Craving a bagel in Boston can feel like searching for a diamond in a sea of cobblestones. This city’s bagel scene is a bit like its neighborhoods: quirky, classic, and full of bold opinions. Finding that perfect balance of chew and crisp isn’t a myth here—if you know where to look. I’ve wandered the streets, sampled schmears, and made enough “just one more” stops to know not all bagels are created equal in Beantown.
Bagels in Boston can surprise you with their variety and craftsmanship. Whether you love a classic sesame ring or something completely new, there’s an address here waiting for your taste buds. The following list collects the best spots for a quick grab-and-go or a slow morning bite, all tested in pursuit of excellence. Get ready to see which doughy masterpieces deserve your attention next.
Where to find the best bagels in Boston, MA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Boston, MA:
- Thinking Cup
- Thinking Cup
- Thornton’s Restaurant
- Trident Booksellers & Cafe
- Clink.
- South End Buttery
- Bakey Babka
- Berkeley Perk Cafe
- Au Bon Pain
- Finagle-A-Bagel
1. Thinking Cup
Thinking Cup has the kind of cozy energy that makes you want to linger a little longer—especially with a bagel in hand. Sitting near the window with a fresh sesame bagel, I watched the city go by and understood why this place has such a loyal following.
Their bagels balance chewiness and softness, easily pairing with their rich, acclaimed Stumptown coffee. If you like a classic start, try the bagel with cream cheese; the spread is always fresh and generously layered. For something heartier, the smoked salmon bagel feels refined but unfussy.
Thinking Cup stands out for sourcing quality ingredients and crafting a menu that feels intentional. Even simple staples, like their bagels, reflect their commitment to elevating breakfast in Boston.
2. Thinking Cup
The Newbury Street location of Thinking Cup feels like a neighborhood secret, tucked among boutiques but buzzing with locals. On a recent visit, I grabbed their multigrain bagel and settled in under the warm brick walls with a coffee. There’s something about the pairing of their rich brew and a fresh, chewy bagel that just works.
Thinking Cup’s dedication to quality is apparent everywhere, from the carefully sourced coffee beans to their house-made pastries. Their bagels, especially with sun-dried tomato cream cheese, are substantial and flavorful—no skimping on freshness or portions here.
For anyone looking for a solid bagel with thoughtful toppings, this spot manages to feel welcoming yet never boring. The creativity in their flavors gives Thinking Cup’s classics a definite edge.
3. Thornton’s Restaurant
Thornton’s Restaurant feels like a neighborhood staple where breakfast happens at its own, easy pace. On slow mornings, I’ve enjoyed their toasted bagel alongside a big mug of coffee—the kind of meal that starts your day on a relaxed note.
The real draw here is reliability and comfort. Their bagels have a pleasing, classic chew and arrive toasted just right, perfect with a generous schmear of cream cheese or paired with eggs for something more filling.
This spot is known for hearty breakfast plates. If you want something satisfying, try their bagel breakfast sandwich. The mix of fresh veggies and generous eggs, tucked into a warm bagel, sums up what Thornton’s does best: simple, fresh, and always consistent.
4. Trident Booksellers & Cafe
Trident Booksellers & Cafe is a place where mornings start with good reads and even better bagels. I once spent a rainy afternoon here, coffee in one hand and a bagel in the other, flipping through a perfectly battered mystery novel. It’s comfortable, genuine, and deeply Boston.
Trident’s bagels are a dependable staple on their breakfast menu. They’re always fresh, with a pleasant outer crunch and soft middle—exactly what you need to pair with a healthy spread of cream cheese or veggie toppings.
If you’re hungry for something a bit more creative, grab their bagel breakfast sandwich with eggs and cheese. The combo of great food, strong coffee, and endless books makes Trident an easy favorite on Newbury Street.
5. Clink.
+1 617-224-4004
See Menu
Clink. is not your average spot for a morning bite. Housed within The Liberty Hotel, it delivers style and a dash of Boston history with remnants of an old jail woven into its chic design. I once settled into a gold leather chair, a bagel on my plate, and felt the unique blend of luxury and charm that defines this restaurant.
Their house-baked bagels are a cut above, served warm with high-quality spreads. For something special, try the smoked salmon bagel. The fish is delicately prepared and paired with crisp veggies, showcasing Clink.’s commitment to top-tier ingredients.
