Bagels have a way of turning an ordinary morning into a reason to linger at the table just a little longer. Appleton, WI, may not be New York, but it’s got its own bagel game worth waking up for. You’d be surprised how many locals have strong opinions about their favorite spot and it’s easy to see why once you start tasting your way across town.
Finding the best bagel can feel a bit like chasing down local legend. After countless mornings clutching coffee, comparing everything bagels, and splitting cinnamon raisin with friends, I’ve picked up more than a few secrets about who’s doing it right. Whether you crave chewy classics or crave something a little out of the ordinary, the shops here each have their own twist. Let’s break down where to get the bagels you’ll remember.
1. Sap Brunch, Brown Bag & Bakery
If you like your mornings filled with fresh flavors, Sap Brunch, Brown Bag & Bakery is a must. This spot skips shortcuts and serves bagels made from scratch. Every bite feels crafted with intention—lightly chewy, flavorful, and never dry.
What really sold me was the creative menu. Try their everything bagel with house-made cream cheese and a side of locally-sourced smoked salmon for a classic with a twist. The vegan options are just as thoughtful, making this a hit even if you’re plant-based.
There’s a genuine local vibe here, too. Staff greet everyone like a regular, which makes lingering over breakfast an easy habit. No surprise it’s a favorite for bagel lovers who want something real in Appleton.
2. Jersey Bagel and Deli
Jersey Bagel and Deli delivers that classic East Coast bagel experience right in the heart of Appleton. Walk in and you’re hit with the irresistible smell of fresh, chewy bagels—no frills, just tradition done right.
Most mornings, I find myself torn between the simplicity of a hand-rolled plain bagel or their everything bagel loaded with garden-fresh veggies. If you appreciate unfussy, authentic flavor, this is the place.
Their bagel sandwiches, especially the veggie spread on a toasted sesame, are a standout. Each bite has a perfect crunch and chew, a rare feat outside New York or New Jersey. No need to cross state lines—your bagel fix is right here.
3. Big Apple Bagels
At Big Apple Bagels, mornings feel easy. The space is simple and friendly, always buzzing with people looking for a quick breakfast fix. Here, you can tell the focus is on comfort and familiarity—every visit feels like a routine worth keeping.
The bagels are pillowy yet satisfyingly dense, just the way you want them. Don’t miss the spinach Florentine bagel or the classic asiago cheese. The spreads are generous, especially their signature cream cheese blends that add a creamy punch without overpowering the bagel.
This spot is perfect for breakfast on the go, or for lingering with a good mug of coffee. The friendly staff and steady flow of regulars make it feel like a true neighborhood staple.
4. Panera Bread
Panera Bread is the go-to when you want consistency and comfort. The bagels here lean soft and bready, making them a great base for generous spreads or thoughtful sandwiches. There’s always a familiar, relaxed buzz—a place that works whether you’re flying solo or catching up with friends.
For me, the cinnamon swirl bagel is a staple. Pair it with the honey walnut cream cheese, and you get just the right balance of sweet and nutty. For something heartier, the whole grain bagel with veggie toppings brings freshness to your usual routine.
The variety is the real draw, from asiago cheese to blueberry, and the ability to customize. Panera’s reliability and range make it easy to stay a regular.
5. Kjdt
(920) 380-9097Call
Kjdt is one of those places locals mention in a lowered voice, almost like sharing a secret. The vibe is delightfully unpretentious—a simple spot that quietly puts out solid bagels, no theatrics needed.
On my first visit, I went straight for the classic sesame bagel. It hit that perfect middle ground between chewy and soft, with a subtle nutty flavor and satisfying crust. Their bagels don’t rely on flashy toppings. Instead, texture and taste do the talking.
Kjdt’s charm is its focus and warmth. The menu may be minimalist, but every option is carefully made. If you value no-fuss, authentic bagels, it’s worth seeking out this College Avenue gem.
6. Bagelicious
Bagelicious has all the charm of a local mainstay, where the bagels are affordable and the service is genuine. The atmosphere is relaxed, welcoming everyone from early risers to brunch seekers. Here, it’s about fresh flavors without any fuss.
The bagel menu covers the essentials, but what really stands out is the balance in their texture—chewy centers and crisp edges. The poppy seed bagel with veggie cream cheese is a personal favorite, tangy and satisfying enough to skip lunch.
There’s a comfort in routine at Bagelicious. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down with a cup of coffee, their straightforward approach keeps people coming back. This is the neighborhood bagel spot you start to crave.
7. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ keeps things simple and efficient—exactly what you want for mornings on the move. It’s the comfort of knowing your favorite bagel is waiting, no matter the rush. There’s always a crowd, but the line moves fast and the staff never miss a beat.
I usually go for their classic plain or multigrain bagel. Pair it with the garden veggie cream cheese for something quick and filling. While their bagels are softer than your typical bakery, they deliver on convenience and consistency every time.
Perfect for a grab-and-go breakfast or mid-day snack, Dunkin’ hits the spot when you need something reliable. It’s hard not to appreciate a place where you can order in your sleep and always know what you’ll get.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I get fresh bagels in Appleton, WI?
You’ll find fresh bagels at Sap Brunch, Jersey Bagel and Deli, Big Apple Bagels, Bagelicious, and Dunkin’. Each spot bakes daily, so you can expect soft, just-made bagels most mornings.
Are there places in Appleton that offer vegan or vegetarian bagel options?
Yes. Both Sap Brunch and Panera Bread have vegan and vegetarian-friendly bagels and spreads. Jersey Bagel and Deli also serves a variety of fresh veggie toppings and dairy-free spreads.
What’s the best bagel sandwich to try in Appleton?
The everything bagel with house-made cream cheese at Sap Brunch is a standout, but don’t skip the veggie-loaded sandwich at Jersey Bagel and Deli or the asiago cheese bagel at Panera for a quick, savory option.
Which Appleton bagel shop is best for a quick breakfast?
Dunkin’ and Big Apple Bagels are both fast and reliable for a grab-and-go breakfast. Dunkin’ has a streamlined system for morning rushes, while Big Apple Bagels is a bit more laid-back but still quick.
Do any local Appleton bagel shops offer gluten-free options?
Sap Brunch stands out for its gluten-free choices, and Panera Bread sometimes has gluten-conscious options, though cross-contact is possible. It’s always a good idea to call ahead and check what’s available that day.