Looking for a truly great bagel in Colorado Springs can feel like exploring a local legend. Everyone seems to know a spot, and friendly debates ensue over which bagel shop actually gets it right. After years wandering the city’s breakfast scene—sometimes with serious bagel cravings—I’ve gathered a reliable list of spots that won’t let you down. These aren’t just places to satisfy a carb fix; they’re where chewy, golden comfort meets a range of fresh toppings.
Finding the best bagels in Colorado Springs isn’t about luck. With a pinch of curiosity and a touch of old-school know-how, you’ll discover classics as well as creative takes that surprise even a lifelong bagel fan. Whether you’re longing for traditional lox and schmear, or just need a quick bite before a busy day, this guide brings together the city’s finest. Go ahead—keep reading to find your new favorite breakfast ritual.
Where to find the best bagels in Colorado Springs, CO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Colorado Springs, CO:
- East Coast Deli
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Olde World Bagel & Deli
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Panera Bread
- Bruegger’s
- Coffee & Bagel Corner
- Dunkin’
1. East Coast Deli
+1 719-633-4522
Walking into East Coast Deli on South Tejon feels a bit like stepping into a corner deli in Manhattan, only with Pikes Peak on the horizon. The place hums with regulars placing familiar orders and newcomers eyeing the menu boards. I once spent a rainy morning here, savoring a classic bagel with smoked salmon and cream cheese, and for a moment, the city seemed to slow down.
What sets East Coast Deli apart is authenticity. Bagels arrive with that golden crust, chewy middle, and just the right hint of malt, transporting you straight to Brooklyn. Try the classic lox bagel—its silky salmon and tangy capers capture the New York spirit with every bite. If you’re feeling bold, the bagel breakfast sandwich is a local favorite, loaded but never overwhelming.
2. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on North Tejon is where I stop when craving something both quick and satisfying. The atmosphere carries a gentle hum of regulars mixing with the aroma of baking bagels. It’s an easy spot to relax with coffee while watching the city start its day.
This spot is known for consistency. The bagels come warm, with a crisp exterior and soft, chewy center. For a satisfying start, go for the classic Bagel & Shmear or customize a breakfast sandwich. I’m partial to their Avocado Toast Bagel—creamy, fresh, and a bit unexpected. Their menu makes it simple to find a favorite, whether you want sweet, savory, or a simple bagel to-go.
3. Olde World Bagel & Deli
Olde World Bagel & Deli has become my go-to for hearty, East Coast–inspired bagels in Colorado Springs. The moment you step inside, there’s a comforting buzz—locals chatting, staff rolling dough, and the unmistakable scent of fresh-baked bread.
The real draw here is variety. Bagels come in flavors ranging from classic sesame to adventurous asiago, with plenty of vegetarian and vegan options. I always find myself drawn to their Everything Bagel topped with house-made cream cheese—simple, yet full of flavor. The veggie bagel sandwich is another winner, with crisp fillings that let the bagel shine.
Olde World’s bagels taste like they’re made with patience, tradition, and a dash of local pride.
4. Einstein Bros. Bagels
There’s something reliable about stopping at Einstein Bros. Bagels on North Powers Boulevard. The space bustles each morning, but never feels rushed. I like sitting near the window—coffee in hand, a toasted bagel within reach, and daylight bouncing off those familiar golden crusts.
This location keeps things fresh and friendly. The bagels are served warm, with plenty of cream cheese options ready for slathering. Their Spinach & Swiss Bagel Sandwich is a personal favorite—hearty, savory, and just filling enough to start the day right. For something classic, the plain bagel with plain shmear is comforting and dependable.
Here, the appeal is in the mix: classic taste, cheerful service, and a menu that covers all breakfast moods.
5. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on East Woodmen Road is my top pick for a relaxed breakfast bite. The space has a warm, inviting feel—just right for catching up with a friend over fresh bagels. I’ve spent a few quiet mornings here with their strong coffee and a bagel that never misses the mark.
Quality and choice take center stage. The menu rotates through staples and unique flavors, so there’s always something new to try. My suggestion? Go for their Honey Whole Wheat Bagel with a generous spread of garden veggie cream cheese. Every bite feels balanced, soft, and wholesome. If you’re a breakfast sandwich devotee, the Farmhouse Bagel Sandwich is filling and full of layered flavors.
This spot gives you that neighborhood comfort with every visit.
