If you’re on a quest for the best bagels in Cincinnati, you’re in for a treat. Cincinnati boasts a vibrant bagel scene that offers everything from classic flavors to innovative creations. Having sampled countless bagels around the city, I can confidently say that each spot has its own unique charm. Whether you crave a simple smear of cream cheese or a lavish sandwich piled high, there’s something for every bagel lover.
Choosing the right bagel is more than just a decision; it’s an experience. Imagine biting into a warm, fresh bagel, the texture perfectly chewy, and the flavor unmistakably delightful. The following list of local favorites will guide you through some top-notch spots, ensuring you find your perfect match. Let’s dive into the diverse offerings that make Cincinnati’s bagel landscape so irresistible.
Where to find the best bagels in Cincinnati, OH
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Cincinnati, OH:
- Skip’s Bageldeli
- Marx Hot Bagels
- Bruegger’s Bagels
- Big Apple Bagels
- Everything Bagels
- Bagel Bros
- Busken Bakery
- The Bagelry
- Einstein Bros Bagels
- Otr Candy Bar
1. Skip’s Bageldeli
Skip’s Bageldeli is a gem nestled on Montgomery Road, where fresh bagels are the star of the show. This spot has a welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal place for breakfast, lunch, or a casual brunch. What sets Skip’s apart is its commitment to quality; each bagel is handcrafted and baked daily, delivering that perfect chew.
During my visit, I could not help but admire their extensive menu. The everything bagel topped with house-made cream cheese is a standout choice, bursting with flavor and texture. Another must-try is their smoked salmon bagel, beautifully layered with crispy capers that elevate the experience.
It’s the attention to detail and passion for bagel-making that makes Skip’s Bageldeli a top contender in Cincinnati’s bagel scene.
2. Marx Hot Bagels
Marx Hot Bagels stands out on Kenwood Road with its impressive variety of authentic bagels. The moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air, promising a delightful experience. This spot is known for its commitment to kosher practices, ensuring that every bagel and topping adheres to high standards.
On my visit, I was captivated by the friendly service and quick turnaround. The poppy seed bagel with classic shmear became my instant favorite, thanks to its perfect crunch and rich flavor. If you’re in the mood for a hearty meal, try the lox and cream cheese sandwich, which captures the essence of New York-style bagels right here in Cincinnati.
Marx Hot Bagels is a must-try for anyone seeking quality without compromise.
3. Bruegger’s Bagels
Bruegger’s Bagels on Miami Avenue brings a slice of New York to Cincinnati with its authentic bagels baked fresh each morning. The inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect pit stop for breakfast or lunch. What stands out here is the emphasis on quality, with their bagels boasting the right balance of chewiness and flavor.
During a recent visit, I was drawn in by the tempting aroma wafting from the kitchen. The garlic bagel topped with their signature Vermont cream cheese was exceptional, delivering a delightful punch of flavor. For a heartier option, the classic egg and cheese sandwich is a fulfilling choice, perfect for starting a busy day.
With a convenient mobile app for ordering ahead, Bruegger’s Bagels ensures you won’t miss out on a well-crafted bagel in a hurry.
4. Big Apple Bagels
Big Apple Bagels, located on Beechmont Avenue, delivers a taste of the iconic New York bagel scene right here in Cincinnati. The moment you step inside, the cheerful ambiance and the sight of freshly baked bagels make it hard to resist. This spot excels in offering a variety of bagels that perfectly balance taste and texture.
On my visit, I indulged in their cinnamon raisin bagel with a spread of whipped cream cheese. The combination of sweet cinnamon and creamy texture was simply delightful. If you prefer something more savory, the asiago cheese bagel with a dash of garlic cream cheese is a must-try for a cozy flavor explosion.
Big Apple Bagels truly shines with its commitment to quality and flavor, making it a local favorite for bagel enthusiasts.
5. Everything Bagels
Everything Bagels is a vibrant spot on Eastgate South Drive that caters to both bagel lovers and those seeking vegetarian or vegan options. The moment you walk in, the lively atmosphere and enticing display of bagels immediately draw you in. Their dedication to quality is evident in every bite.
During my experience there, I couldn’t resist trying their famous everything bagel, which lives up to its name with a perfect blend of spices and toppings. Paired with an avocado spread, it made for a refreshing and satisfying choice. If you’re craving something heartier, the breakfast sandwich featuring egg and cheese is a delightful classic.
Everything Bagels excels in variety and flavor, making it a must-visit for bagel enthusiasts in Cincinnati.
6. Bagel Bros
Bagel Bros is a beloved bagel shop situated on Calhoun Street, essentially a local treasure for breakfast and brunch lovers in Cincinnati. The inviting atmosphere combined with the scent of freshly baked bagels creates an irresistible charm. This place shines with its wide selection of bagels, sandwiches, and quality coffee, making it a favorite among both locals and students.
