Best Bagels in Fort Myers, FL

Fort Myers, FL, is a treasure trove for bagel lovers, boasting a variety of spots that serve this beloved breakfast staple. From classic flavors to creative toppings, each bagel shop adds its unique twist to the experience. Having sampled a few of these delightful offerings, it’s clear that each location has its own charm, providing not just food but a warm atmosphere that draws locals and visitors alike.

Whether you crave a simple toasted bagel with cream cheese or something more extravagant like a lox spread, you’re in for a treat. The following guide highlights the best bagel spots in Fort Myers, each one worth the trip. Ready to dive into this flavorful exploration? Let’s get started.

1. Biscotti’s Cafe

Biscotti’s Cafe offers a cozy, family-owned vibe that truly makes you feel at home. Located in the BeachWalk Plaza, this spot serves up more than just bagels; their breakfast menu shines with creativity and quality. What sets Biscotti’s apart is their commitment to using fresh, homemade ingredients in every dish.

For a standout bagel experience, try their everything bagel topped with rich cream cheese and smoked salmon. This combination reflects the cafe’s ability to elevate simple ingredients into something memorable. Pair it with one of their specialty coffee drinks for a perfect start to your day. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service will make your visit feel special every time.

2. The Speckled Egg Cafe

The Speckled Egg Cafe is a delightful spot on McGregor Blvd, blending a casual atmosphere with a menu that caters to various tastes. Known for its friendly service and inviting decor, this cafe creates a perfect setting for a relaxed meal any time of day. The emphasis on fresh ingredients and heartwarming recipes is evident in every bite.

If you’re a fan of bagels, don’t miss the avocado toast on a freshly baked bagel. This dish combines creamy avocado with a perfectly toasted bagel, topped with a sprinkle of seasoning. It captures the healthy yet hearty spirit of the cafe. With vegetarian and vegan options available, there’s something for everyone here.

3. The Bagel Factory

Tucked away in Fort Myers, The Bagel Factory is a cozy spot that brings the taste of New York-style bagels to Southwest Florida. From the moment you step in, the warm, inviting aroma of freshly baked bagels and brewed coffee fills the air.

What sets this place apart is its authentic, hand-rolled bagels, made fresh daily. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the atmosphere is relaxed—perfect for a casual breakfast or lunch.

I loved their Egg & Cheese on a Toasted Everything Bagel—crispy on the outside, soft inside, and packed with flavor. Pair it with their house coffee for a satisfying start to your day.

Try their Veggie Cream Cheese on a Poppy Seed Bagel—a local favorite!

4. Great American Bagel

Located conveniently at the airport, Great American Bagel is a go-to spot for travelers and locals alike. With a menu that extends from breakfast through dinner, it caters to a variety of cravings at any time of the day. The cheerful ambiance and quick service make it an ideal stop whether you’re in a hurry or looking to unwind a bit.

This place stands out for its diverse selection of bagels, each baked to perfection. I recommend their smoked salmon bagel; the flavor is fresh and the presentation is delightful. The toppings are generous, reflecting their commitment to quality. Pair it with a cup of their freshly brewed coffee for an energizing experience.

5. Great American Bagel

Another gem called Great American Bagel can be found near Gate B-1 at the Fort Myers airport, making it a convenient stop. This location offers a welcoming atmosphere and a focus on quality ingredients that add to the experience of grabbing a quick meal.

What truly makes Great American Bagel stand out is its variety of bagels, including unique flavors that cater to all taste preferences. My personal favorite is the asiago cheese bagel, perfectly toasted and topped with a generous layer of cream cheese. It combines a satisfying crunch with creamy richness, showcasing the cafe’s commitment to flavor.

With options for vegetarians and a friendly staff, Great American Bagel is a solid choice for breakfast or lunch, and it’s hard to leave without trying at least one bagel.

6. Great American Bagel

Strategically located across from Gate C-1, Great American Bagel caters to the busy traveler while offering delicious options. The menu covers breakfast, lunch, and dinner, making it a versatile choice for any time of day. The fast-service environment ensures you can grab a quick bite without sacrificing quality.

This spot stands out for its array of freshly baked bagels and their toppings. One highlight is the spinach and feta bagel, which strikes a perfect balance between savory and satisfying. It’s great on its own or toasted with a light spread of cream cheese.

