If you’ve ever bitten into a perfectly warm, chewy bagel with just the right crust and thought, “Where has this been all my life?”, then you’ll understand my obsession. A few years ago, I stumbled into a cozy local bakery in Peoria, Illinois, on a rainy morning, just looking for something to warm me up. What I found instead was a bagel that changed everything—lightly crisp on the outside, soft inside, and packed with flavor. Since then, I’ve been on a mission to find the best bagels in Peoria, and trust me, I’ve done the legwork so you don’t have to.
Peoria may not be the first city that comes to mind when you think of iconic bagels, but that’s what makes this journey so exciting. Hidden throughout this heartland city are artisan bakers and family-owned shops crafting unforgettable bagels—without any shortcuts or haram ingredients. Whether you’re after a classic sesame with cream cheese or a bold jalapeño cheddar, this guide will point you straight to the very best. If you’re serious about bagels, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best bagels in Peoria, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Peoria, IL:
1. Big Apple Bagels
(309) 691-4122Call
Big Apple Bagels is a delightful stop for anyone craving quality bagels in Peoria. This hidden gem, located at 3408 W Willow Knolls Dr, offers a diverse menu that goes beyond traditional bagels. You can enjoy a relaxing breakfast or brunch while savoring their freshly baked bagels paired with artisan cream cheeses.
What sets Big Apple Bagels apart is their dedication to quality. Each bagel is made from scratch daily, ensuring a chewy texture and rich flavor that’s hard to beat. I still remember my first visit, when I bit into a warm onion bagel that was perfectly toasted—it was instant love.
When you’re there, don’t miss out on the classic everything bagel topped with their famous smoked salmon cream cheese. It captures the essence of their commitment to flavor. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee and bagel or dining in, Big Apple Bagels never disappoints.
2. Einstein Bros Bagels
Located at 9126 N Lindbergh Dr, Einstein Bros Bagels is a go-to spot for anyone in Peoria searching for a casual yet satisfying bagel experience. The atmosphere is welcoming, making it perfect for grabbing a bite alone or enjoying a meal with friends.
What makes Einstein Bros stand out is their extensive menu, which features unique bagel creations and an array of toppings. The bagels are always fresh and satisfyingly chewy, showing a great commitment to quality. On my last visit, I tried their spinach and feta bagel paired with egg and cheese, and it was delightful.
For a standout experience, try the smoked salmon bagel. Topped with cream cheese, capers, and onions, it’s a menu favorite that perfectly captures their style of bold flavors. You won’t leave hungry, that’s for sure.
3. Dunkin’
Dunkin’, located at 4525 N Sterling Ave, is more than just a coffee shop; it’s a beloved institution in Peoria. This bustling spot combines the best of both worlds: comforting classics and fast service, making it a popular choice for breakfast on the go.
What makes Dunkin’ stand out is its consistent quality and convenience. The staff always greets you with a smile, and their extensive menu ensures you’ll find something to love. I still remember the first time I stopped in for a quick breakfast and was pleasantly surprised by the freshness of their bagels.
For a recommendation, try the plain bagel with cream cheese, or go bold with a spinach & cheese bagel. Both options showcase Dunkin’s commitment to delivering simple yet satisfying flavors that hit the spot any time of day.
More Things to Try in Peoria, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where can I find the best bagels in Peoria, IL?
You’ll have great options at places like Big Apple Bagels, Einstein Bros Bagels, and Dunkin’. Each spot offers unique flavors and styles, so it’s worth trying a few to see which you prefer.
2. What types of bagels are most popular?
Classic flavors such as everything, sesame, and plain remain top choices. However, many places also offer gourmet varieties like jalapeño cheddar and spinach & feta for those looking for something different.
3. Do these shops offer breakfast sandwiches?
Yes, most bagel shops in Peoria do offer breakfast sandwiches. You can customize them with your choice of bagel, eggs, cheese, and various meats to create a satisfying meal.
4. Are there gluten-free bagel options available?
Some establishments, like Dunkin’, provide gluten-free bagels, so it’s best to check with each specific shop to see their offerings.
5. Can I order bagels for catering or events?
Absolutely. Many bagel shops in Peoria offer catering services for meetings, events, and gatherings. Be sure to call ahead to discuss options and to place your order.