Nothing sharpens the appetite quite like a brisk Atlantic City morning. If you know the area, you know it’s a town that takes bagels seriously. As someone who’s stood in line with locals debating the merits of a perfect everything bagel, I can tell you—the quest is real, and the selection is impressive.
This guide sorts through every classic shop and hidden nook to help you find the very best bagels in Atlantic City. Whether you crave a tender chew, a crisp crust, or just the right smear, you’ll find tips here for every preference. Prepare to discover favorites you’ll want to revisit—and maybe even settle your own local debate.
Where to find the best bagels in Atlantic City, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Atlantic City, NJ:
- Borgata Buffet
- Hot Bagels & More
- Café Tazza Delizioso
- Tazza Caffé
- Bread and Butter
- Fresh Harvest Buffet
- Dunkin’
- N Y Style Bagles
- Brigantine Beach Bagel
- Yianni’s Cafe
1. Borgata Buffet
When I walked into Borgata Buffet, the sheer spread set the tone. It’s Atlantic City’s answer to “what if you could have everything for breakfast?” Bagel lovers won’t leave disappointed here. I once paired a perfect sesame bagel with rich smoked salmon and creamy chive cheese, and it was the highlight of my morning.
The bagel station is surprisingly top-tier, offering warm, freshly baked choices with plenty of classic toppings. Cream cheese, jams, and smoked fish reflect the buffet’s commitment to variety and freshness. If you want to start your day with something filling and classic, Borgata’s bagels set a high bar.
Try an everything bagel with lox for a taste that’s both satisfying and pure Atlantic City.
2. Hot Bagels & More
I remember my first visit to Hot Bagels & More—a rush of energy, the sound of bagels being sliced, and the inviting scent of fresh dough. This spot knows how to please a crowd with its bustling atmosphere and bags packed with a dozen in minutes. It’s an Atlantic City favorite for a reason.
What stands out is their variety and freshness. Each bagel is baked daily, achieving that magic balance: a crisp outer layer and a light, airy center. Vegetarian options and spreads add even more reason to swing by, especially if you love a classic breakfast on the go.
Try their poppy seed bagel with veggie cream cheese; it’s simple yet satisfying, and you’ll taste why Hot Bagels & More gets the morning crowds talking.
3. Café Tazza Delizioso
Café Tazza Delizioso inside Harrah’s Resort is a hidden treat for anyone who wants a lighter, more European take on breakfast in Atlantic City. On my last visit, I found myself wandering in at sunrise, searching for something simple but satisfying before a busy day. The atmosphere felt relaxed and charming—unexpected in a casino tower.
Bagel lovers will appreciate their fresh-baked options. The spreads here make all the difference, with options like silky plain cream cheese or roasted veggie. Their bagels pair beautifully with a cup of bold, Italian roast coffee.
If you want something with a little flair, grab a plain or whole wheat bagel with the herbed cream cheese. It’s the kind of breakfast that nails both comfort and elegance, swaying just a bit from tradition.
4. Tazza Caffé
Tazza Caffé is tucked inside Caesars, and once you walk in, the warm scent of fresh-baked bread is hard to miss. My morning ritual here involves a strong Illy coffee and a bagel so fresh it almost steams when sliced. This café truly gets the details right, from the pastries to the polished service.
The standout at Tazza is their hearty breakfast bagels. They’re perfect if you want something more robust before hitting the boardwalk. Each bagel is soft inside, yet holds its shape, and the toppings are generously portioned.
Order a classic bagel with cream cheese or go for a toasted whole wheat with a veggie spread. Pair it with a rich espresso for a breakfast that feels both indulgent and practical. It’s the ideal start for a day in Atlantic City.
5. Bread and Butter
Bread and Butter at Borgata Hotel is one of those rare spots where a bagel is always just the right choice, no matter the hour. My go-to move after a late night is stopping in for a toasted bagel, relishing the calm after the casino’s buzz. The staff always greets you with a genuine smile, even if it’s almost sunrise.
Their bagels stand out for two reasons: quality and consistency. Each is soft inside, with a subtle outer crunch—the kind you crave with a hot coffee. Every topping is fresh, and the classic choices let you keep it simple.
