Best Bagels in Fishkill, NY

Hey there, bagel lovers! If you’re on the hunt for the best bagels in Fishkill, NY, you’re in the right place. I’ve scoured every nook and cranny of this charming town to bring you the cream of the crop. You won’t want to miss out on these heavenly bagels.

Ever wondered where to find the best bagels in Fishkill, NY? Well, wonder no more. The top spots for bagels are The Bagel Shoppe, Empire Bagels, and Bagel-ish. They serve the freshest, most delicious bagels that will leave you craving more.

Keep reading to discover what makes each of these bagel places special. From cozy vibes to unique flavors, you’ll learn everything you need to know to find your perfect bagel spot in Fishkill. So, let’s dive in!

Top 10 Bagels in Fishkill, NY

1. The Bagel Shoppe
2. Empire Bagels
3. Panera Bread
4. Dunkin’
5. Red Line Diner
6. Bert’s Hideout
7. The Bagel Shoppe
8. Dunkin’
9. Bagel-ish
10. ShopRite of Fishkill

1. The Bagel Shoppe

The Bagel Shoppe is a little treasure on Main Street in Fishkill. It’s cozy and inviting. I felt right at home as soon as I walked in. Plus, it’s accessible for everyone!

On my visit, the smell of fresh bagels hit me. I just had to try their everything bagel. I spread on some cream cheese, and wow! It was soft, chewy, and packed with flavor. I couldn’t get enough!

What makes The Bagel Shoppe stand out? It’s their fresh, homemade bagels. They make them daily, and you can taste the difference. If you go, definitely try the smoked salmon bagel. It’s a standout! Trust me; you won’t regret it!

2. Empire Bagels

Empire Bagels is a delightful spot on US-9 in Fishkill. It’s bright and welcoming. The staff are super friendly. I felt at ease right away.

On my visit, I tried their garlic bagel with herb cream cheese. It was a winner! The bagel had a lovely crunch, and the cream cheese was packed with flavor. I could eat it every day!

Empire Bagels stands out because of their variety. They have unique flavors and toppings. If you go, try the blueberry bagel. It’s a bit sweet and totally delicious. You’ll leave happy and full. Trust me; it’s worth it!

3. Panera Bread

Panera Bread on Merritt Blvd is a nice spot. It feels cozy and relaxed. I love that they have free WiFi. It’s perfect for a quick bite or chilling out.

I decided to try their Asiago bagel with cream cheese. Oh wow! It was soft and cheesy. The flavor was just right. I enjoyed every single bite.

What makes Panera stand out is their fresh food. They have so many yummy options. If you’re hungry, go for their breakfast sandwiches. They are filling and super tasty. You’ll leave happy and satisfied!

4. Dunkin’

Dunkin’ on US-9 is a go-to spot for me. It’s busy and lively, which I love. Plus, they have curbside pickup. It’s super convenient when I’m in a hurry!

Last time I stopped by, I got a plain bagel with cream cheese and a hot coffee. It was just what I needed. The bagel was soft and fresh. I really enjoyed it!

Dunkin’ stands out because it’s reliable and quick. You always know what you’ll get. If you’re feeling sweet, try their Boston cream donut. It’s a fun treat that makes my day brighter!

5. Red Line Diner

Red Line Diner on US-9 is such a fun place. It’s got that classic, retro diner vibe. Bright booths, shiny counters, and all the nostalgia. It’s the perfect mix of casual and cool.

I went there and loved it. I had a bagel with smoked salmon and cream cheese. Oh my, it was so fresh and tasty! The bagel was soft but had a great chew. The salmon? Absolutely perfect—light and flavorful. Every bite felt just right.

This place really stands out. The service is friendly and quick. The staff make you feel at home. It’s not just the food, it’s the whole vibe. Super cozy and welcoming.

If you go, try their pancakes. They’re fluffy and buttery, with just the right amount of syrup. Seriously, they’re a treat. Perfect for a classic diner experience!

6. Bert’s Hideout

So, there’s this place called Bert’s Hideout on Robinson Street in Fishkill. It’s cozy and kind of hidden. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, which is cool.

