taste tests”—which are much more fun than they sound—I’ve come to believe Goshen might be hiding the best bagels in all of Orange County. Each shop has its own secret, from hand-rolled techniques passed down through generations, to cream cheese spreads that border on legendary. What follows isn’t a list pulled out of thin air, but hard-won knowledge, built on early mornings and plenty of coffee. If you want to know where to find a bagel worth getting out of bed for, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best bagels in Goshen, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Goshen, NY:
- Orange County Bagel
- Not Just Bagels
- Dunkin’
- Bagel Girls Cafe
- Downtown Bagels
- The Bagel Shop & Deli
- Orange County Bagel Bakery
- Bagel Boys of Monroe
- C & D’s Old World Bagels
- C and D’s Old World Bagels
1. Orange County Bagel
Orange County Bagel is the kind of spot where the line often snakes out the door, and everyone acts like it’s no big deal. The staff seems to know half the customers by name, and there’s always a little friendly banter at the register. My first visit was on a chilly morning; I left with a warm sesame bagel and the sense I’d stumbled onto a local secret.
The menu is rooted in classic New York bagel tradition. I recommend the egg bagel with a swipe of scallion cream cheese—soft, chewy, and seriously satisfying. If you want more bite, their everything bagel loaded with veggie spread is the move. Orange County Bagel nails the basics and makes them unforgettable.
2. Not Just Bagels
Not Just Bagels has a way of making simple things taste like part of a celebration. The shop feels cozy, with shelves lined with fresh bagels just behind the counter. The scent of baking dough pulls you in before you even decide what to order. First time I dropped by, a rush of regulars filed through, happily swapping stories as they waited.
It’s cash only here, but that hasn’t stopped a steady stream of loyal locals. Try their onion bagel with homemade vegetable cream cheese—the savory crunch and creamy topping land perfectly. If you lean classic, the plain bagel still impresses. Each bite has the ideal balance of crust and chew, showing off what Not Just Bagels does best.
3. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ in Goshen is the spot for those who like their mornings with a side of efficiency. Even early on a busy weekday, you can count on fast service and a fresh cup of coffee. The bright lights and familiar hum make it a go-to when routine is what you crave—sometimes, predictability is a comfort.
Dunkin’ doesn’t pretend to be a local bagel institution, but it delivers reliable classics. Their multigrain bagel with plain cream cheese is a quick, satisfying choice. If you’re hungry, the bagel sandwiches here offer soft bread and custom toppings. It’s not artisanal, but sometimes you just need simple and tasty with no fuss. Here, you get just that.
4. Bagel Girls Cafe
Bagel Girls Cafe feels like a neighborhood hangout, where the coffee is strong and the bagels always look fresh out of the oven. The playful vibe—chalkboard menus, comfy chairs, laughter from a corner table—gives it real local charm. My first stop at Bagel Girls had me hooked when the staff greeted customers by name, making everyone feel like a regular.
Their cinnamon raisin bagel with whipped cream cheese is a classic pick, with sweetness and tang that balance just right. If savory is your thing, the garlic bagel with scallion spread is both fragrant and full-flavored. Bagel Girls Cafe is proof you don’t have to travel far for that perfect morning bite—just follow the scent of fresh bagels.
5. Downtown Bagels
Downtown Bagels manages to pull off that classic deli energy—quick-moving but always friendly. The shelves are stacked high, and the selection covers every craving, from sweet to savory. On my last visit, I took my time at the counter, eyeing the bagels while the regulars breezed through their orders.
The salt bagel is a standout, especially when paired with their smooth chive cream cheese. For something on the hearty side, their bagel breakfast sandwich balances fresh bread with warm, satisfying fillings. Downtown Bagels stays busy for a reason—they know how to serve up no-nonsense, memorable bagels any time of day. If you want a classic New York experience in Goshen, this shop delivers.
