Best Bagels in Erie, PA

Erie, PA is a hidden gem for bagel lovers. If you’re a bagel enthusiast, you’re in for a treat! The city boasts a variety of bagel shops that cater to every taste bud. Whether you’re craving a classic New York bagel or something more unique, Erie has got you covered.

What are the best bagels in Erie, PA? The top spots serve bagels that are fresh, delicious, and perfect for any bagel lover. From traditional flavors to creative toppings, there’s something for everyone.

In this article, I’ll take you on a tour of Erie’s best bagel shops. You’ll learn about each place’s unique offerings, ambiance, and what makes them special. Get ready to dive into the world of Erie’s bagels!

Top 10 Bagels in Erie, PA

  1. Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel
  2. New York Bagel
  3. Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel Too
  4. Brew Ha Ha at the Colony
  5. Wegmans
  6. Mighty Fine Donuts
  7. Rose Garden Cafe
  8. Art’s Bakery
  9. The Park Coffee & Bread Co.
  10. Herb & Honey Bakery

1. Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel

Jo's Brooklyn Bagel

833 W 38th St, Erie, PA 16508, USA
Phone: (814) 520-6246
Directions: Open on Map

Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel is a cozy spot. It’s at 833 W 38th St, Erie, PA. You can sit inside or outside. It’s got a laid-back vibe. The place is also wheelchair-accessible.

Jo’s is all about New York-style bagels. The bagels are fresh and flavorful. They’re chewy on the outside, soft on the inside. I loved how each bite was just perfect.

If you’re there, try the Everything Bagel with cream cheese. It’s a burst of flavors. You get a bit of everything with each bite. Trust me, it’s a treat you don’t want to miss!

2. New York Bagel

New York Bagel

3802 Elmwood Ave, Erie, PA 16509, USA
Phone: (814) 315-6025
Directions: Open on Map

New York Bagel is a lovely little spot. It’s at 3802 Elmwood Ave, Erie, PA. Perfect for takeout. As soon as you walk in, the smell of fresh bagels hits you. It’s a small place but has a big heart.

I stopped by and was amazed by the variety. Each bagel looked so tempting! New York Bagel shines with its classic recipe. They get that authentic New York taste just right.

If you visit, go for the Cinnamon Raisin Bagel. It’s warm, fluffy, and slightly sweet. Add some cream cheese, and you’re in for a treat. It’s the simple joy of a perfectly made bagel. You’ll love it!

3. Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel Too

Jo's Brooklyn Bagel Too

22 N Park Row, Erie, PA 16501, USA
Directions: Open on Map

Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel Too is a gem in Erie. Located at 22 N Park Row, it’s super easy to find. This spot is all about takeout. As soon as you walk in, the smell of fresh bagels makes you smile.

I had the best time here! The choices are really awesome. What stands out is the friendly vibe and quick service. Everyone treats you like a regular.

If you stop by, try the Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel. It’s spicy and cheesy—so good! Add some cream cheese, and you’ve got a tasty treat. This bagel shows off their passion for great flavors. Trust me, you’ll love it!

4. Brew Ha Ha at the Colony

Brew Ha Ha at the Colony

2612 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505, USA
Phone: (814) 833-2739
Menu: www.brewhahacolony.com
Directions: Open on Map

Brew Ha Ha at the Colony is a delightful little spot. It’s right on 2612 W 8th St in Erie. The place has indoor and outdoor seating. There’s also curbside pickup, which is super handy. Plus, the entrance is wheelchair-friendly.

So, one morning, I decided to check it out. The staff there are just the friendliest. The vibe is warm and cozy. I felt right at home. What I loved most? The bagels, of course! And the coffee? Top-notch.

If you’re planning to go, you must try the Spinach and Feta Bagel. Trust me, it’s delicious. The flavors are spot on. It’s just so satisfying. You can tell they use fresh ingredients. It’s a must-try!

5. Wegmans

Wegmans

6143 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509, USA
Phone: (814) 860-5300
Menu: www.wegmans.com
Directions: Open on Map

Wegmans on Peach St in Erie is amazing. They offer curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout. It’s also wheelchair-friendly, which is a big plus.

I stopped by Wegmans recently. The place is super clean. The staff? They’re just the best. They helped me find everything I needed. It’s like they read my mind.

What makes Wegmans special? It’s the quality. And the variety. It’s a one-stop shop. Everything you need in one place. Simple as that.

If you go, try the Asiago Cheese Bagel. Trust me, it’s amazing. Pair it with house-made cream cheese. It’s a flavor explosion. You won’t regret it. Wegmans? It’s a must-visit!

6. Mighty Fine Donuts

Mighty Fine Donuts

2612 Parade St, Erie, PA 16504, USA
Phone: (814) 455-6408
Menu: m.facebook.com
Directions: Open on Map

Mighty Fine Donuts, at 2612 Parade St, is my favorite donut spot in Erie. The place is so cozy. I always feel welcome. Prices? Super cheap. Perfect for my budget. Plus, they are wheelchair accessible. It’s great to see that inclusivity.

I remember one morning. The smell of fresh donuts hit me. The staff greeted me with warm smiles. It felt like a small piece of heaven.

