Bagel hunting in Eureka, CA can feel a bit like searching for treasure along the fog-draped coastline—but in this case, you’re rewarded with chewy, golden rings of satisfaction. The local bagel scene is small but surprisingly distinct, mixing a dash of Humboldt character into each recipe. If you know where to look, you’ll find classic styles sitting side by side with inventive newcomers, often just steps away from the morning mist rolling off Humboldt Bay.
The first time I bit into a fresh bagel in Eureka, I was strolling past redwood-lined streets with steam curling from my coffee. The crisp shell gave way to a warm, soft center, and I realized this was the kind of comfort people chase across city blocks and state lines. Curious about the top spots for bagels in Eureka? I’ve rounded up the best bakeries and cafes, so you can skip the search and jump straight to the good stuff.
Where to find the best bagels in Eureka, CA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Eureka, CA:
- Los Bagels – Eureka
- Old Town Coffee & Chocolates
- Frankie’s New York Bagels
- Los Bagels Co
- Shotz Coffee and Drive Thru
1. Los Bagels – Eureka
Los Bagels – Eureka is more than just a local staple; it’s where bagel cravings and coastal culture intersect. The rustic charm and mural-clad walls set the mood long before you grab a seat. I still remember my first Beast of Bagels, toasted perfectly and loaded with a tangy schmear, its flavor as bright as the Humboldt sun peeking through the window.
What makes Los Bagels memorable is its focus on organic ingredients and hand-rolled traditions. The bagels here have a signature chew that hints at generations of fine-tuned methods, setting them apart from anything generic. Choices like the Slug Bagel—a nod to local legends—or a hearty sesame with vegan schmear, deliver big on flavor while catering to all diets.
For anyone curious, the lox bagel here is an easy recommendation, layered with local produce and generous slices of smoked salmon. Or try the Bialy with jalapeño spread, a Humboldt twist you won’t soon forget.
2. Old Town Coffee & Chocolates
Old Town Coffee & Chocolates blends the earthy aroma of small-batch roasted coffee with the comfort of freshly baked bagels. Walking into their F Street shop feels like stepping into a friendly hideaway with just the right amount of bustle. The bagels are always fresh, often still warm, and pair perfectly with their specialty espresso drinks.
This spot stands out for its commitment to quality and creativity. The house-made spreads range from classic cream cheese to unexpected flavors like sun-dried tomato or local berry. I once tried their onion bagel with a generous slather of herb schmear—it was simple, yet rich, and made for a perfect companion to their signature dark chocolate mocha.
For a true taste of Old Town, order a toasted everything bagel with veggie spread and pair it with a small-batch cappuccino. You’ll leave with your curiosity—if not your hunger—satisfied.
3. Frankie’s New York Bagels
Frankie’s New York Bagels brings a taste of the East Coast straight to Eureka’s Redwood Acres neighborhood. With a reputation for hand-shaped dough and a true New York-style boil-and-bake process, their bagels have that unmistakable dense chew and shiny crust. The first time I picked up a hot plain bagel here, its satisfying crunch and soft, flavorful interior took me right back to Manhattan mornings.
Frankie’s is known for authenticity. Everything from the water to the flour is carefully chosen, so each bite feels like a little trip. Their bagel sandwiches get a lot of local love, too—try the classic egg and cheese or a veggie-packed breakfast bagel if you’re hungry.
Don’t miss the cinnamon raisin bagel with a swirl of whipped cream cheese. It highlights Frankie’s knack for keeping things traditional while still feeling local at heart.
4. Los Bagels Co
Los Bagels Co, tucked right on the Humboldt State campus in Arcata, keeps the same lively spirit and hand-rolled tradition as its Eureka sibling. The energy here is unique—think students lingering over coffee and bagels in a sunny, bustling setting. My own midday visit turned an ordinary break into a standout moment, thanks to a poppy seed bagel with rich sun-dried tomato spread.
What sets Los Bagels Co apart is its fusion of local flavor and nostalgia. You’ll find organic ingredients throughout the menu and bagels that celebrate Humboldt’s blend of cultures. The Slug Bagel—a local favorite—is both quirky and delicious, especially with a swipe of avocado spread or classic schmear.
Whatever you order, the bagels here balance a chewy bite with an airy quality that’s hard to find outside this region. It’s an essential stop, whether you’re a student, a visitor, or just a bagel devotee.
5. Shotz Coffee and Drive Thru
Shotz Coffee and Drive Thru is the answer to early-morning cravings in Fortuna. Its drive-thru setup is a lifesaver for anyone who prefers a great bagel with zero hassle. More than once, I’ve swung by on a busy morning and driven off with a hot bagel and bold espresso—no waiting, no fuss.
This spot shines for convenience and consistency. The menu is straightforward but reliable, featuring classic bagel choices that are always fresh. Their bagel with veggie cream cheese hits the mark and pairs perfectly with any of their hand-crafted coffee drinks.
If you want something savory, the toasted everything bagel is a crowd-pleaser. For something lighter, a plain bagel with fresh jam never disappoints. The quick service and friendly vibe make mornings feel a bit less rushed—and a lot more delicious.
More Things to Try in Eureka, CA
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best bagels in Eureka, CA?
Some of the top spots include Los Bagels – Eureka, Old Town Coffee & Chocolates, and Frankie’s New York Bagels. Each offers a signature style, so it’s worth trying more than one if you can.
Do any Eureka bagel places have vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes. Los Bagels – Eureka is especially known for its vegan and gluten-free bagels, along with a wide range of spreads for different dietary needs.
Which shop serves New York-style bagels in Eureka?
Frankie’s New York Bagels is dedicated to fresh, authentic New York-style bagels, using traditional hand-rolled and boiled methods for that signature bite.
Are there options for a quick bagel breakfast on the go?
Absolutely. Shotz Coffee and Drive Thru in nearby Fortuna offers fresh bagels and specialty coffee at drive-thru speed—perfect for busy mornings.
Can I find unique or local bagel flavors in Eureka?
You can. Los Bagels stands out with its signature Slug Bagel, a local favorite, and playful options like their bialys and specialty schmears.