Missing a great bagel is like skipping the sunrise—technically possible, but why would you? Fairview, NY, has quietly built a reputation for bagels that range from classic hand-rolled rounds to bold, inventive takes, all while sticking to time-honored traditions. Finding the right bagel is more than hunting for a breakfast fix—it’s about discovering the places that put care into every golden crust and chewy center.
A weekend spent exploring Fairview’s thriving bagel spots turned into a personal quest: Can you tell a shop by its everything seasoning? Does a schmear reveal a baker’s soul? This guide draws from real crumbs, real cream cheese, and small conversations over steaming coffee. If you’re looking for guidance beyond star ratings and big chains, you’re about to tap into local wisdom and the kind of bagel knowledge you only get by tasting—and sometimes wearing—poppy seeds. Dive in if you’re ready for the real Fairview bagel tour.
Where to find the best bagels in Fairview, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Fairview, NY:
- Eastdale Ave Bagels
- Bagel Bites
- New Paltz Bagel Cafe
- Rudy S Bagels Inc
- Hopewell Hot Bagels
- Empire Bagels
- Bagel Brothers of Plattekill
- The Bagel Shoppe
- Sunrise Bagel & Deli
- Blazing Bagels
1. Eastdale Ave Bagels
(845) 595-8711Call
Eastdale Ave Bagels is a local favorite that does not stick to shortcuts. Their bagels come out warm, with a crisp shell and that real chew everyone chases. Each time I stop in, there’s a steady calling of names—regulars, locals, and the staff recognizing both. It makes the shop feel like part of the neighborhood’s heartbeat.
The Everything bagel here sets the standard. Balanced spice, a hint of onion, nothing overpowers. For a genuine experience, pair it with a whipped scallion cream cheese or opt for their signature egg bagel, which is rich and pillowy. Eastdale Ave Bagels stands out for quality and a sense of place—you’ll leave feeling like you belong, bag in hand.
2. Bagel Bites
Bagel Bites is the kind of place you find by following the scent of real bagels. Once inside, the variety hits you—airy sesame, classic plain, and hearty whole wheat. Last time I visited, I watched the staff pull hot bagels from the oven and couldn’t resist grabbing a cinnamon raisin on the spot.
Their texture is what wins fans: a crisp bite that leads to soft, fresh dough inside. For a true taste of their style, try the veggie cream cheese atop a warm everything bagel. The flavor pops without feeling heavy. Bagel Bites balances quality with friendly prices, making it easy to sample a few and still keep your morning simple.
3. New Paltz Bagel Cafe
New Paltz Bagel Cafe is a place that feels like a well-kept secret, even though the line on weekends says otherwise. Every bagel is shaped by hand and baked daily, which you taste in every bite. I once spent a cold morning here, watching college students fuel up alongside locals with favorite orders recited from memory.
The spinach bagel is a surprise hit—not too grassy, just right with a smear of sun-dried tomato cream cheese. Or go for their sesame bagel, toasted, with a gentle crunch that sets it apart. The staff move quickly but never rush you, letting the atmosphere stay relaxed yet energized. New Paltz Bagel Cafe offers consistency and warmth with each bagel served.
4. Rudy S Bagels Inc
(845) 463-2182Call
Rudy S Bagels Inc catches your attention the moment you pull into their easy parking. The shop has a timeless feel, with a display case stacked high and the smell of real, hand-rolled bagels in the air. My first visit was a weekday morning, and I quickly saw why regulars return: the staff welcomes everyone, but the bagels truly shine.
The salt bagel, lightly crisp and not too salty, is a strong contender for best in the area. Add their homemade chive cream cheese for a pairing that stays memorable. For a heartier bite, the whole wheat bagel is soft and full of flavor. Rudy S Bagels Inc stands out for their friendly pace and consistent quality.
5. Hopewell Hot Bagels
Hopewell Hot Bagels is known for living up to its name—every bagel, genuinely hot from the oven, carries a fresh-baked aroma that travels right out to the parking lot. This spot has a loyal following and offers a smooth, fast pace even when crowded. Walking in, you’ll spot regulars swapping quick hellos with the staff.
The standout here is their garlic bagel, crunchy on the outside, packed with toasted garlic that never overwhelms. Spread it with their homemade plain cream cheese or go for a classic egg bagel if you prefer something soft and rich. Hopewell Hot Bagels balances that small-town spirit with expert technique, making each visit feel both easy and special.
