Bagels in Gulf Shores, Alabama are more than just a breakfast staple. They’re a comfort food with personality, wrapped in a chewy exterior and packed with just the right amount of flavor. When you set out to find the best bagels in this beach town, you want more than just a generic list; you want real insight from someone who’s tasted their way through the crust and crumb. Sinking your teeth into a perfectly baked bagel here feels like discovering a bite of New York on the Alabama coast.
After countless mornings dedicated to testing cream cheese ratios and toasting preferences, I can confidently separate the average from the exceptional. If you crave bagels that actually taste as good as they smell, you’re in the right place. Whether you’re after a warm everything bagel with classic schmear or a seeded masterpiece with a twist, these Gulf Shores favorites will not disappoint. Curious which shops made the cut? Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best bagels in Gulf Shores, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Gulf Shores, AL:
1. Bagel Boy
(205) 275-5502Call
Bagel Boy has turned the ordinary bagel into something memorable. Tucked right off Gulf Shores Parkway, this spot has an unmistakable local vibe—think friendly greetings and that aroma of fresh dough you can practically taste before you even order.
What really sets Bagel Boy apart is its dedication to creating bagels with the right balance of chewiness and flavor. My standout visit included a toasted sesame bagel topped with velvety cream cheese—each bite delivered the kind of texture that’s hard to find outside big city bakeries.
Their classic plain, sesame, and everything bagels are all worth trying, but don’t leave without sampling their breakfast bagel sandwiches. For a true taste of Gulf Shores, order the veggie-loaded bagel; it’s fresh, filling, and never disappoints.
2. New York Bagel Cafe & Deli
(251) 974-2245Call
New York Bagel Cafe & Deli brings the unmistakable flavor of the Northeast to the Gulf Coast. Walk in and you’ll notice the steady hum of regulars who count on this place for their morning fix. The counter displays a tempting range of bagels, all baked fresh each day.
The signature New York-style bagels are the real draw here. They have the golden crust and soft, rich center that define a true classic. On my most recent visit, the whole wheat bagel with scallion cream cheese made a strong impression—simple, but perfectly executed.
If you’re feeling adventurous, try the everything bagel piled with fresh tomato and cucumber. The deli’s veggie bagel sandwiches offer a refreshing twist and highlight their eye for quality produce and flavor pairings. It feels effortless yet elevated.
More Things to Try in Gulf Shores, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best bagels in Gulf Shores, AL?
You’ll want to visit local favorites like Bagel Boy and New York Bagel Cafe & Deli. These spots consistently deliver on freshness, flavor, and variety, setting them apart from standard chain bakeries.
Are there vegetarian bagel options available?
Absolutely. Both Bagel Boy and New York Bagel Cafe & Deli offer plenty of vegetarian bagels and spreads. Veggie-packed bagel sandwiches are a local favorite at each shop.
Do these Gulf Shores bagel shops offer gluten-free options?
Choices are limited, but it’s worth calling ahead as availability can change. Traditional NY-style bagels are made with wheat flour, but some shops rotate in specialty options for those avoiding gluten.
Can I get bagels to go or order ahead?
Yes, both spots offer takeout and phone orders. For busy mornings or family breakfasts, calling ahead is a smart move to avoid waiting in line.
What makes Gulf Shores bagels unique?
Local shops take pride in freshness and quality, and you’ll often find creative twists inspired by Gulf Coast produce. Expect classic flavors with a bit of Southern hospitality baked right in.