Finding the best bagels in Nyack, NY is a bit like searching for hidden treasure—except the gold comes fresh from the oven and is usually topped with a generous smear of cream cheese. Strolling past the cheerful storefronts on Main Street, you’ll notice the aroma of warm dough mingling with coffee. That’s the sign you’re in the right place. I’ve spent more than a few mornings, rain or shine, zig-zagging between local favorites to grab a chewy bagel at sunrise or an everything bagel for a late afternoon pick-me-up. Each spot has its own style; some crisp up their crust just so, while others bury you in soft, fluffy folds.
There’s something special about holding a bagel still warm in its paper sleeve, whether you grew up in Rockland County or just happened to roll into town. With a list ranging from family-run bakeries to local legends with a loyal following, this guide brings together a cross-section of the most popular and beloved bagel shops in Nyack and nearby. If you’re here to find out where your new favorite breakfast lives, you’re in the right place. Stick around—you’ll want to see which shops made the cut and what makes each one worth a visit.
Where to find the best bagels in Nyack, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bagels in Nyack, NY:
- Nyack Hot Bagels
- Neftali Inc
- Dunkin’
- David’s Bagels
- New City Bagel Boys
- D’s Bagels & Brunch
- Kamp Sal Associates
- Not Just Bagels
- Martha’s West Nyack Deli
- Town Plaza Bagel Inc
1. Nyack Hot Bagels
+1 845-358-0837
Tucked off Route 59, Nyack Hot Bagels is one of those local spots where regulars greet the staff by name and the bagels disappear almost as quickly as they come out of the oven. Walk in on a Saturday morning and you’ll see a line, but it moves fast—everyone’s here for the same thing: fresh, chewy bagels and friendly service without fuss.
Their classic plain bagel, warm and just crisped on the outside, is a standout. If you crave a little more, try the sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese. It’s the perfect balance of nutty crunch and tangy smoothness.
Nyack Hot Bagels doesn’t overcomplicate things. No frills, just excellent bagels, generous portions, and reliable quality. It’s the kind of place you want in your neighborhood.
2. Neftali Inc
(845) 727-7257Call
Neftali Inc sits quietly on North Highland Ave, but once you step in, there’s an unmistakable energy—everyone seems to know this is a spot for top-tier bagels and deli fare. My first visit started with a simple order, but I left with a new favorite bagel: their pumpernickel toasted and layered with perfectly whipped chive cream cheese. It’s earthy and rich, a perfect morning boost.
There’s a steady rhythm here, with bagels crafted to be both hearty and satisfying. The everything bagel with vegetable spread—unpretentious and fresh—shows what Neftali Inc does best: keeping things classic, quality-first, and generously portioned.
This is the place for bagel lovers who crave a slice of local character along with their breakfast. You’ll want to come back, and bring a friend.
3. Dunkin’
Dunkin’ on Route 59 offers a reliable pit stop for quick bagels and coffee. It’s the spot where early risers and late commuters cross paths, grabbing a bite and a caffeine fix before heading out. I’ve ducked in here more times than I can count when my schedule demanded both speed and consistency.
The bagels are soft, fresh, and perfect for customization. I keep coming back for the multigrain bagel, lightly toasted, with plain cream cheese—it’s simple, satisfying, and always ready fast. Pair it with Dunkin’s signature coffee if you want the full experience.
While known for donuts, Dunkin’ holds its own in the bagel department with a dependable menu and cheerful service. It’s the definition of grab-and-go in Nyack.
4. David’s Bagels
David’s Bagels in Valley Cottage is a local institution, drawing crowds from Nyack and beyond with its hand-rolled, kettle-boiled bagels. During my last visit, what struck me most was the steady stream of regulars—the kind of place where folks know their order before hitting the counter. There’s a comforting energy here, as if bagels are part of the daily ritual.
Their bagels are sturdy yet soft, with a golden crust and plenty of chew. For a real treat, order the egg bagel with veggie cream cheese. The subtle egg flavor adds richness, perfect for anyone who likes a classic with a twist.
It’s easy to see why David’s Bagels is a favorite: quality ingredients, old-school methods, and friendly, efficient service. They stay busy for a reason.
5. New City Bagel Boys
New City Bagel Boys brings serious bagel game to Rockland County. My first visit was pure curiosity, but the crisp-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside bagels quickly made me a regular. There’s an impressive variety, including some creative flavors you won’t find everywhere.
The standout here is their cinnamon raisin bagel with plain cream cheese: sweet, slightly chewy, and a morning favorite. Their lunch menu goes deep, but at heart, it’s the bagels that steal the show.