During my recent visit, I was struck by the freshness of their offerings. The plain bagel with strawberry cream cheese stood out for its delightful flavor combination. For those desiring a heartier meal, the smoked turkey and avocado sandwich hits the spot, showcasing the shop’s versatility.
Bagel Bros truly captures the essence of great bagels in Cincinnati, making it a must-visit destination.
7. Busken Bakery
(513) 922-7395Call
Busken Bakery, located on Glenway Avenue, is a beloved institution in Cincinnati, known for its incredible baked goods, including their delightful bagels. This charming bakery combines traditional recipes with local flair, creating a warm, inviting space for customers. Whether you’re in the mood for something sweet or savory, Busken Bakery delivers with quality and consistency.
During my visit, I couldn’t resist the temptation of their garlic bagel. Its rich flavor and texture were a perfect match for a spread of cream cheese. For an indulgent treat, the everything bagel topped with lox is a must-try, capturing the essence of a classic New York breakfast.
With its reputation for excellence, Busken Bakery offers a delightful bagel experience that is not to be missed.
8. The Bagelry
The Bagelry on Madison Road is a delightful spot that champions the art of bagel-making, offering a cozy and welcoming environment. Known for its commitment to freshness and quality, this locale draws in bagel lovers from all over Cincinnati. The diverse menu showcases a range of bagels, each crafted with care.
During my visit, I was particularly impressed by their plain bagel with homemade herb cream cheese, a classic combination done exceptionally well. Additionally, the jalapeño cheddar bagel provided a spicy kick, complementing the rich flavors perfectly.
The Bagelry sets itself apart with its dedication to traditional flavors while incorporating a modern twist, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking great bagels in Cincinnati.
9. Einstein Bros Bagels
Einstein Bros Bagels, located on Calhoun Street, is known for its lively atmosphere and extensive menu focusing on flavorful bagels and breakfast items. This spot combines a fast-casual dining experience with quality, ensuring that customers enjoy fresh bagels every day. With its inviting space, it’s a perfect place to grab a quick bite or settle in for a relaxed meal.
On my last visit, I ordered the everything bagel topped with their classic cream cheese, and it exceeded my expectations for flavor and freshness. For those seeking something heartier, the spinach and cheese bagel sandwich is a must-try, providing a satisfying start to the day.
Einstein Bros Bagels stands out for its commitment to variety and taste, making it a top choice for bagel enthusiasts in Cincinnati.
10. Otr Candy Bar
Otr Candy Bar, nestled in the heart of Cincinnati, is a unique spot where bagels meet creativity. Located on W Elder Street, this vibrant eatery stands out for its playful approach to food, infusing fun into every meal. The atmosphere is both relaxed and inviting, making it an ideal place for leisurely breakfasts or casual lunches.
On my visit, I was enchanted by their circus bagel, a colorful creation that balanced flavors beautifully without sacrificing quality. Pair it with their homemade cream cheese for a delightful experience. Another highlight is the B.L.T. bagel sandwich, which combines fresh ingredients for a satisfying bite.
Otr Candy Bar is all about innovative flavors and an enjoyable setting, making it a charming choice for bagel lovers in Cincinnati.
More Things to Try in Cincinnati, OH
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best bagels in Cincinnati?
A: Cincinnati offers several excellent bagel spots. Some favorites include Skip’s Bageldeli, Marx Hot Bagels, and The Bagelry. Each place has its unique offerings, so exploring a few is a great idea.
Q: Are there vegan or vegetarian bagel options in Cincinnati?
A: Yes, many bagel shops in Cincinnati provide vegan and vegetarian choices. Shops like Everything Bagels and Otr Candy Bar offer a variety of plant-based spreads and toppings.
Q: What are some popular bagel toppings?
A: Popular toppings include classic cream cheese, smoked salmon, avocado, and various vegetables. For something different, try flavored cream cheeses or homemade spreads available at local shops.
Q: Can I get bagels for breakfast catering in Cincinnati?
A: Absolutely! Several places, including Bruegger’s Bagels, offer breakfast catering options. You can order a variety of bagels and spreads for events and gatherings.
Q: What is the difference between New York-style and Montreal-style bagels?
A: New York-style bagels are larger and typically boiled in water before baking, giving them a chewy texture. Montreal-style bagels are smaller, sweeter, and often cooked in honey-sweetened water, resulting in a denser, more flavorful product.
Q: Do bagel shops in Cincinnati accept orders online?
A: Many bagel shops, like Einstein Bros Bagels and Bruegger’s, allow online ordering for pickup, making it easy to enjoy your favorite bagels on the go.
Q: Are there gluten-free bagel options in Cincinnati?
A: Some shops offer gluten-free bagel options. It’s best to check with individual locations, as availability may vary.