When I dropped by, I went for the everything bagel with avocado. Oh boy, was it good! The bagel was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The avocado made it even better.

What makes Bert’s Hideout special is the vibe. It’s friendly and chill. It feels like a secret spot. Plus, the staff is super nice.

If you ever go there, try the breakfast sandwiches. They’re amazing and full of flavor. You’ll love them!

7. The Bagel Shoppe

The Bagel Shoppe at 466 Main St is a gem. Cozy spot, right in Beacon, NY. Perfect for a quick bite or a relaxing meal. They’ve got housemade bagels, sandwiches, and even vegan and gluten-free options.

When I visited, I had the lox bagel. Fresh bagel, perfectly seasoned lox. Loved the vibe. Indoor and outdoor seating makes it super chill.

Their quality and variety are amazing. Plus, they offer delivery and takeout. So convenient.

If you go, try the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. It’s a flavor explosion. You won’t regret it!

8. Dunkin’

Oh, Dunkin’ is such a lifesaver sometimes. The spot on Westage Dr is super handy. It’s perfect when I need a quick breakfast fix or just a break.

The bagels are great. I had one with cream cheese the other day, and it hit the spot. Soft on the inside, just the right chew. Their coffee is always reliable too. I can’t function without it!

What I like most? It’s just so easy. Grab it to-go or sit for a bit. Oh, and their bacon, egg, and cheese croissant? Amazing. I always leave feeling happy and ready to tackle the day. Dunkin’ really knows how to keep mornings simple and satisfying.

9. Bagel-ish

Bagel-ish is such a cool spot on Main St in Beacon. It may be small, but it has a huge charm. I love how easy it is to grab a bagel and head out.

One morning, I stopped in and tried their jalapeño bagel. Oh my goodness—so good! It had just the right kick to it. I slathered on some cream cheese, and it made everything better.

What I really like about Bagel-ish is their unique flavors. They get creative with their bagels, and it’s fun. If you go, you absolutely have to try their sun-dried tomato bagel. It’s bursting with flavor and shows just how special they are. I promise, you’ll love it!

10. ShopRite of Fishkill

ShopRite of Fishkill is my go-to supermarket on US-9. It has everything you could ask for. From groceries to fresh bakery items, it’s all here. I really love the curbside pickup option; it makes life so easy!

The last time I visited, I was on a mission for bagels. I grabbed some fresh everything bagels, and wow! They were warm and soft, just how I like them. Every bite was loaded with flavor.

What I enjoy about ShopRite is the great variety. They have both big-name brands and their own products, which is nice. If you stop by, definitely check out their deli meats. They are super fresh and delicious, perfect for sandwiches. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed!

Map of Bagels in Fishkill, NY

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Where can I find the best bagels in Fishkill?
Okay, so listen up. If you want the best bagels, head to The Bagel Shoppe, Empire Bagels, or Dunkin’. Each one has its own special flavors. You won’t regret it.

2. Are there vegan bagel options in Fishkill?
Oh, absolutely! The Bagel Shoppe is your go-to. They’ve got vegan cream cheeses and bagels. Trust me, they’re delicious.

3. Do bagel shops in Fishkill offer delivery?
Yes, they do! Places like Dunkin’ and The Bagel Shoppe deliver. Check their websites for details.

4. What are the typical prices for bagels in Fishkill?
Bagels here are pretty affordable. You’ll find them around $1 to $3 each. It depends on the shop and toppings.

5. Can I get gluten-free bagels in Fishkill?
Yes, you can. The Bagel Shoppe has gluten-free options. Always ask when you visit.

6. What are some popular bagel toppings?
Cream cheese and lox are big hits. Avocado is also trendy. Some places even have hummus or pesto.

7. What’s the best time to get fresh bagels?
Mornings, for sure. That’s when they’re the freshest. They sell out fast, so go early!

8. Is there outdoor seating at bagel shops in Fishkill?
Yes, for sure! Many places, like Empire Bagels and The Bagel Shoppe, have outdoor seating. Perfect for nice weather!