With a friendly staff and a bustling vibe, Great American Bagel is perfect for a quick meal that hits the spot.

7. Panera Bread

At Panera Bread on University Plaza Drive, you’re welcomed into a warm, inviting atmosphere where quality ingredients shine. This location excels at offering nutritious options, making it a favorite among health-conscious diners. With a focus on freshly baked goods, Panera Bread ensures that every bagel is crafted with care.

What sets this café apart is its balance of speed and quality. I personally enjoy their four-cheese souffle paired with a plain bagel, which creates a delightful contrast between creamy and crunchy textures. The bagels here are soft and fresh, making them a delight to start your day.

With plenty of vegetarian and vegan options, Panera Bread remains a solid choice for any meal throughout the day.

8. Panera Bread

Located on S Cleveland Ave, Panera Bread provides a cozy escape with a menu dedicated to fresh, wholesome ingredients. The inviting environment encourages diners to relax with a cup of coffee or enjoy a quick meal. This cafe truly embodies the idea of “food as it should be,” focusing on quality and care in every dish.

What makes Panera stand out is their emphasis on variety and convenience. I’ve often stopped by for their asiago cheese bagel, which pairs beautifully with their rich vegetable soup. It’s the perfect comfort food combo, showcasing their commitment to delicious, satisfying meals.

With many vegetarian and vegan options, Panera Bread is perfect for anyone looking for nutritious choices in Fort Myers.

9. Fresh Bagels & More

Located on Daniels Parkway, Fresh Bagels & More is a friendly neighborhood spot that delivers delicious bagels at an affordable price. This cafe perfectly blends convenience and quality, making it a favorite for busy mornings or casual afternoons. The relaxed atmosphere invites you to linger over your meal.

What makes Fresh Bagels & More truly stand out is their focus on freshness and variety. I highly recommend trying their lox spread on a sesame seed bagel. The combination of fresh flavors and smooth texture hits the mark every time.

With a menu that’s easy on the wallet, this place ensures that everyone can enjoy a scrumptious bagel without breaking the bank.

10. Downtown Bagels

At Downtown Bagels, situated on Dean St, you’ll find a charming little cafe that focuses solely on what bagel lovers crave. This establishment prides itself on creating delicious, hand-crafted bagels in a welcoming environment. It’s a great spot to grab a quick bite or enjoy a leisurely breakfast.

What sets Downtown Bagels apart is their commitment to quality and freshness. I particularly enjoy their blueberry bagel topped with light cream cheese—it’s a delightful balance of sweet and savory that makes any morning better.

With a straightforward menu dedicated to bagels, you can always expect a satisfying experience that keeps locals coming back for more.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best bagel shops in Fort Myers, FL?
Some of the top bagel shops include Biscotti’s Cafe, The Speckled Egg Cafe, and The Bagel Factory. Each offers a unique variety of bagels and toppings, making them favorites among locals.

2. Are there vegan bagel options in Fort Myers?
Yes, several cafes like Panera Bread and Fresh Bagels & More offer vegan-friendly bagels and spreads. Just ask the staff for recommendations tailored to your dietary needs.

3. Do these bagel shops offer breakfast all day?
Many bagel spots, including Great American Bagel and Downtown Bagels, serve breakfast throughout the day. It’s always a good idea to check their specific hours for details.

4. Can I order bagels for takeout?
Absolutely! Most bagel shops in Fort Myers, including Einstein Bros. Bagels and Downtown Bagels, offer takeout options, so you can enjoy your favorite bagels on the go.

5. How do I choose the best bagel flavor?
Choosing a bagel flavor often comes down to personal preference. Classics like plain and everything are always safe bets, but feel free to explore unique options like asiago cheese or cinnamon raisin for something different!

6. Are there gluten-free bagels available?
Yes, some cafes like Panera Bread may offer gluten-free options. It’s best to check each establishment’s menu or ask the staff for availability.

7. Do these shops have parking available?
Many bagel shops, including Fresh Bagels & More, offer free parking. However, it’s a good idea to check for specific details when visiting, especially in busier areas.

8. Can I get bagels delivered?
While not all bagel shops offer delivery, some, like Panera Bread, partner with delivery services. Check their website or app for delivery options in your area.