Bethpage, NY, is a bagel lover’s dream. I’ve explored this charming town, and trust me, it’s a bagel paradise. You’ll find warm, fresh bagels at every turn. I’m excited to share my favorites.
So, what are the best bagels in Bethpage, NY? The top spots are known for their amazing, fresh bagels. They offer a variety of flavors and toppings. Each place has its own special touch that makes it unique. You won’t be disappointed.
Stick around! I’ll share the best bagel spots in town. You’ll discover what makes each one special. Let’s dive into this delicious journey together!
Top 5 Bagels in Bethpage, NY
- Bethpage Bagels
- Stuff-A-Bagel Bethpage
- Central Ave Gourmet Deli & bagels
- Bagel & Deli Creations
- Bagelafe
1. Bethpage Bagels
Bethpage Bagels is a true gem. Located on N Wantagh Ave, it’s a cozy spot. The moment you walk in, the smell of fresh bagels hits you. It feels inviting and warm.
What I love most? Their bagels are soft and fluffy. Each one is hand-rolled and baked just right. They have a great selection, too! You can grab everything from plain to everything bagels. Plus, they offer curbside pickup and takeout, which is super handy.
When I visit, I can’t resist the lox and cream cheese bagel. It’s simple, but oh so good! The creamy lox goes perfectly with the chewy bagel. It’s a classic choice that really shows off their quality. Trust me, you’ll love it!
2. Stuff-A-Bagel Bethpage
Phone: (516) 933-8468
Menu: stuffabagelbethpage.wixsite.com
Directions: Open on Map
Stuff-A-Bagel Bethpage is such a cool spot! Located right on Broadway, it’s super inviting. You can choose to sit inside or outside, which I love. They even offer delivery and takeout. Perfect for those busy mornings!
What really makes this place shine? The creative stuffed bagels! They’re huge and seriously delicious. I was blown away by all the options they have.
Every time I stop by, I can’t resist the stuffed breakfast bagel. It’s loaded with eggs, cheese, and your choice of meat. It’s filling and packed with flavor. You can really taste the quality in every bite. If you’re nearby, you’ve got to check it out!
3. Central Ave Gourmet Deli & bagels
Phone: (516) 939-9393
Menu: centralbagel.com
Directions: Open on Map
You have to check out Central Ave Gourmet Deli & Bagels. It’s this little spot on Central Ave. Nothing fancy, but super welcoming. Plus, they do delivery and takeout. So, it’s really easy to grab your favorite bagels.
The bagels? Oh, they’re amazing. Soft, chewy, and so fresh. Each bite feels like it’s made just for you. You can tell they put love into what they do. The variety is insane. There’s something for everyone.
Whenever I go, I get the bacon, egg, and cheese bagel. It’s just the best. The bacon is crispy, the eggs are fluffy, and the cheese melts perfectly. It’s simple, yet unforgettable. Honestly, it’s the kind of meal that makes your day better. Try it—you’ll thank me later!
4. Bagel & Deli Creations
Bagel & Deli Creations is such a cool spot! It’s right on Hempstead Tpke. I love how cozy and welcoming it feels. You can choose to sit inside or outside, which is nice. They even offer delivery and takeout for those busy days.
So, what stands out here? Their menu is super creative. They have a great selection of unique bagels. Each bagel is fresh and packed with flavor. You can tell they really care about quality.
Whenever I visit, I can’t help but get the turkey club bagel. It’s huge and loaded with goodness. Turkey, bacon, lettuce—it all works together perfectly. Each bite is just delicious. If you’re nearby, definitely give it a try!
5. Bagelafe
Phone: (516) 942-3840
Menu: bagelafe.com
Directions: Open on Map
Bagelafe is such a nice spot! It’s located on Hicksville Rd. The vibe is cozy, perfect for hanging out. You can choose to sit inside or outside. They also offer delivery and takeout, which is super convenient.
I had a great experience there. The staff was really friendly and welcoming. It made me feel right at home. I loved how relaxed the atmosphere was.
What makes Bagelafe stand out? Their menu is full of fun and tasty options. Each bagel is fresh and full of flavor. You can tell they care about quality.
When you go, you’ve got to try the smoked salmon bagel. It’s packed with flavor and really showcases what Bagelafe is all about. You won’t regret it!
Map of Bagels in Bethpage, NY
Choosing the Right Shop for You
With 5 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Shop | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bethpage Bagels | Inexpensive | – | Yes | – | Accessible | – |
| Stuff-A-Bagel Bethpage | Inexpensive | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Central Ave Gourmet Deli & bagels | Inexpensive | – | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagel & Deli Creations | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | – |
| Bagelafe | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | No |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where can I find the best bagels?
Oh, there are so many good places! Try Bethpage Bagels or Stuff-A-Bagel. Both are local favorites.
2. Are the bagels really fresh?
Totally fresh, every single day. You can taste it. Warm, soft, and perfect!
3. Can I get delivery?
Yes, most spots deliver! It’s so handy. You can enjoy bagels at home.
4. What toppings should I try?
Go for cream cheese or lox. Flavored spreads are fun too! There’s always something new.
5. Are there places to sit and eat?
Yes, of course! Most shops have cozy seating. Perfect for a relaxed bagel break.
