Brookville might not hog the local food headlines, but it quietly excels in one vital craft: bagels worth getting out of bed for. If you’ve ever spent a weekend morning hunting for that ideal mix of crisp shell and tender middle, you know the journey can be a saga. Once, I wandered Long Island’s leafy roads chasing that elusive perfect bagel, only to end up in Brookville, where every bakery had its own distinct approach—yet all seemed to hit the spot. That first bite made it clear; this area has hidden talent kneaded right into its dough.
With plenty of choices around, the question isn’t whether you’ll find a good bagel—it’s which spot delivers the exact flavor or texture you crave. Whether you’re a purist (sesame, lightly toasted, maybe a swipe of cream cheese) or you chase bolder varieties, this guide slices through the noise. You’ll find clear, honest takes on each shop, so you won’t waste a morning on anything less than outstanding. The perfect bagel is closer than you think.
Where to find the best bagels in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Brookville, NY:
- Bagel Boss
- Bagel Doctor
- Locust Valley Bagels
- Gabby’s Gourmet Bagels
- Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
- Bagel Boss Hicksville
- Greenvale Bagels
- Bagel Master
- Bagelman Of Mineola
- BagelGram
1. Bagel Boss
(516) 626-5599Call
Bagel Boss in Roslyn Heights stands out for its consistent quality and impressive variety. On my first visit, the fresh, chewy bagels pulled me right in—the everything bagel paired with their whipped scallion cream cheese set a high bar I still use for comparison.
What makes Bagel Boss unique is its kosher certification and 100% nut-free promise, making it an easy choice for anyone with dietary restrictions. They take care to offer gluten-free and vegan options, so nobody has to miss out on the classics.
If you’re stopping in, try their sesame bagel with egg salad or grab a traditional plain bagel, toasted, with their homemade tuna. These simple combos let Bagel Boss’s old-school flavors shine.
2. Bagel Doctor
Bagel Doctor in Jericho delivers on its reputation for classic, no-fuss bagels done right. My own Sunday tradition wouldn’t be complete without their onion bagel, warm and just the right balance of chewy and crisp. The old-school bakery vibe draws regulars who know there’s comfort in routine.
It stands out for fast, friendly service and wallet-friendly prices. You never have to wait long, and the staff remembers your order—even after one or two visits. There’s nothing overly fancy here, just solid bagel craftsmanship.
The standout pairing here: a salt bagel with their creamy chive spread. For purists, the egg bagel with a classic schmear is a must. It’s bagels, but with quiet confidence.
3. Locust Valley Bagels
Locust Valley Bagels feels like a neighborhood staple where every bite is somehow familiar and reliable. I still remember stumbling in half-awake one Saturday, only to be revived by a perfectly boiled and baked poppy seed bagel. The warmth and crunch hit all the right notes—simple and honest, just how it should be.
This shop stands out for its friendly staff and generous portions. The locals swear by their classic combos, so you know they’re doing something right. There’s no attempt to show off, just great bagels at a price that keeps you coming back.
Order the whole wheat everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese or opt for a cinnamon raisin if you’re after something sweet. These spins add character to the classics, all served with an easy small-town charm.
4. Gabby’s Gourmet Bagels
Gabby’s Gourmet Bagels brings an upscale touch to the art of bagel-making. The first time I stopped by, I was drawn in by their fresh, hand-rolled bagels with inventive spreads. A single bite of their pumpernickel with scallion cream cheese made a lasting impression. You’ll notice the attention to detail in every sandwich and spread.
This spot stands out for its impeccable freshness and creative menu. Service is swift, and the staff always has a recommendation up their sleeve. Gabby’s offers a lovely balance for those who like both classic and adventurous flavors.
Don’t miss out on their egg everything bagel or the sundried tomato cream cheese. These standouts are a clear sign that Gabby’s doesn’t cut corners on quality or taste.
5. Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe
(516) 671-0100Call
Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe carries that classic local vibe—friendly faces behind the counter and bagels that speak for themselves. I once ducked in after a long walk along the waterfront, and the scent of freshly baked bagels was hard to resist. Their bagels have that right mix of crisp exterior and doughy middle, never skimping on quality.
What sets Sea Cliff Bagel Cafe apart is its consistent freshness and wide variety of spreads. It’s the kind of spot where you’re just as likely to see families as commuters grabbing a quick bite before starting the day.