Bagel Boys keeps things lively with friendly staff, speedy service, and a vibe that feels both old-school and fresh. If you want a bagel with personality and consistency, this is your spot.
6. D’s Bagels & Brunch
(845) 589-0777Call
D’s Bagels & Brunch in Congers knows how to turn a simple breakfast into something memorable. The first time I stopped by, the aroma of hot bagels made it almost impossible to choose just one. There’s a relaxed, neighborhood feel here, where people actually linger over breakfast instead of rushing out the door.
The classic salt bagel with cream cheese is a salty-savory delight, nicely balanced and never overpowering. If you’re in the mood for something heartier, the whole wheat bagel sandwiches make a satisfying, wholesome meal.
D’s Bagels & Brunch stands out for freshness and friendly, no-frills service. Whether you’re fueling up before a busy day or enjoying a weekend treat, this spot makes you want to slow down and savor every bite.
7. Kamp Sal Associates
(845) 358-0837Call
Kamp Sal Associates might sound low-key, but locals know it for its consistently fresh bagels and friendly counter service. My visit started with a plain bagel and ended with a newfound appreciation for simple, well-executed classics. There’s no fuss here—just straightforward, satisfying bagels every time.
The best choice is the classic poppy seed bagel. Bite into one and you get just the right mix of crackly bite and soft, chewy inside. Their cream cheese, always smooth and generously spread, complements every bagel perfectly.
If you prefer your bagels without extra frills but with plenty of flavor, Kamp Sal Associates fits the bill. It’s a dependable stop in West Nyack for the real bagel fan.
8. Not Just Bagels
(845) 267-8877Call
Not Just Bagels in Valley Cottage wears its name well. The first time I stopped by, I discovered a bagel spot that takes pride in tradition while offering just enough variety to keep things interesting. Each bagel is dense, chewy, and always fresh—a classic New York recipe done right.
The standout here is the onion bagel, with a golden crust and a savory bite that pairs well with plain or vegetable cream cheese. It delivers a perfect blend of crunch and flavor, making breakfast feel like the main event.
If you appreciate a bagel shop that stays true to the basics and does them exceptionally well, Not Just Bagels is the kind of place you’ll want to visit again and again.
9. Martha’s West Nyack Deli
Martha’s West Nyack Deli offers more than just deli classics—it’s a hidden gem for bagel lovers. On my last visit, the buzz of early morning regulars let me know I was in the right place. There’s a comforting, old-fashioned deli vibe as soon as you walk in the door.
The everything bagel here is a solid favorite: it’s generously coated, toasted just right, and goes perfectly with their house-made cream cheese. If you want something with extra local flair, ask for it “all the way”—cream cheese, tomato, and a dash of black pepper.
Martha’s sets itself apart with genuine hospitality and a kitchen that respects tradition. If you want a classic bagel deli experience, this spot hits the mark.
10. Town Plaza Bagel Inc
(845) 359-2330Call
Town Plaza Bagel Inc in Orangeburg is the spot where bagel cravings meet hometown comfort. I stopped in on a chilly morning, and the lively counter and wall of fresh bagels were instantly inviting. There’s a warmth in the air—both from the ovens and the staff—that makes it easy to feel like a regular, even on your first visit.
Bagels here are sturdy, slightly sweet, and have that ideal New York-style chew. The whole wheat everything bagel with light cream cheese became my go-to: hearty enough for breakfast, but never heavy. For something extra, try their breakfast bagel sandwiches—they’re filling and full of flavor.
Town Plaza Bagel Inc stands out for its quality, consistency, and the kind of friendly banter every good bagel shop needs. It’s one of those places you’ll keep coming back to.
More Things to Try in Nyack, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best bagel shops in Nyack, NY?
Some of the top spots include Nyack Hot Bagels, David’s Bagels, and Not Just Bagels. Each has its loyal fans and signature style, so trying a few is half the fun.
Are there vegan or dairy-free options at Nyack bagel shops?
Most local spots offer vegan bagels like plain or everything, and some carry dairy-free spreads. Check the menu or ask at the counter for specifics.
What makes a New York-style bagel unique?
New York-style bagels are boiled before baking, which gives them a shiny crust and a dense, chewy interior that stands out from other types.
Can I get a bagel sandwich for lunch at these shops?
Absolutely. Many offer lunch bagel sandwiches with a range of fillings, including vegetarian options and classic spreads.
Do Nyack bagel shops bake fresh daily?
Yes, freshness is the name of the game. Most local shops bake several times each day, so you’re likely grabbing a bagel that’s just come out of the oven.
Where can I find gluten-free bagels in Nyack?
Some bagel shops, like David’s Bagels, offer gluten-free bagel options. Availability may vary, so it’s smart to call ahead.