Searching for the best bagels in East Hills, NY is both a satisfying mission and a delicious excuse to start your day right. This corner of Long Island is where bagel traditions meet new ideas, and every shop brings its own touch to the table. Whether you crave a classic doughy circle or prefer your bagel stacked with fresh spreads, East Hills has you covered. Over the years, I’ve wandered from block to block, sometimes following nothing but the smell of freshly baked rounds in the morning air. Few things compare to that first, soft bite—sometimes so good, you start planning your next visit before you’ve even finished eating.
Selecting a standout bagel shop isn’t just about a golden crust or a chewy interior—it’s about how your breakfast fits into your day. The right bagel can make a crowded commute easier or turn a regular morning into something memorable. With this in mind, I’ve rounded up the places in East Hills where bagels are more than a basic breakfast. Ready to find your next favorite? Let’s get started.
Where to find the best bagels in East Hills, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in East Hills, NY:
- Dunkin’
- Greenvale Bagels
- Bagel Boss
- 113Mineola Avenue Inc
- Stuff Steffs
- PopUp Bagels
- Barbara’s Bagels
- I Bagel Cafe
- Bagels and Bialys
- Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
1. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ at 300 Roslyn Rd in Roslyn Heights is a familiar staple for quick, consistent bagels near East Hills. Stepping inside, I’m always greeted by the comforting aroma of fresh brews and baking bread—it’s the kind of place you can count on for friendly service and a grab-and-go breakfast that hits the spot.
While Dunkin’ is famous for coffee and donuts, their bagels are quietly reliable. I often pick up a classic plain or everything bagel, toasted and spread with cream cheese. The texture is soft yet sturdy, ideal for a busy morning.
If you like a little extra, the veggie cream cheese pairs well with the multi-grain bagel. Bagels here may not be gourmet, but they shine as a familiar start to the day when time is tight.
2. Greenvale Bagels
Greenvale Bagels is one of those places where the bagels look and taste like they just left a Brooklyn bakery oven. There’s something about the tight parking lot and steady morning crowd that feels welcoming. This is my go-to when I want a bagel that clings to tradition—boiled, baked, and finished with a dense, chewy bite.
The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese never disappoints; the toppings stretch from edge to edge. For something heartier, you can try a classic egg bagel that’s perfectly yellow and pillowy inside. Each bite is noticeably fresh.
Greenvale Bagels delivers a true New York bagel experience close to East Hills, making it easy to see why so many locals return every morning.
3. Bagel Boss
(516) 626-5599Call
Bagel Boss on Willis Ave is a local favorite for anyone who wants a quality bagel with a side of genuine hospitality. The shop has a noticeable energy in the mornings—families, commuters, and regulars all blend together in line, each searching for the perfect bite.
Bagel Boss shines for its wide variety of kosher bagels, vegan options, and fresh spreads. I keep coming back for the sesame bagel loaded with vegetable cream cheese. The bagels have a crisp crust and a springy, soft center, the kind you want from a true New York bagel.
Their menu covers everything from dairy salads to homemade soups, but it’s the freshly baked bagels and parve spreads that make Bagel Boss a clear standout in East Hills.
4. 113Mineola Avenue Inc
(516) 484-3245Call
113Mineola Avenue Inc is easy to miss, but once you step inside, it’s hard to forget. The aroma says everything: this place takes bagel-making seriously. One visit turned a simple errand into a carb-fueled detour that I still think about.
What makes this spot unique is its focus on the basics. The plain and poppy bagels taste fresh, never heavy, with a tender crumb and a proper, glossy crust. Grab a cinnamon raisin if you prefer a hint of sweetness—it’s chewy and just a touch warm right out of the basket.
This isn’t a spot for elaborate toppings, but when a bagel is this consistent, all you need is a swipe of cream cheese and a good appetite.
5. Stuff Steffs
(516) 625-1576Call
Stuff Steffs is a bit of a hidden gem tucked along The Crescent. On my first visit, I was charmed by the cozy, neighborly vibe and the unmistakable scent of baking bagels drifting onto the sidewalk. This spot favors simplicity, but it doesn’t skip on quality or flavor.
The standout here is the onion bagel, toasted with a thick layer of cream cheese. The outside hits you with crunch, the inside stays soft, and the onion flavor is bold but never overpowering. For those who like their bagels on the fluffier side, the egg bagel is worth a try.