If you’re after a recommendation, the sesame bagel with vegetable cream cheese or their hearty whole wheat bagel is a safe bet. Each bite reflects their old-school, welcoming approach to bagel-making.
6. Bagel Boss Hicksville
Bagel Boss Hicksville keeps the tradition alive with their dense, chewy bagels and no-nonsense service. I discovered them early on a lazy Sunday, thanks to a friend who swore their rye bagel would change my mind about breakfast. She was right—it packed plenty of flavor without any fuss.
Bagel Boss Hicksville stands out for its generous deli-style options and its classic, satisfying bagel recipe. The deli counter is always buzzing, and you won’t have to wait long, even when the line snakes out the door.
The must-try? Their pumpernickel bagel with classic cream cheese or, if you’re craving something filling, the whole wheat with veggie spread. Each bagel packs in years of experience and a genuine New York attitude.
7. Greenvale Bagels
Greenvale Bagels offers that old-school comfort you look for on a bustling morning. My standout memory is grabbing a hot sesame bagel straight from the rack as the sun rose—a small, everyday luxury that Greenvale seems to do best. The smells alone are reason to stop in.
This spot stands out thanks to its friendly, efficient crew and never-stale offerings. The parking is easy, so you never have to work hard for your breakfast or snack. It’s community-focused, with regulars chatting across bakery tables each morning.
Don’t be shy about ordering their everything bagel loaded with veggie cream cheese, or their classic cinnamon raisin for a sweet twist. Simple, well-made, and satisfying—just what the best bagel should be.
8. Bagel Master
Bagel Master in Syosset lives up to its name, serving up pillowy, flavorful bagels that never disappoint. My first experience was a classic: a fresh sesame bagel, still warm, with a generous smear of their homemade veggie cream cheese. Simple, but it set the gold standard for every bagel after.
The menu shines with both bagel staples and creative specialty options. What keeps people coming back is their attention to texture—chewy inside, crisp outside—each one made with care. You can feel the passion behind every batch.
If you’re unsure where to begin, try the garlic bagel with a classic egg salad or go a bit sweet with their blueberry bagel and plain cream cheese. These combinations put Bagel Master’s range on full display.
9. Bagelman Of Mineola
Bagelman Of Mineola is a spot that takes bagels seriously, but never feels stuffy. My go-to order here is their toasted everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. The crisp edges and robust flavor make it an easy favorite on busy mornings—trust me, even a quick stop feels special.
This place stands out for its quick service and generous bagel selection. Regulars appreciate the always-fresh bakery case and the staff’s attention to detail. Free parking adds to the stress-free experience, perfect for a grab-and-go routine.
The signature sesame bagel, paired with a scoop of classic tuna salad, gives you a clear sense of Bagelman’s style: simple, well-executed, and satisfying. It’s authentic comfort any day of the week.
10. BagelGram
BagelGram is the answer when you crave real New York bagels without leaving home. My first order felt almost like magic—fresh bagels landed on my doorstep still warm, with that unmistakable city flavor. The experience rivals a trip to the bakery, minus the lines and parking struggles.
This service stands out for its reliable delivery and clear commitment to freshness. Whether you’re hosting brunch or fueling up for the week, you get authentic bagels made with care. They cover all the classics, using old-school recipes that keep the chew and flavor intact.
For standout picks, try their blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese or grab a baker’s dozen to experience the whole range. BagelGram brings that Brooklyn spirit straight to your breakfast table.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes bagels in Brookville, NY different?
Bagels here are known for their authentic texture—crisp outside, chewy inside. Many local shops use traditional kettle-boiling methods and source top ingredients. You’ll find both classic flavors and creative specials that keep things interesting.
Are there gluten-free or vegan bagel options near Brookville?
Yes, several local spots like Bagel Boss offer gluten-free and vegan bagels and spreads. It’s best to check menus or call ahead for availability, as options can rotate.
Can I order bagels for catering or events?
Absolutely. Many Brookville area bakeries provide catering trays and bulk bagel orders. You can include bagels, spreads, and salads for gatherings, meetings, or family weekends.
Which bagel shops have the best reviews in Brookville?
Shops like Bagel Boss, Bagel Doctor, and Locust Valley Bagels often stand out based on local reviews and word of mouth. Each has its specialties, so trying a few is the best way to find your favorite.
What are the most popular bagel flavors in the area?
Favorites include everything, sesame, plain, and cinnamon raisin. Many places also offer unique takes, like blueberry or pumpernickel, to keep things fresh and exciting.