6. The Bagel Shop & Deli
The Bagel Shop & Deli is a place where grabbing breakfast feels like catching up with a friend. The aroma of fresh bagels and the buzz from the deli counter set the scene. Every visit, you’ll spot regulars enjoying their favorite orders, which says a lot about the loyalty this spot inspires.
The whole wheat bagel with classic plain cream cheese always hits the mark. For something more filling, the bagel deli sandwiches layer mild cheeses and crisp veggies on a chewy foundation. This shop’s attention to both classic flavors and hearty options means you never leave disappointed. When you’re searching for a reliable breakfast or lunch, The Bagel Shop & Deli makes it easy.
7. Orange County Bagel Bakery
Orange County Bagel Bakery brings old-school charm to the Middletown bagel scene. The prices are refreshingly down-to-earth, and the atmosphere feels honest—just good bagels, friendly staff, and hardly any fuss. It’s the kind of place where your order is remembered if you show up often enough.
Their pumpernickel bagel with veggie cream cheese stands out for bold flavor and a satisfying chew. If you’re indecisive, the baker’s dozen gives you a little of everything, all fresh and perfectly crisp. Orange County Bagel Bakery is ideal when you want tradition and value in every bite, all served up before the morning rush even hits.
8. Bagel Boys of Monroe
Bagel Boys of Monroe brings a mix of fun and classic flavor to its spot in the Monroe Shopping Center. The glass cases are always filled with rows of fresh, glossy bagels, and the morning crowd gives everything a lively buzz. My trip there kicked off with a friendly hello and ended with a bag full of warm, chewy bagels to share.
The French toast bagel has just the right touch of sweetness, and it pairs nicely with a whipped honey cream cheese. If you like things on the savory side, the sesame bagel loaded with veggie spread is a solid bet. Bagel Boys of Monroe proves that simple recipes and fresh ingredients can still keep a line out the door.
9. C & D’s Old World Bagels
(845) 981-7156Call
C & D’s Old World Bagels lives up to its name, offering bagels that taste like they’ve been perfected over generations. The chewy crust and just-right density show off that classic technique. When I stopped by, the morning rush included folks picking up a dozen—always a sign a spot’s doing things right.
The rye bagel with a simple schmear shines for its earthy flavor and satisfying bite. The poppy seed option is another favorite, tacky with seeds and baked fresh. At C & D’s, the focus is on pure, honest bagels. No fancy frills, just tradition in its best form, delivered straight from oven to paper bag.
10. C and D’s Old World Bagels
(845) 988-5046Call
C and D’s Old World Bagels in Warwick is a cozy spot with serious fans of its no-nonsense approach. You won’t find trendy toppings here—just genuinely fresh, flavorful bagels made with old-school technique. My first visit had me chatting with a few regulars, all quick to mention their favorite flavors and why no other place compares.
The everything bagel, balanced with a gentle crust and seeds on every inch, stands out. Pair it with plain cream cheese, and you’ll understand the draw. If you like minimal fuss but full flavor, this spot delivers. At C and D’s, bagels are always the star, and each bite says plenty about their loyal customer base.
More Things to Try in Goshen, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular bagels in Goshen, NY?
The most popular choices tend to be everything, sesame, plain, and cinnamon raisin. Each shop has its specialty, so trying a few is never a bad idea.
Are there any shops with vegan or dairy-free bagel options?
Most local bagel shops offer standard bagels that are naturally dairy-free and vegan. For spreads, call ahead to check for plant-based options.
Can I find gluten-free bagels in Goshen?
Some bakers offer gluten-free bagels, but availability changes. It’s always best to call the shop before you go.
Which bagel shops in Goshen have the best coffee?
Bagel Girls Cafe and Orange County Bagel are known for pairing fresh bagels with solid coffee. If a good brew is as important as your bagel, those two are safe bets.
Do local bagel shops offer catering or large orders?
Yes, most places like Orange County Bagel and Downtown Bagels can handle catering or large orders. Call ahead to place your request and you’ll be set for any crowd.