Stuff Steffs doesn’t complicate things—they let their classic bagels speak for themselves, and around East Hills, that’s plenty.
6. PopUp Bagels
PopUp Bagels brings a new twist to the bagel game near East Hills. I first heard about it from friends who called it “the place where bagels disappear fast,” and they weren’t kidding. Walk in early and you’ll find a lively counter stacked with fresh, hand-rolled bagels—by mid-morning, the trays are already thinning out.
The signature choice is a classic sesame bagel paired with whipped scallion cream cheese. The bagels here have a satisfyingly crisp shell and a tender interior. Their everything bagel, lightly toasted, stands out for its balance of seasoning and airy crumb.
PopUp Bagels focuses on small batch quality, which means every bite tastes deliberate. It’s the kind of spot that tempts you to take a dozen home, just in case.
7. Barbara’s Bagels
Barbara’s Bagels sits on Mineola Ave and always feels like more than a bakery—it’s a neighborhood fixture. My last stop there turned into an unexpected catch-up with friends and a bagel that landed squarely in my top five. The staff move with practiced ease behind the counter, keeping things welcoming but efficient.
The cinnamon raisin bagel here is a crowd-pleaser, swirled with just enough sweetness to make mornings better. If you’re after something savory, the pumpernickel with chive cream cheese is rich and earthy, just the way it should be.
Barbara’s Bagels delivers consistent quality and generous portions, capturing that blend of comfort and tradition that East Hills locals love.
8. I Bagel Cafe
I Bagel Cafe is the kind of local spot where bagels are front and center—fresh, flavorful, and never rushed. On my last visit, I watched the staff load racks with bagels that still steamed, evidence of just-out-of-the-oven freshness. The line moved quickly, but no one left without a chat or a smile.
The salt bagel with plain cream cheese hits a satisfying mix of chewy and crunchy. It’s the best pick-me-up if you crave bold flavors early in the day. Their whole wheat and rye bagels are also solid choices, especially when you want something hearty and wholesome.
I Bagel Cafe stays true to time-honored recipes and gives each bagel the attention it deserves—a detail that sets it apart in the East Hills bagel scene.
9. Bagels and Bialys
(516) 621-9520Call
Bagels and Bialys on Willis Ave is all about tradition with just enough modern touches to keep things interesting. My first stop there was an impulse visit while running errands. By the time I left, I’d already decided to make it part of my regular rotation.
The bialys here are a standout—soft, slightly chewy, with a hint of onion in every bite. If you’re a bagel purist, grab a sesame or everything bagel topped with their signature veggie cream cheese. Each one comes out fresh, warm, and full of old-school New York flavor.
You’ll also find a variety of bagels that appeal to every palate, making Bagels and Bialys a quiet favorite among East Hills locals who crave authenticity.
10. Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
(516) 671-0100Call
Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe is the sort of spot that draws you in for a quiet breakfast and keeps you coming back for its homey atmosphere. My first visit started with a recommendation from a local, and I ended up making a detour there just to grab a dozen bagels for the office.
The standout pick is their everything bagel, hot from the oven with a generous spread of chive cream cheese. Each bagel has that signature crackly outside and a pillowy center. Their menu isn’t flashy, but it is full of comforting, classic flavors at a price that doesn’t cut corners.
Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe lets the quality of their bagels do the talking, and it pays off in every bite for East Hills breakfast fans.
More Things to Try in East Hills, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of bagels can I find in East Hills, NY?
You’ll find all the classics—plain, everything, sesame, poppy, onion, salt, pumpernickel, and cinnamon raisin—alongside options like whole wheat, multi-grain, and a good assortment of bialys at several spots.
Are there kosher or vegan bagel places in East Hills?
Yes. Bagel Boss, for example, offers kosher-certified bagels, vegan bagels, and dairy-free spreads, making it a safe choice for a variety of dietary needs.
Which bagel shop is best for a quick breakfast on the go?
If speed and convenience matter, Dunkin’ or Greenvale Bagels make mornings smoother with fast service and ready-to-go options.
Are there any bagel shops in East Hills that cater events?
Several local shops, like Bagel Boss and Barbara’s Bagels, provide catering platters perfect for meetings, brunches, or celebrations.
Where can I get freshly made bialys in East Hills?
Bagels and Bialys is a top pick if you’re after a freshly baked bialy with an authentic flavor that matches your favorite classic bagel.