Order a classic bagel with plain or veggie cream cheese, and you’ll see why Bread and Butter keeps regulars coming back. This spot delivers comfort, without sacrificing flavor or freshness.
6. Fresh Harvest Buffet
The first thing you notice at Fresh Harvest Buffet is the sheer excitement of live cooking stations and endless options. I once spent an entire morning just exploring the breakfast spread, but the bagel station reeled me in with its tempting lineup.
Their bagels are warm, freshly baked, and always paired with top-quality spreads. No matter when you go, you’re treated to a soft interior and a subtle, crisp crust. The variety at this buffet makes it ideal for groups or people who want to sample a bit of everything.
For a classic Atlantic City touch, try a plain bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon. It’s a simple yet memorable way to enjoy the buffet’s attention to freshness.
7. Dunkin’
Every Atlantic City morning inevitably passes a Dunkin’, and sometimes, familiarity is exactly what you want. I’ve grabbed more than a few bagels at this Bally’s location on my way to the boardwalk. The speed and consistency are unmatched, especially if you’re in a rush or just want your favorite done right.
Dunkin’s bagels are reliable, with a soft bite and mild flavor that pairs well with their signature cream cheese spreads. It’s that predictability that has folks returning daily—plus, the coffee is always hot.
Go for a toasted multigrain bagel with plain cream cheese for a quick, satisfying breakfast. It’s basic in the best way, making Dunkin’ a solid pick for that classic bagel fix.
8. N Y Style Bagles
N Y Style Bagles brings a slice of New York tradition right to Atlantic City. Stepping into this shop, I’m always hit with memories of early-morning Manhattan bagel runs—except the ocean’s just blocks away.
The bagels here have that trademark chew and flavorful crust you expect from a proper New York bagel. You can taste the care in every batch, from the plain to the sesame and everything in between.
If you’re unsure, try a classic everything bagel with plain or veggie cream cheese. It’s the kind of breakfast that feels both humble and indulgent, and it doesn’t try to reinvent what already works.
9. Brigantine Beach Bagel
(609) 266-0555Call
Brigantine Beach Bagel is the kind of spot that feels like summer, even in the off-season. I’ve stopped by on a chilly morning, only to be greeted by the warmth of fresh bagels and cheerful regulars. The beach town vibe makes every visit relaxed and welcoming.
These bagels set themselves apart with a light, fluffy interior and just the right amount of chew. They’re made for mornings by the shore or a quick bite before hitting the sand.
Order a sesame bagel with plain or veggie cream cheese—simple, satisfying, and a perfect fit for the Brigantine spirit. This is where to get a bagel that feels authentically local.
10. Yianni’s Cafe
(609) 266-4600Call
The local energy at Yianni’s Cafe makes every visit memorable, especially on a lazy weekend morning. I stopped in once after an early walk, hoping for something quick but fresh, and left with a bagel that hit all the right notes. The staff makes regulars feel like family, even if you’re just passing through.
Yianni’s bagels stand out with their generous size and classic, chewy bite. It’s the kind of spot where you appreciate the simplicity of a plain or whole wheat bagel toasted to perfection.
Pair a bagel with their veggie cream cheese for a breakfast that’s hearty but never heavy. It’s a Brigantine staple for anyone who appreciates a fresh, satisfying start.
More Things to Try in Atlantic City, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Atlantic City bagels different?
Atlantic City’s best bagels tend to have the perfect contrast—a crisp outer crust and a soft, chewy center. Local shops often boil their dough and bake fresh each day, giving bagels a classic texture and flavor.
Where can I find bagels near the casinos?
Several top bagel shops are inside or within walking distance of major casinos, like Borgata Buffet, Bread and Butter, and Tazza Caffé. Even Dunkin’ has convenient locations close to the action.
Are there vegetarian or vegan bagel options available?
Many Atlantic City bagel shops offer vegetarian and vegan choices. Look for veggie-based spreads, dairy-free cream cheeses, and a variety of plant-friendly toppings.
Do bagel shops in Atlantic City offer gluten-free options?
A few shops do carry gluten-free bagels or breads—though availability sometimes changes. It’s best to call ahead or check menus online before visiting.
What are classic bagel toppings in Atlantic City?
Cream cheese, lox, and veggie spreads are popular, along with staples like butter and jam. Many places offer unique twists, so trying something new often pays off.