Bagels hold a special place in Franklin Square. This isn’t just another breakfast ritual. Here, bagel shops spark early-morning debates, and regulars will argue that you can taste the small-batch difference. I still remember the first time I tore into a warm, glossy bagel after a brisk walk down Dogwood Avenue. The chew, that hint of malt, the slight tang—it set a new standard. That’s when I realized: not all bagels are born equal.
If you’re searching for the best bagels in Franklin Square, NY, you’re in the right place. These aren’t your doughy chain bagels, but honed classics and neighborhood gems, where the water, timing, and technique really matter. Whether it’s sesame, plain, or a surprise flavor, this guide sorts through the hype, giving you the confidence to walk in and order like a local. Read on—your next favorite bagel might be just a block away.
Where to find the best bagels in Franklin Square, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Franklin Square, NY:
- Bagel Doctor West
- A & S Bagels
- Cherry Bagel Corp
- Dozen Bagel
- Bagels On the Square
- Bagels Bagels Bagels
- Franklin Bagel Cafe
- Dunkin’
- Magic Bagels
- Jr’s Bagels
1. Bagel Doctor West
(516) 358-7400Call
Bagel Doctor West has the kind of old-school storefront that makes you pause—and the bagels live up to it. When I stopped in for the first time, the morning rush was like clockwork: locals ordering with confidence, staff moving quick, and the scent of baked dough filling the space. That first bite of a classic plain bagel, crunchy on the outside and soft in the center, convinced me I wasn’t just in any shop.
What sets Bagel Doctor West apart is their consistency. Every bagel has that signature glossy finish and perfect density, not too heavy, never airy. Classic choices shine here, but their poppy bagel with vegetable cream cheese impresses too. Try the everything bagel, toasted—no bells, no whistles, but plenty of heart.
2. A & S Bagels
A & S Bagels commands a loyal following, and I found out why after an early Saturday visit. Walking in, the buzz of the kitchen never stops, even at odd hours. The staff works like a well-oiled machine, and every bagel on their racks looks inviting. Their process is no secret—everyone comes here for that fresh-out-of-the-oven warmth and the unmistakable aroma that says you’re in the right place.
The New York-style bagels here have real chew, with a crisp outer shell and an exceptionally soft crumb. The sesame bagel with whipped scallion cream cheese is a standout choice, especially when you want something classic but with a little zip. If you’re feeling bold, the pumpernickel bagel offers a deep flavor that’s hard to forget.
3. Cherry Bagel Corp
(516) 305-4006Call
Cherry Bagel Corp is the kind of spot where you find locals chatting at the counter, coffee in hand, often debating which bagel is best. My first visit was spur-of-the-moment, but the friendly staff made it feel like I’d stopped by a long-time favorite.
The biggest draw is their fresh, pillowy bagels that manage to stay light without losing substance. There’s a real homey feel here, and you can tell each batch is made with care. Try their whole wheat bagel with a simple schmear; it’s familiar, hearty, and just right for a quick breakfast.
Cherry Bagel Corp also offers an irresistible egg bagel, which has a yellow hue and delicate sweetness—unique in all the right ways.
4. Dozen Bagel
(516) 485-4421Call
Dozen Bagel has the energy of a neighborhood secret, even if the morning line sometimes says otherwise. I wandered in one weekday, expecting the usual, but left with a new favorite. The bagels here have that old-fashioned look—crackled shell, hefty center, and satisfying chew.
What puts Dozen Bagel ahead is their no-nonsense approach; every bagel gets the same careful treatment, whether you’re grabbing a single or a baker’s dozen. Their cinnamon raisin bagel, toasted with plain cream cheese, is a bright spot on the menu and never disappoints.
If you’re hungry for something heartier, go for their everything bagel. Somehow, it balances the mix of seeds and spices without overwhelming the dough’s clean flavor.
5. Bagels On the Square
(516) 775-0777Call
Bagels On the Square is a bustling corner spot, where the smell of hot bagels lures early risers and lunchtime regulars alike. My first visit was on a rainy day, but the cheery interior and genuine smiles behind the counter brightened things right up.
Their bagels have a signature, just-baked warmth that makes any filling taste better. The family-run vibe comes through in how meticulously they prepare every order. I was especially impressed by the poppy seed bagel—it’s always fresh, never dry, and holds up to a generous spread of cream cheese.
If you like to keep things classic, the plain bagel here lets the dough and texture shine. For a real treat, try their salt bagel; it’s simple yet memorable.
