When it comes to finding the best bagels in Melbourne, FL, the search can feel overwhelming. With so many options scattered across town, each promising the perfect chew, crisp, and flavor, knowing where to start is half the journey. Having spent countless mornings hunting down bagels that balance a sturdy crust with a soft, doughy center, I can confidently say that Melbourne offers a surprising range of spots where bagel lovers can satisfy their cravings without compromising on quality or taste.
This guide narrows down that list to the most trustworthy and delicious bagel destinations around Melbourne. Whether you prefer your bagels traditional, spiced, or toasted with the perfect schmear, these picks stand out by delivering consistency and flavor that keep locals coming back. Read on to discover where your next bagel fix should be—each place tested and selected to ensure your mornings start right.
Where to find the best bagels in Melbourne, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Melbourne, FL:
- Bagel 13
- Bagel Joe’s
- Sun Shoppe & Cafe
- Panera Bread
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Einstein Bros. Bagels
- Panera Bread
- Best Bagels
- Bagel Joes
- Station 830
1. Bagel 13
Bagel 13 isn’t just another breakfast spot—it’s the place where mornings feel intentional. Tucked along S Babcock Street, it welcomes you with the smell of house-made bagels fresh out of the oven. I’ve stopped in during early errands, and the buzz inside always feels like the town’s awake and ready. It’s the kind of space where cold-brewed coffee served in Mason jars pairs perfectly with warm bagels that don’t crumble or disappoint.
What makes Bagel 13 stand out is its dedication to quality and creativity. The menu is built around bagels that are baked from scratch daily, and you can taste the difference. Their spicy jalapeño cheddar is bold but balanced, while the everything bagel hits all the right notes with its generous seasoning.
For a more filling bite, go for the egg-and-cheese breakfast sandwich on an asiago bagel. It’s a classic done right, holding texture and flavor without feeling heavy. Vegetarian-friendly options mean more choices without compromise.
Bagel 13 stays consistent—from flavor to service—and earns its spot as one of Melbourne’s top bagel destinations.
2. Bagel Joe’s
Bagel Joe’s is a cozy spot nestled on Lake Washington Road, known for its friendly atmosphere and reliable bagel offerings. I visited during a weekend brunch and was impressed by how quickly they serve up fresh, flavorful bagels that maintain perfect texture. The welcoming vibe makes it an ideal spot for a breakfast or lunch on the go.
What sets Bagel Joe’s apart is its attention to classic comfort. Their bagels are freshly baked and come in a variety of styles, from plain to everything, perfect for customizing your favorite toppings. The American-style menu complements the bagels well, with hearty options for any palate.
If you’re undecided, the breakfast bagel with smoked salmon and cream cheese or the breakfast sandwich on a toasted bagel are excellent choices, showcasing quality ingredients and simple yet satisfying flavors.
Overall, Bagel Joe’s offers consistency and a warm environment that makes it a standout for bagels in Melbourne, FL.
3. Sun Shoppe & Cafe
Sun Shoppe & Cafe in Melbourne offers a charming spot for breakfast and lunch, famed for its friendly service and cozy setting. During a recent visit, I appreciated how quickly the staff prepared a freshly toasted bagel topped with savory cream cheese and smoked salmon—simple yet full of flavor. It’s a place that values quality ingredients and a homemade touch.
What makes Sun Shoppe & Cafe stand out is its mix of traditional and creative options. Their bagels are fresh and versatile, perfect for customizing to your taste. You can also enjoy a hearty breakfast sandwich or a flavorful salad, all served with a warm smile.
If you want a reliable, satisfying bagel, try the classic sesame or everything bagel with your favorite toppings. It’s a reflection of their commitment to quality and comfort.
4. Panera Bread
Panera Bread in West Melbourne blends consistency with comfort, making it a favorite stop for bagel lovers seeking a dependable bite. The moment you walk in, the scent of fresh bread and the soft hum of conversation let you know you’ve entered a space that values warmth—both in food and atmosphere.
What sets this spot apart is how it manages to feel personal without being pretentious. Whether you’re working on your laptop or grabbing a bite between errands, the staff keeps things moving without rushing you out.
The standout? The Everything Bagel, toasted just enough to highlight its savory crust, served with plain or chive cream cheese. It’s not overloaded, just balanced—like Panera itself.
For a quick, satisfying meal in Melbourne, Panera delivers quality without compromise.
5. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on S Harbor City Blvd feels like the kind of place that’s always ready to greet you with a warm, no-frills breakfast. The pace is easygoing, and the staff never miss a beat—even if you walk in bleary-eyed before your first sip of coffee.
What makes this location stand out is consistency. You can count on freshly baked bagels—none of that chewy disappointment you find elsewhere. The space is modest, but the flavor isn’t.
Try the Classic Plain or Asiago Bagel with Garden Veggie shmear. It’s sharp, creamy, and satisfying without being heavy. For something heartier, go for the Avocado Toast Bagel sandwich, which shows Einstein Bros. knows how to keep things simple, yet elevated.
