Best Bagels in Farmingdale, NY

Hey there! So, let me tell you about the best bagels in Farmingdale, NY. I’ve explored every nook and cranny in this town to find the most delicious bagels just for you.

What are the best bagels in Farmingdale, NY? Well, let me break it down for you. The best bagels can be found at places like The Bagel Hut, G & L Bagels, and Stuff A Bagel. Each spot offers amazing flavors and high-quality bagels that you’ll love.

Now, get ready for a tasty adventure. Keep reading to discover more about these incredible bagel spots, their unique offerings, and what makes each one stand out. Let’s dive in!

Top 10 Bagels in Farmingdale, NY

1. The Bagel Hut
2. G & L Bagels
3. Stuff A Bagel
4. Stuff A Bagel University
5. Hi Bagel Deli & Grocery
6. Pete’s Deli
7. Gold & Meyer’s Gourmet Deli
8. South Main Street Deli
9. Boulevard Deli
10. Flux Coffee

1. The Bagel Hut

The Bagel Hut is such a great spot! Located at 525 Fulton Street, it’s easy to get to. Walk in, and you’ll be hit by the smell of fresh bagels. It’s cozy, with nice seating both inside and outside.

Last time I came, I had an everything bagel. It was warm and chewy, just like I like it! The staff is super friendly, which makes you feel right at home. I loved how quickly I got my food, too.

What really stands out here is the quality. Their bagels are fresh every day. You have to try their flavored cream cheeses. They take everything to the next level! Trust me, you won’t regret it!

2. G & L Bagels

G & L Bagels is such a cozy spot! You’ll find it at 820 Main Street. When you walk in, you feel right at home. They also do delivery if you can’t make it.

I grabbed a cinnamon raisin bagel. It was so soft and yummy! The staff was super nice too. My visit was great from start to finish.

What’s awesome about G & L Bagels? The variety! They have so many bagels and toppings. I suggest the garlic bagel with plain cream cheese. It’s a must-try combo. You’ll love it!

3. Stuff A Bagel

Stuff A Bagel is such a great find! It’s right on Main Street at 234 Main Street. The place feels cozy and welcoming. You can sit inside or outside. They even offer delivery, which is a plus.

When I stopped by, I had to try their homemade bagels. Wow! They were fresh and super tasty! The staff was nice, and the vibe was fun. I had a great time.

What I really love about Stuff A Bagel is their menu. It’s not just bagels! You can get pancakes, salads, and more. I highly recommend the lox bagel. It’s packed with flavor and freshness. You’re gonna enjoy it for sure!

4. Stuff A Bagel University

Stuff A Bagel University is such a great spot! It’s at 1253 Melville Road. The vibe here is super relaxed. You can sit inside or outside, which is nice. Plus, they offer curbside pickup and delivery if you’re in a hurry.

On my visit, I had to try their bagels. I went with an everything bagel toasted with cream cheese. Oh man, it was warm and packed with flavor! The staff was really kind and helpful, which made it even better.

What I love about Stuff A Bagel University is the creativity. They have so many tasty options! I totally recommend their egg, and cheese bagel. It’s super satisfying and really delicious. You’re gonna want to try it!

5. Hi Bagel Deli & Grocery

Oh, you have to check out Hi Bagel Deli & Grocery at 1111 Broadhollow Rd, Farmingdale! The place is just so welcoming. It has indoor and outdoor seating, perfect for anyone, including those with wheelchairs. Plus, they do delivery and takeout, super handy!

I visited last week and loved it. The vibe was chill and relaxed. The staff was so friendly. I went for the classic bagel with lox and cream cheese. Every bite was just so good.

Hi Bagel Deli & Grocery stands out for its top-notch quality and awesome service. Their bagels are always fresh and full of flavor.

If you go, definitely try the egg, and cheese bagel. It’s simple but oh-so-delicious and really shows off their style!

6. Pete’s Deli

Pete’s Deli is a must-visit at 800 Main St, Farmingdale! It’s super convenient. They have curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-accessible, which is great.

I popped in last week and had a blast. The staff was so friendly and quick. I tried their bagel with egg salad, and wow! It was delicious, with great flavor in every bite.

What makes Pete’s Deli stand out is the freshness of their food. Everything tastes homemade and quality. You really feel it.

If you go, you have to order the egg, and cheese bagel. It’s hearty and super tasty. Trust me, you’ll love it!

7. Gold & Meyer’s Gourmet Deli

Gold & Meyer’s Gourmet Deli is such a great find! Located at 255 Airport Plaza Blvd, Farmingdale, it’s super inviting. You can sit inside or outside, which is nice. Plus, they offer delivery and takeout.

I popped in last week and had a wonderful time. The staff was super friendly and ready to help. I decided to try their bagel with smoked salmon. Oh wow, it was fresh and so flavorful!

What really stands out at Gold & Meyer’s is the quality. They have a lot of great options for everyone.

If you visit, you have to try the turkey club bagel. It’s hearty and delicious, and you’ll absolutely love it!

8. South Main Street Deli

You know, South Main Street Deli at 718 Main St is a gem. The moment you walk in, it’s like, “Wow, this place is cozy!” They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Plus, it’s wheelchair accessible, which is great.

I remember my visit there. The staff was super nice, and the smell of fresh bagels was amazing. It’s not just the food; it’s the whole vibe that stands out.

Oh, and if you go, definitely try the Everything Bagel. It’s fresh, tasty, and just perfect. The care they put into making it really shows.

9. Boulevard Deli

Let me tell you about Boulevard Deli. It’s at 35 Allen Blvd. When I first stepped in, the place felt super cozy. You know, like a warm hug. And guess what? It’s budget-friendly and wheelchair-accessible. Win-win!

The staff there? Oh, they’re the best. Friendly smiles everywhere. And the smell of fresh bagels? Heaven. It wasn’t just food; it was pure joy.

Boulevard Deli is special. The chill vibe and top-notch service make it stand out. It’s more than a deli; it’s like a little community hub.

If you go, try the Bagel with Lox. It’s fresh, tasty, and shows off their amazing quality. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

10. Flux Coffee

You have to check out Flux Coffee at 211 Main St, Farmingdale! It’s such a cozy place. They have indoor and outdoor seating, which is great. The entrance is wheelchair-accessible, so everyone can enjoy it.

When I walked in, I felt right at home. The staff greeted me with big smiles. I ordered a cold brew and a bagel. Let me tell you, they were both amazing!

What really makes Flux Coffee stand out is their quality. You can taste it in every sip and bite.

If you visit, try their cold brew with a plain bagel and cream cheese. It’s simple but so delicious! You won’t regret it!

Map of Bagels in Farmingdale, NY

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Best Bagel Spots?
Oh, there are gems! Try The Bagel Hut, G & L Bagels, and Stuff A Bagel. Fresh flavors everywhere.

2. Do They Deliver?
Yep, most do. Call to check specifics.

3. Veggie or Vegan Options?
Definitely! Think fresh avocado, cream cheese, and veggies. Some even have vegan spreads.

4. Typical Prices?
Super affordable. Under $2 for a bagel, more with toppings.

5. Can I Sit and Eat?
Yes! Many have indoor and outdoor seating. It’s cozy and casual.

6. Popular Flavors?
Everything, sesame, plain. All-time favorites!

7. Other Breakfast Items?
Absolutely. Egg sandwiches, pancakes, the works!

8. Gluten-Free Options?
Yes, but always ask first. Not everywhere has them.