Bagels might look simple—just a round bread with a hole in the middle—but anyone who has hunted for a great one knows the truth: finding a bagel worth bragging about is a quest. Coral Gables, surrounded by sun and glossy palm trees, hides a surprising stash of bagel shops, each with its own secret. Some promise the chew of New York. Others tempt with house-made spreads and creative flavors you never saw coming. My own journey began with a plain bagel and a quick coffee, but I kept circling back, winning over my friends (and probably alarming my carb tracker) in hopes of tasting where the best bite was hiding.
Curating this list took earnest research, more than a few breakfasts, and not a single shortcut. Each spot below brings something special to the table—maybe it’s a hot, toasted crunch, or a generous slather of schmear—so you can trust that every bagel on this list has earned its spot. Whether you want traditional or adventurous, your ideal bagel in Coral Gables is just a scroll away. If you’re ready for the fluffiest insides and crispiest crusts in town, you’re about to discover the best of the best.
Where to find the best bagels in Coral Gables, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Coral Gables, FL:
- Bagel Emporium & Grille
- Toasted Bagelry & Deli
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Coral Bagels
- Outrageous Bagel
- Holy Bagels and Pizzeria of Downtown
- New York Bagel Deli Brickell
- The Bagel Club Miami
- N Bagel
- Westside Bagels
1. Bagel Emporium & Grille
Step inside Bagel Emporium & Grille and you’ll notice the vibe: unfussy, friendly, full of regulars with bagel crumbs on their shirts. Freshness drives every bite here—each bagel is made daily, with a dense, chewy texture that’s the real deal. After trying a range across town, I keep returning for their classic sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese. Something about that simple combo just hits right.
Another standout? Their breakfast special: a warm everything bagel, scrambled eggs, and just the right amount of seasoning. The menu rewards curiosity, but even a plain bagel feels oddly indulgent thanks to their house-made schmears.
Bagel Emporium & Grille’s secret is quality. Nothing arrives stale or bland, and if you get a craving on a Sunday morning, they’re open and ready. For many, this isn’t just a bagel shop—it’s the first stop of a good day.
2. Toasted Bagelry & Deli
Toasted Bagelry & Deli feels instantly welcoming, with a European touch in the air and bagels that make breakfast more interesting. The bagels here are perfectly crisp outside, tender inside, and keep their freshness long after you’ve left the shop. I once grabbed a cinnamon raisin bagel here on a busy morning—it stayed soft, sweet, and comforting through every bite.
What really draws people in is their creativity. Try the multigrain bagel with chive cream cheese or their classic lox and veggies—the vibrant flavors show a respect for tradition but with their own style.
Each visit to Toasted Bagelry & Deli is a reminder that simple food can be memorable. The seating area has an easygoing energy; if you need a calm spot to start the day, this place fits the bill.
3. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels is a go-to for anyone craving a reliable, freshly baked bagel near the University of Miami. The menu is straightforward, with fresh-baked bagels always at its heart. I’ve popped in more times than I care to admit for an onion bagel with garden veggie shmear—the kind of satisfying, no-fuss breakfast that just works when you’re in a rush.
People like Einstein Bros. for the range: whether you want a baker’s dozen to share or a quick egg sandwich, the options are solid. The cage-free egg sandwiches are a popular pick, especially stacked on an everything bagel.
If you’re after a classic combo—bagel, shmear, hot coffee—this spot delivers. Consistency is key here, and that’s what keeps it on the radar for longtime fans and first-timers alike.
4. Coral Bagels
(305) 854-0336Call
Coral Bagels is a laid-back spot where regulars and newcomers share tables and stories over fresh-baked bagels. The price is easy on your wallet, but the quality doesn’t cut corners. The bagels are always tender, making it easy to see why the early crowd claims their favorites before noon.
My morning there started with a toasted plain bagel and a generous topping of veggie cream cheese. Their spreads taste homemade, and the atmosphere feels like a neighborhood classic—no rush, no pretense.
The customer favorites? Try their everything bagel with a double helping of chive cream cheese. Simple, filling, and satisfying, it’s the kind of breakfast that turns into a tradition after just one visit. Coral Bagels has a way of keeping people coming back for more.
5. Outrageous Bagel
Outrageous Bagel lives up to its name by taking classic bagels and turning them up a notch—without any frills. The prices stay refreshingly low, but the bagels feel far from basic. I first stopped in after a friend raved about their jalapeño bagel, and it was memorable: warm, chewy, and just the right kick for breakfast.
The menu covers the must-haves, but look out for the cinnamon raisin and whole wheat options. Each brings its own charm, always fresh and satisfying. Even a simple toasted bagel feels like an upgrade here.