If you’re in Melbourne and want a dependable spot for breakfast or lunch, this one’s quietly reliable.
6. Einstein Bros. Bagels
Einstein Bros. Bagels on N Wickham Rd. delivers a steady rhythm of quality and comfort. The staff are quick, friendly, and keep the space clean and inviting. It’s the kind of spot where the coffee is hot and the bagels are always fresh.
What sets this location apart is its reliable service and well-balanced menu. Whether you’re grabbing a bite before work or settling in for a casual brunch, the experience is smooth and satisfying.
Go for the Asiago Bagel with Garden Veggie shmear—it’s tangy, creamy, and never overdone. If you’re after something more filling, the Avocado Toast Bagel sandwich hits the mark with its simple, fresh ingredients.
Einstein Bros. doesn’t try too hard. It just gets the basics right, and that’s what makes it a local favorite.
7. Panera Bread
Panera Bread at Town Center Avenue strikes the perfect balance between convenience and quality. On one of my visits, I appreciated the comfortable seating and free Wi-Fi—ideal for a quick work session paired with a satisfying bagel. The atmosphere feels welcoming without fuss.
Panera stands out by offering a menu crafted with fresh, wholesome ingredients, where you don’t have to sacrifice taste for health. Their bagels are reliably fresh, with options catering to vegetarian and gluten-free preferences.
I recommend the Everything Bagel with plain cream cheese for a classic experience. Their breakfast sandwiches, especially on an asiago or cinnamon raisin bagel, offer a great mix of flavors and textures—perfect for starting your day right.
For anyone in Melbourne seeking quality bagels with a modern twist, Panera Bread remains a dependable choice.
8. Best Bagels
Tucked along N Wickham Road, Best Bagels lives up to its name with a no-frills approach to quality. The space is modest, but the flavors are anything but. On my last visit, the aroma of fresh-baked dough hit before I even opened the door.
What sets this spot apart is its New York-style bagels, baked fresh daily and served with house-made cream cheese blends. The texture hits that sweet spot—chewy inside, crisp outside.
I’d recommend the Egg & Cheese on an Everything Bagel. It’s simple, satisfying, and showcases their commitment to freshness. Their veggie cream cheese is also a standout—light, flavorful, and generously spread.
If you’re after a classic bagel done right, Best Bagels delivers without the fuss.
9. Bagel Joes
Bagel Joe’s brings authentic New York-style bagels to the heart of Melbourne. Nestled in Lake Washington Crossing, it’s the kind of neighborhood gem where regulars are known by name and the bagels speak for themselves. On a quiet weekday morning, I dropped in and was greeted with the scent of warm dough and a counter lined with fresh options.
Their Everything Bagel with plain cream cheese is simple but deeply satisfying—chewy inside, crisp shell, with flavor that doesn’t overpower. If you’re more into breakfast builds, the Egg and Cheese on a Sesame Bagel feels thoughtfully assembled and balanced, not rushed.
The prices are modest, the service is easy-going, and the quality doesn’t waver. Bagel Joe’s makes classic bagels feel personal, which is rare these days.
10. Station 830
(321) 837-3942Call
Station 830 on New Haven Avenue is a delightful stop for bagel enthusiasts and sweet treat lovers alike. On a recent visit, I was drawn in by the inviting aroma of freshly baked bagels paired with the tempting array of pastries and coffee options. The cozy café vibe makes it a great spot to relax or grab a quick bite.
What sets Station 830 apart is its unique combination of quality bagels and a broad menu that includes espresso drinks and desserts, appealing to varied tastes. Their bagels are perfectly crafted—crispy outside and chewy inside.
I recommend trying the classic bagel with cream cheese alongside one of their signature coffee brews. For a sweeter option, their house-baked pastries pair well with the smooth espresso.
Station 830 confidently blends traditional bagel craftsmanship with a café culture that Melbourne appreciates.
More Things to Try in Melbourne, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best places to find authentic bagels in Melbourne, FL?
A: Some top spots include Bagel 13, Bagel Joe’s, and Best Bagels. These locations are known for fresh, house-made bagels with a variety of flavors.
Q: Are there vegetarian or gluten-free bagel options in Melbourne?
A: Yes, many bakeries like Panera Bread and Einstein Bros. Bagels offer vegetarian and gluten-free choices, including bagels topped with vegetables or served with gluten-free spreads.
Q: What time do bagel shops typically open in Melbourne?
A: Most places like Sun Shoppe & Cafe and Station 830 open early, around 6 or 7 a.m., to serve breakfast and morning commuters.
Q: Can I get a bagel for takeaway or delivery?
A: Absolutely. Many locations, including Panera Bread and Einstein Bros., offer takeout and online ordering options for quick pickup or delivery.
Q: What are popular bagel toppings or spreads?
A: Classic favorites include cream cheese, smoked salmon, and fresh vegetables. Many shops also offer specialty spreads like hummus or fruit preserves to customize your bagel.