6. Empire Bagels
Empire Bagels wakes up early and so do its customers. What sets this spot apart is the daily lineup of fresh bagels, always rotating but never missing the classics. Stopping in, I found the staff quick with a smile and even quicker with the tongs, always happy to share recommendations.
The pumpernickel bagel is worth a detour—dense, a bit sweet, and full of character, it’s even better with their signature vegetable cream cheese. If you’re feeling ambitious, try the toasted sesame bagel with a light spread for a simple, flawless start. Empire Bagels blends the efficiency of a busy deli with that special hand-crafted touch that keeps people coming back.
7. Bagel Brothers of Plattekill
(845) 728-0460Call
Bagel Brothers of Plattekill feels like an old friend—warm, quick with conversation, and always ready with a fresh batch. The first thing you notice is the pillowy texture of their bagels, soft inside with a satisfying crust. People here aren’t shy about sharing favorites, and the mood is always relaxed.
The blueberry bagel is a top pick—loaded with berries and just the right balance of sweet. Pair it with a light cream cheese for a comforting treat. Or, if you’re craving something classic, their plain bagel doesn’t disappoint. Bagel Brothers of Plattekill stands out by offering honest, high-quality bagels in an easygoing setting that welcomes all.
8. The Bagel Shoppe
The Bagel Shoppe on Beacon’s Main Street draws crowds with good reason. Every bagel is oversized and dense, with an unmistakable homemade feel that lingers long after breakfast. My visit began with the familiar shuffle of people clutching morning coffee and ended with a bag of hot sesame bagels for the ride home.
The standout is their multigrain bagel, nutty and subtly sweet, balanced by a smooth, tangy plain cream cheese. If you like an extra crunch, try it toasted. The scene is lively but never chaotic—a rhythm that keeps regulars coming back. The Bagel Shoppe’s appeal lies in their reliable variety and the way they make each customer feel like a local.
9. Sunrise Bagel & Deli
Sunrise Bagel & Deli brings a big-city bagel experience to a Kingston address. The ovens start early and the bagels come out with shiny tops and an ideal, chewy snap. The first time I dropped by, I found a line, but it moved quickly—everyone knew exactly what they wanted.
Their egg bagel is a standout: yellow, rich, and soft, perfect with a swipe of scallion cream cheese. Or opt for the everything bagel, which packs balanced flavor and a just-right crust. Sunrise Bagel & Deli mixes the efficiency of a classic deli with plenty of warmth from the staff, making each stop feel like the start of a good day.
10. Blazing Bagels
(845) 522-8897Call
Blazing Bagels lives up to its name with kettle-boiled bagels that arrive fresh and soft every morning. The process starts early—long before sunrise—so every customer gets authentic texture and true bagel flavor. Stepping inside, there’s always the comfort of warmth and the subtle excitement of choosing from a full rack.
The plain bagel is everything a classic should be: airy yet substantial, with a shiny, satisfying bite. For something more memorable, try the poppy seed bagel paired with a gentle vegetable cream cheese. Blazing Bagels stands out for sticking to traditional methods and keeping their community well-fed from the crack of dawn—it’s the spot where quality starts with the basics.
More Things to Try in Fairview, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Fairview bagels different from others?
Bagels in Fairview, NY often feature the classic New York-style qualities—crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside. Local bakeries focus on traditional kettle-boiling methods, which give their bagels a superior texture and flavor.
Are vegetarian bagel options easy to find in Fairview?
Most shops in Fairview offer a range of vegetarian bagels and cream cheese spreads, such as vegetable, scallion, and plain. Many also carry egg or whole wheat bagels for variety.
What time should I visit to get bagels at their freshest?
Early morning is best. Bakeries in Fairview start baking before sunrise, and you’ll get the freshest bagels right after opening hours.
Can I find gluten-free bagel options in Fairview?
Some shops carry gluten-free options, but selection varies. It’s a good idea to call ahead and check if it’s a must for you.
Which bagel flavor is most popular in Fairview?
The everything bagel remains a crowd-pleaser thanks to its mix of seeds and spices. Plain, sesame, and egg bagels are also staple favorites at most local spots.