If you want something straight-up good, try a bagel with their homemade cream cheese. No shortcuts, just solid quality—and that’s what makes Outrageous Bagel a favorite for locals and anyone passing through.
6. Holy Bagels and Pizzeria of Downtown
Holy Bagels and Pizzeria of Downtown brings an unexpected mix to Miami: classic bagels and the aroma of fresh-baked pizza sharing space on the menu. The bagels here have a loyal following for their springy texture and golden crust. My first trip led to a delightful surprise—an everything bagel toasted just right, paired with tangy scallion cream cheese.
The experience is all about options. You can stick with a classic bagel breakfast, or try a bagel sandwich that feels more like lunch than a morning snack.
If you’re nearby, order the sesame bagel with fresh veggie toppings. It’s a wholesome, filling start to any day and shows off their generous approach to flavor. Holy Bagels keeps the mornings interesting and fresh.
7. New York Bagel Deli Brickell
(786) 364-9422Call
New York Bagel Deli Brickell channels the city’s classic bagel energy right into downtown Miami. The bagels have that honest, chewy bite New Yorkers swear by. On my first visit, a simple everything bagel with a shmear and fresh tomato felt like breakfast in Brooklyn—transportive even as palm trees waved outside.
The deli shines with its bagel sandwiches: egg, avocado, and a punch of pepper on a poppy seed bagel hits that satisfying balance between hearty and fresh.
If you’re looking for a taste of the Northeast, try their pumpernickel bagel with plain cream cheese. No-nonsense, deeply flavorful, and consistent, New York Bagel Deli Brickell is a hidden gem for bagel traditionalists and newcomers alike.
8. The Bagel Club Miami
The Bagel Club Miami is where Wynwood’s creative spirit meets solid bagel-making. There’s a definite “club” feel—friendly staff, cool murals, and bagels that show real attention to detail. For me, the standout was their pumpernickel bagel, toasted and topped with a heap of chive cream cheese, both earthy and fresh.
The menu plays with tradition without losing sight of what works. The salt bagel with a scoop of house-made veggie spread is salty, savory, and just right for starting the day.
If you want a spot that looks as good as it tastes, this is it. The Bagel Club Miami merges style, substance, and a little bit of local flair on every plate.
9. N Bagel
(786) 542-0462Call
N Bagel keeps things straightforward, but the quality is anything but ordinary. The bagels here have a subtle crunch outside and a pillowy inside that’s tough to forget. I stopped in out of curiosity and wound up staying for a classic: toasted sesame bagel with house-made veggie cream cheese.
The menu covers every craving, from traditional plain to seeded favorites. Bagels arrive warm, with spreads made in-house, giving even simple choices a special touch.
Next time you’re nearby, try their multigrain bagel for something hearty yet light. N Bagel’s attention to texture and flavor sets them apart, making it a solid stop for both bagel enthusiasts and early morning wanderers.
10. Westside Bagels
Westside Bagels is the kind of place where the bagels don’t stay on the shelf for long. Each bagel has a classic crunch and soft interior that feels almost nostalgic. My visit started with the onion bagel toasted to perfection, paired with a simple yet rich scallion cream cheese—comforting and memorable.
The menu offers all the staples, but their whole wheat bagel stands out. It’s hearty, never dry, turning even a basic breakfast into something noteworthy.
If you appreciate a neighborhood spot with reliable quality, Westside Bagels delivers. The staff moves fast, and the regulars know exactly what they want, a clear sign you’re in the right place for a satisfying bagel experience.
More Things to Try in Coral Gables, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a bagel from Coral Gables stand out compared to others?
Bagels in Coral Gables often combine a New York-style chew with fresh, local ingredients. Many shops here bake daily and offer unique twists—like specialty spreads and inventive toppings—that you won’t find everywhere.
Which bagel shop in Coral Gables is known for the most authentic New York-style bagels?
Several local spots come close, but Bagel Emporium & Grille and New York Bagel Deli Brickell are favorites for their chewy interiors and classic crusts reminiscent of the best from New York.
Are there vegetarian options at Coral Gables bagel shops?
Yes, most bagel shops in the area offer a variety of vegetarian-friendly choices, such as veggie cream cheese, salads, and veggie bagel sandwiches.
Can I order bagels online or for catering in Coral Gables?
Absolutely. Many spots, including Bagel Emporium & Grille and Toasted Bagelry & Deli, offer online ordering and catering, making it easy to feed a crowd with fresh bagels.
What’s the best time to visit a bagel shop for maximum freshness?
Morning is your best bet. Bagels are usually freshest just after opening, and the selection is widest before the mid-morning rush.
Are there gluten-free bagel options in Coral Gables?
A handful of local shops do offer gluten-free bagels, though selection varies. It’s worth calling ahead to check availability at your chosen spot.