The donuts? Oh, they are amazing. So light. So fluffy. My top pick? The glazed donuts. They melt in your mouth. Pair with a hot coffee. Perfect start to my day. Mighty Fine Donuts never lets me down.

7. Rose Garden Cafe

Rose Garden Cafe

815 State St, Erie, PA 16501, USA
Phone: (814) 864-3091
Directions: Open on Map

Rose Garden Cafe is such a lovely place! It’s at 815 State St in Erie. They have indoor and outdoor seating, which is great. You can also get delivery or takeout, making it super easy.

I dropped by the other day. The vibe inside was so cozy. The staff welcomed me with big smiles. It felt just right, like a warm hug.

What really makes Rose Garden Cafe special? Their fresh ingredients! You can taste the quality in every bite. I recommend the Avocado Toast on a bagel. It’s fresh and flavorful. And don’t forget to grab a smoothie, too. It’s the perfect combo! Rose Garden Cafe is definitely a spot worth visiting.

8. Art’s Bakery

Art's Bakery

4380 W Ridge Rd, Erie, PA 16506, USA
Phone: (814) 833-1098
Menu: artsbakeryerie.com
Directions: Open on Map

Oh, Art’s Bakery on W Ridge Rd is such a delight. I mean, the place just screams charm. You pull up, and it’s curbside pickup, delivery, or takeout. So easy. Prices? Super friendly on the wallet. Plus, it’s accessible for everyone.

You walk in and get hit by the smell of fresh pastries. It’s heavenly. The staff there? They’re like your best friends. Every time I’m there, it’s like catching up with family.

Their bagels? Simply the best. Fresh and perfect every single time. If you visit, you have to try their everything bagel with cream cheese. It’s a mix of all the best flavors.

Seriously, don’t miss out on Art’s Bakery. Their warmth and amazing bagels will leave you craving more.

9. The Park Coffee & Bread Co.

The Park Coffee & Bread Co.

4007 Main St, Erie, PA 16511, USA
Phone: (814) 315-0878
Menu: www.theparkcoffeeandbreadco.com
Directions: Open on Map

The Park Coffee & Bread Co. is at 4007 Main St, Erie, PA 16511, USA. It’s so cozy. Perfect for indoor and outdoor seating. You can make reservations or grab takeout. The best part? It’s wheelchair accessible.

When I visit, it feels like a warm, inviting haven. The ambiance is charming and relaxed. It’s perfect for unwinding with friends. Or getting some work done. The staff is always friendly and attentive. It adds to the overall delightful experience.

What makes The Park Coffee & Bread Co. special? Their commitment to quality and community. They source fresh ingredients. They craft delicious, memorable dishes. They genuinely care about their patrons. And it shows in every detail.

When you visit, try their signature bagel with lox and cream cheese. It’s a perfect blend of flavors. It reflects their dedication to quality and taste. Also, don’t miss their avocado toast. It’s simple yet packed with flavor. These little touches make The Park Coffee & Bread Co. a standout in Erie’s bagel scene.

10. Herb & Honey Bakery

Herb & Honey Bakery

516 Cherry St, Erie, PA 16507, USA
Menu: www.herbandhoneybakery.com
Directions: Open on Map

Herb & Honey Bakery is such a charming spot! It’s located at 516 Cherry St, Erie, PA 16507. You can sit indoors or outside, which is great. They also do takeout if you’re in a hurry.

I popped in the other day. As soon as I walked in, the smell of fresh baked goods hit me. It was heavenly! The staff greeted me with big smiles, which made me feel right at home.

What really makes Herb & Honey stand out is their focus on fresh ingredients. Their bagels are simply amazing! You have to try the everything bagel. The flavors are so bold and satisfying. And don’t skip the homemade honey butter. It makes everything even better!

Map of Bagels in Erie, PA

Choosing the Right Shop for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

ShopPriceSeatingTakeoutDeliveryWheelchairReservation
Jo’s Brooklyn BagelInexpensiveYesYesNoAccessible
New York BagelYes
Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel TooYes
Brew Ha Ha at the ColonyInexpensiveYesYesAccessibleNo
WegmansModerateYesYesAccessible
Mighty Fine DonutsInexpensiveYesAccessible
Rose Garden CafeYesYesYes
Art’s BakeryInexpensiveNoYesYesAccessible
The Park Coffee & Bread Co.YesYesNoAccessibleYes
Herb & Honey BakeryYesYesNo

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Where can I find the best bagels in Erie, PA?
Oh, there are so many great places! I love Jo’s Brooklyn Bagel and New York Bagel. Each shop has its own special flavors, so you can’t go wrong!

2. Are there gluten-free bagel options in Erie?
Yes! Many shops offer gluten-free bagels. Just ask when you visit, and they’ll let you know what’s available.

3. Can I get bagels delivered in Erie?
For sure! Shops like Wegmans and The Park Coffee & Bread Co. have delivery options. It’s super easy to get fresh bagels right at your door.

4. What’s the difference between New York-style bagels and others?
New York-style bagels are chewy and have a shiny crust. They are boiled before baking, which gives them that special taste.

5. What are the most popular bagel toppings?
Popular toppings include cream cheese, lox, and avocado. You can also find fun options like flavored cream cheese or veggies. They make every bagel so tasty!

Scroll to Top
best website stats