6. Einstein Bros. Bagels
The Einstein Bros. Bagels on Centennial Boulevard is my go-to for a quick pick-me-up when I’m running errands on the west side of town. The friendly staff always greet guests with a smile, which makes even a rushed visit feel easy. Fresh bagels line the counter, filling the café with a warm, inviting scent.
What sets this spot apart is the laid-back vibe and outdoor seating. On sunny mornings, I like grabbing a classic Everything Bagel and enjoying it outside with a cup of their house coffee. Their Power Protein Bagel Sandwich is a solid choice if you need fuel for the day—brimming with eggs, cheese, and fresh veggies.
This Einstein Bros. feels like a neighborhood staple—reliable, welcoming, and always satisfying.
7. Panera Bread
Panera Bread on Southgate Road is where I tend to land when I want a cozy spot to get some work done or meet up with friends. The environment buzzes quietly with families, students, and people savoring their morning routines. I like their simple décor and big windows that make even cloudy days feel bright.
The bagel selection here is surprisingly robust. My favorite is the Cinnamon Crunch Bagel—it’s sweet, subtly spiced, and pairs perfectly with a schmear of plain cream cheese. For something more savory, the Asiago Cheese Bagel is a tempting choice—its crisp crust and cheesy melt make it a standout. Panera’s attention to fresh, simple ingredients carries through every order.
It’s easy to linger a little longer at Panera, which might be why so many regulars do.
8. Bruegger’s
(719) 635-8548Call
Bruegger’s on North Tejon brings a real sense of tradition to Colorado Springs’ bagel scene. Walking in, you’re greeted by the aroma of bagels baking in-house and the clatter of morning regulars catching up over coffee. It feels like the kind of place where everyone has a usual order, even if it’s just their second visit.
The hallmark here is classic preparation. Bruegger’s bagels are dense, chewy, and served fresh all day. I recommend the classic Egg Bagel topped with a light spread of their signature veggie cream cheese—simple, but packed with flavor. The smoked salmon and red onion bagel sandwich is another star, nodding to old-school deli style.
Consistent, unfussy, and flavorful, Bruegger’s is a downtown staple for good reason.
9. Coffee & Bagel Corner
Coffee & Bagel Corner, tucked inside the Citadel, surprised me with its down-to-earth charm. The atmosphere is low-key, perfect for a quiet breakfast or a casual chat. On my last visit, I was struck by how genuine and friendly the service was—a rare find in a busy shopping area.
Affordability without compromise is what stands out here. Bagels come fresh and warm, with enough variety to keep mornings interesting. I recommend their classic plain bagel with a generous layer of chive cream cheese; it’s soft, flavorful, and never greasy. For something different, the spinach bagel is delightfully chewy and pairs well with a simple egg topping.
If you want a no-fuss spot for good bagels, this corner delivers every time.
10. Dunkin’
(719) 634-4561Call
Dunkin’ on West Colorado Avenue keeps the focus on convenience without skimping on flavor. Whether I’m dashing in for an early meeting or picking up a quick lunch, it’s always speedy with no fuss. The coffee, predictably strong, pairs well with their reliable bagel selection.
Consistency is Dunkin’s trademark. The bagels are soft, with a slightly crisp outer edge—great for quick toasting. I often choose the multigrain bagel, topped with their classic plain cream cheese, for a simple and filling treat. If you’re craving something heartier, the egg and cheese bagel sandwich hits the spot and never feels heavy.
For straightforward bagels on the go, Dunkin’ makes the process easy and reliable every time.
More Things to Try in Colorado Springs, CO
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a good bagel?
A good bagel is boiled before baking, giving it a crisp outside and chewy inside. Freshness, even crumb, and that signature shine set great bagels apart.
Who serves the most authentic New York–style bagels in Colorado Springs?
East Coast Deli is known for its traditional approach, offering bagels that capture that classic New York flavor and texture.
Which spot has the best variety of bagel flavors?
Olde World Bagel & Deli stands out with a wide range—from sesame to asiago—plus plenty of options for vegetarians and vegans.
Are there vegan or vegetarian bagel options in Colorado Springs?
Yes, many places like Olde World Bagel & Deli and Panera Bread offer vegan and vegetarian choices, including plant-based spreads and fillings.
Can I order bagels for takeout or catering?
Almost every spot on this list offers takeout, and several—including Einstein Bros. Bagels and Panera Bread—also provide catering for meetings and parties.
Where can I find bagels with gluten-free options?
Selections can be limited, but Panera Bread and some local cafes occasionally offer gluten-friendly choices—call ahead to check daily availability.