Everything here, from the airy dining room to the thoughtful presentation, feels intentional. If you want your bagel moment to come with a side of atmosphere and a bit of Boston’s character, Clink. delivers every time.
6. South End Buttery
South End Buttery is the sort of place that charms you before you even get to the food. The cozy, sunlit space always feels like a little escape, and I’ve lost track of how many weekends I’ve started at one of their tables with a freshly toasted bagel.
What sets the Buttery apart is their dedication to everyday excellence. Their bagels are lovingly made, with a golden crust and soft, tender inside. Even a simple bagel with cream cheese here tastes elevated, thanks to the quality of each ingredient.
If you’re after something more substantial, try their breakfast sandwich on a bagel. The balance of flavors and attention to detail reflect the Buttery’s approach to comfort food done right.
7. Bakey Babka
Bakey Babka is a haven for anyone who appreciates the craft of baking. The aroma of fresh bread and bagels greets you the moment you walk in—I’ve genuinely detoured my morning walks just to pick up a warm bagel here.
The shop is known for its kosher offerings and commitment to quality. Each bagel is perfectly dense and chewy, carrying the kind of homemade character that’s hard to imitate.
Order their classic bagel, lightly toasted, with a thick smear of cream cheese. The result is simple, yet delightfully satisfying, capturing the spirit of tradition in every bite. Bakey Babka stands out for giving bagels the same respect as their famous babka.
8. Berkeley Perk Cafe
Berkeley Perk Cafe feels like one of those neighborhood gems you want to keep to yourself. I first stumbled in on a sleepy Sunday, lured by the promise of a classic bagel and a hot cup of coffee. The vibe is warm, friendly, and never rushed.
This spot stands out for its consistently fresh bagels and laid-back energy. Each one arrives toasted to perfection, with just the right amount of chew. The cafe offers both traditional and creative bagel options, making it easy to find something for any mood.
If you’re in the mood for something memorable, try their veggie bagel sandwich. The combination of crisp veggies and flavorful cream cheese shows how Berkeley Perk gives simple breakfasts a personal touch.
9. Au Bon Pain
Au Bon Pain has a reputation for being reliable and easy to spot, often found just where you need a quick breakfast. I’ve stopped in countless times for a bagel fix on busy mornings, always welcomed by a display of golden, fresh options.
Their bagels offer a gentle crunch and a satisfying interior, ideal for pairing with their whipped cream cheese or a drizzle of honey. You can keep it classic or go for a bagel breakfast sandwich for something a little more filling.
What makes Au Bon Pain shine is convenience without sacrificing quality. The combination of attentive service and consistently fresh bagels makes it a dependable choice when you need a satisfying start to your day in Boston.
10. Finagle-A-Bagel
Finagle-A-Bagel is the kind of place where bagel enthusiasts feel instantly at home. My go-to move is to walk straight to the counter and order a warm, chewy everything bagel. The aroma alone is enough to brighten any morning.
The standout here is variety and customization. You get your pick from a wide selection of bagels and can build your breakfast just how you like. Every bagel is fresh, satisfying, and perfectly balanced between crunchy and doughy.
If you want something more substantial, try their classic bagel sandwich with eggs and cheese. Finagle-A-Bagel’s focus on quality and generosity means you leave full and happy every time.
More Things to Try in Boston, MA
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places to get bagels in Boston?
Boston has great options, from classic spots like Finagle-A-Bagel and Better Bagels to cozy cafes such as Thinking Cup and South End Buttery. Each offers fresh bagels with unique flavors and toppings.
Are there vegan or gluten-free bagel options in Boston?
Yes, many bakeries and cafes—including Berkeley Perk Cafe and Tatte Bakery & Cafe—offer vegan and gluten-free bagels. Always check with staff, as special options may rotate or sell out early.
Where can I find fresh, made-in-house bagels?
Spots like Bakey Babka and Levend Bagelry prioritize freshly baked, handmade bagels that highlight traditional techniques and quality ingredients.
Which bagel shops are best for breakfast sandwiches?
South End Buttery, Finagle-A-Bagel, and Pavement Coffeehouse are popular choices for hearty bagel breakfast sandwiches made with eggs, cheese, and fresh toppings.
Can I find kosher bagels in Boston?
Bakey Babka is well-known for its kosher bagels, and a few other bakeries offer kosher options as well. Just ask at the counter for details on preparation.