6. Bagels Bagels Bagels
(516) 485-4421Call
Bagels Bagels Bagels instantly caught my eye, not just for the triple name but for the steady stream of locals ducking in for breakfast. I remember standing in line, watching the staff pull tray after tray of glossy, hot bagels from the oven. The anticipation was real.
This shop nails the balance of tender interior and crisp outside, making each bite memorable. The texture alone explains the devoted following. Their sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese became my go-to—savory, dense, and just the right amount of chewy.
Don’t skip their pumpernickel bagel, either. With its earthy taste and distinct aroma, it’s a strong contender if you crave something outside the standard lineup.
7. Franklin Bagel Cafe
(516) 216-1300Call
Franklin Bagel Cafe is the kind of easygoing spot where you see both commuters and families grabbing a quick breakfast. My first visit was on a sleepy Sunday, and the gentle chatter paired well with the unbeatable aroma of bagels toasting behind the counter.
The real charm here is their value. The bagels are large, freshly made, and have a soft, springy bite. Not too dense, not too airy—just right for piling on your favorite toppings. The everything bagel, in particular, is loaded with seeds and never skimps on flavor.
Pair it with their homemade vegetable cream cheese for a meal that feels both classic and thoughtful. Franklin Bagel Cafe makes it easy to become a regular.
8. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ is a fixture on Hempstead Turnpike, drawing a steady crowd with its reliable bagels and signature coffee. I’ve often stopped by during an early morning commute, grateful for the quick service and the familiar buzz of people grabbing their breakfast on the go.
Consistency is the key at Dunkin’. The bagels are always fresh, offering a dependable option if you crave something simple and classic. The plain bagel with a schmear of cream cheese is an easy favorite, especially when paired with a hot cup of coffee.
If you’re on the move, try their multigrain bagel—it’s soft, filling, and holds up well even hours later. Dunkin’ delivers a consistent, no-surprise start to your day.
9. Magic Bagels
(516) 872-8779Call
Magic Bagels may be a short drive from Franklin Square, but it’s worth every minute for their standout bagels. I first landed here on a friend’s recommendation and quickly saw why it’s a local favorite. The counter is always buzzing, and every bagel is made on-site, giving that unmistakable fresh-baked aroma.
What makes Magic Bagels memorable is their crust. Each bagel comes with a golden, slightly crackled exterior and a hearty, satisfying inside. Their rye bagel stands out—complex, earthy, and perfectly balanced.
If you like to keep things classic, the plain or sesame bagel never disappoints. Pair yours with a spread of cream cheese, and you’ll quickly see why Magic Bagels has a devoted following.
10. Jr’s Bagels
Jr’s Bagels, though a bit of a drive from Franklin Square, earns a spot on any bagel lover’s list thanks to quality that’s hard to beat. I dropped in on a weekend trip and instantly noticed the inviting aroma and how every customer seemed to be a regular—always a good sign.
Jr’s builds their reputation on a dense, chewy bagel that stays true to classic New York style. Every bite reveals a crisp crust with a generous crumb. The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese is a go-to move—savory, balanced, and never skimpy on seeds or toppings.
If you’re searching for a bagel that’s filling and full of character, stick to the basics here. Their plain and sesame bagels never disappoint.
More Things to Try in Franklin Square, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes bagels in Franklin Square different from other places?
Franklin Square bagels often follow traditional New York methods, with a crisp crust and a dense, chewy inside. Many shops here take pride in hand-rolling and boiling their bagels daily, which sets them apart from mass-produced options.
Are there vegetarian bagel options available?
Yes, almost every bagel spot in Franklin Square offers a variety of vegetarian-friendly choices, including plain, sesame, poppy, and everything bagels, paired with dairy spreads or vegetable cream cheese.
Which shops serve the freshest bagels in the morning?
Most local bagel shops start baking before dawn. A & S Bagels, Dozen Bagel, Bagel Doctor West, and Bagels On the Square are all known for having hot, fresh bagels if you arrive early.
Is gluten-free available at any Franklin Square bagel shops?
Some shops do carry gluten-free varieties, but selection can vary. It’s a good idea to call ahead to places like A & S Bagels to check availability for the day.
What is the most popular bagel flavor in Franklin Square?
Everything bagels lead the pack thanks to their blend of seeds and spices. Sesame and plain are also crowd favorites, especially with classic cream cheese spreads.
Do any local bagel shops deliver?
Many Franklin Square bagel shops partner with delivery platforms or offer their own delivery service. Check with your preferred shop or browse their website for delivery options.
Can I find kosher bagels in Franklin Square?
While not all bagel shops are kosher-certified, certain local spots may offer kosher options. It’s best to ask directly or check for certification on the shop’s website.