Searching for the best bagels in Santa Fe can feel like a quirky mission. Santa Fe isn’t the first city most people think of for classic bagels, but that’s what makes discovering them here feel a bit like finding a hidden gem. Over the years, I’ve sampled many—from seeded rings with chewy interiors to toasted wonders melting beneath a generous spread. The local bakeries and cafes take bagels as seriously as sky-gazers chase sunsets in New Mexico.
If you crave a freshly baked bagel—crisp on the outside, tender within, and easy to pair with your favorite schmear—you’ve landed in the right place. Whether you’re a fan of classic sesame, bold everything, or a cinnamon raisin twist, this guide rolls through the top local spots that treat bagels with genuine care. Dive in; each stop is worth a bite.
Where to find the best bagels in Santa Fe, NM
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Santa Fe, NM:
- Cafe Catron
- New York Deli Southside
- BoulTawn’s Cafe & Bakery
- Panera Bread
- Iconik Coffee Roasters and Cafe
- Dunkin’
1. Cafe Catron
Cafe Catron mingles local history and modern taste in a sun-lit, inviting space just a short stroll from Santa Fe Plaza. I first wandered in after a brisk morning walk, expecting basics, but left genuinely impressed by their attention to detail.
The bagels are fresh, slightly crisp outside and tender inside—a sure sign they know what they’re doing. Pair one with their house-made schmears or build your own with classic toppings. Their breakfast bagel sandwich hits a satisfying balance: fluffy eggs, creamy cheese, and a perfectly chewy base.
The outdoor patio, surrounded by artful landscaping, feels like a well-kept secret. With vegetarian and vegan options, everyone finds something to savor. It’s an easy choice for anyone serious about starting their day strong.
2. New York Deli Southside
New York Deli Southside channels that classic deli vibe, right down to the no-nonsense counter and stacks of bagels behind glass. My first visit was on a whim, but the warm staff and aroma of fresh bread drew me in faster than the menu could. The energy here feels unfussy—a genuine spot for a solid breakfast or lunch.
Bagels come in the real New York style—plump, chewy, and served with proper respect for tradition. Make room for their bagel and lox; the balance of silky salmon, capers, and red onion over a crispy bagel is spot on. Or try the bagel, egg, and cheese for something satisfying and simple.
Vegetarian choices are plenty, and breakfast runs all day, so you can chase your bagel craving whenever it appears. This is where you go to satisfy an East Coast fix without leaving the Southwest.
3. BoulTawn’s Cafe & Bakery
BoulTawn’s Cafe & Bakery is tucked just around the corner from galleries, making it ideal for a quick stop after browsing art. I once ducked in during a chilly morning and was met with the welcoming smell of baked goods and fresh coffee.
Their bagels are made onsite, generous in size, and have a soft chew that works well with both sweet and savory toppings. The garden veggie bagel sandwich is always stacked high with crisp, colorful veggies and a dollop of creamy cheese—an easy favorite.
If you’re after a lighter start, try a classic bagel with their signature whipped cream cheese or house preserves for a local twist. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and the pace here matches Santa Fe’s relaxed rhythm, so you can linger as long as you like.
4. Panera Bread
Panera Bread delivers consistency, which is why I find myself stopping here when I need a dependable bagel in Santa Fe. The bright space, easy parking, and quick service make it a convenient spot for breakfast, lunch, or a snack on the go.
Their bagels are known for being fresh with a smooth, slightly sweet finish you can count on every time. My go-to is the asiago cheese bagel—savory, golden, and crisped to perfection. The walnut cream cheese spread adds a rich touch, and together they make a simple yet satisfying meal.
If you want extra variety, try building your own bagel sandwich with their plentiful vegetarian ingredients. Panera’s mix of quality, comfort, and speedy pick-up suits any busy Santa Fe morning.
5. Iconik Coffee Roasters and Cafe
Iconik Coffee Roasters and Cafe pulls you in with the smell of fresh coffee and keeps you around with its relaxed, eclectic vibe. My favorite mornings involve a quiet corner here, a bold espresso, and the sight of sunrise over Lena Street.
Bagels at Iconik lean artisan—firm on the outside, with a subtle, bready sweetness inside, best paired with their house-made spreads. The avocado bagel with a sprinkle of sea salt and local greens offers a fresh, west-meets-southwest flavor.
For something classic, try a toasted plain bagel, topped with their herbed cream cheese and a side of hot coffee. Locally sourced ingredients and small-batch baking set Iconik apart, making it a top spot for those who appreciate detail with their morning bite.
6. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ stands for streamlined mornings, familiar flavors, and reliable speed. I’ve stopped here before early meetings when convenience and consistency matter most. The Santa Fe location keeps up with brisk pace and friendly service, a combo that’s hard to beat on busy days.
The bagels are classic and satisfying—soft, springy, and easy to pair with a hot cup of coffee. Try the everything bagel toasted with their plain cream cheese for an effortless breakfast that hits the spot. If you have a little more time, the veggie bagel sandwich layers in fresh crunch while staying simple and tasty.
Dunkin’ delivers comfort in each bite, ideal when you want a predictable start or need a quick pick-up. It’s a go-to for straightforward bagel flavor in Santa Fe.
More Things to Try in Santa Fe, NM
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find fresh bagels in Santa Fe?
You have plenty of tasty options. Cafe Catron, New York Deli Southside, BoulTawn’s Cafe & Bakery, Panera Bread, Iconik Coffee Roasters, and Dunkin’ all offer fresh bagels daily.
What are the most popular bagel flavors in Santa Fe?
Classic choices like everything, sesame, plain, and asiago cheese are crowd favorites. You’ll also find house-made specialty options at several cafes.
Are there vegetarian or vegan bagel options available?
Yes, nearly every spot on this list serves vegetarian bagels. Many, like Cafe Catron and BoulTawn’s, also offer vegan spreads or sandwiches.
Which spot serves the best bagel and coffee combo?
Iconik Coffee Roasters is a popular pick with locally roasted beans and artisan bagels for a true Santa Fe experience.
Can I get gluten-free bagels in Santa Fe?
Some cafes, including Cafe Catron and Iconik, offer gluten-free options. It’s wise to call ahead as availability can change.